The Fire that burnt Vinit - Page 2

Well nicely written topic. You are right at every point. JL comments on Joyeeta was the worst of SRGMP. And raising issue of NE was also main reason for Vinit's and Hema's loss. And ID did commendable job by walking out and exposing the sinister design of HR and AS. If you observed just after ID walk out Debojit got highes number of vote and margin was big. At that point people realised about the HR and AS gang.

Originally posted by: prakashb44

It all started with jatin - Lilit . There were two participants from NE in the Saregama .

Out of them was jayeeta & other debu. The infamous, comment by Jatin-lLalit in one of jayeta performance , the Kotha ka gana ... , was very sad and unnecessary. Jayeta was bold & strong enough to protest on stage. This incident touched the people of NE. Accept it or not in NE you do not find any good place to learn music & there is hardly any participants from NE in any major music events of national level. People from their was listening to them seriously.

Talking about the mentor, Himesh intially was polite & Humble. He was able to get the no. one on the list of voting and being able to call back Ashiwara & Dilshad. but lately, he adopted a different style.As for Adarsh from the begining was not being able to take on people heart. His low marking to oppenent gharanas was well noticed by the public. many a times he showed his anger in opponent mentor marking . ID have the advantage of being continuously providing lasting hits for the last few years. However, all the mentors failed in hiding the lust for the title. Adarsh & Himesh completely failed to hide their lust.

Talking about Vinit. He is a good singer, probably initially the best. But, as the time moves forward his concentration drifts to other strategies. Initially his hair style change , Topi comes , love story , walk out etc. this were all noticed by the public. In his love story, HR missed one basic conclusion, the climax . it should have come before the grand finale. Any story, to be a hit needs a very positive climax . Public was very confused with the story, the subject was unclear. Though initially, it was being able to create lot of atmosphere, lately the motive became very clear. Vinit also co-operate in popularising the story like his comment - Sir please please etc to make the public believe his romance. His image got a stain. 10 out of 10 to most of his song was also not necessary. 10 is only given to someone who is very perfect . This was over marking.

Secondly, he have not put his mind in the Walk out. I believe it was a trap from Adarsh & Himani . At that stage adarsh have two participants, HR one and ID one . He know for sure that this time one of his beta will be out. Vote trend shows that NE have started voting for their brother. The strategy is to eliminate vinit. Also, vinit was not being able to maintain the top slot in the voting. So, if vinit image can some how be darken a little, Hemu chance of going to top 2 is sure. So he use Himani to trap Vinit. HR was very slow in reacting & over reacted. Himani started by saying that we 3 are quiting & Vinit falls on Himani word & become the spoke person. He missed the Bus. At that time he got 2nd position as far as result was announced, and Shaan called him on stage. A lady burst 'It is India Voice not NE' and HR supporting her by shouting 'Oihi to baat ha' makes vinit a scapegoat. Adarsh, successfully blackens Vinit & HR Image . Vinit losses his innocent appeal. Otherwise he would have got another 10 to 15 lakhs more vote in the final and Debo a little less voting from NE. Every one vote , one can get from his oppenent camp makes a difference of 2. Adarsh, however have made some basic mistakes in his math. He make a flop of himself. Vinit made the mistake. His innocence lost. One should know the reality in a reality show. the public meter depends on lot of factors and each has its own weight.

As for Debojit, he was improving episode after episode. It was well noticed that his improvement, have not got him any positive marking. Adarsh attitude was well known. Himesh should have given some positve marking. Lots of people were clear, what the two mentors are cooking. HR giving 10 out of 10 to Debo with lots of dialogue was well noticed. With these , his 'Lets Rock' image was have taken a left turn in middle aged Indian mind .

As for determined NE people , comment to Joyeeta was well in their mind. The lady yelling was taken as " NE is not part of India' and HR supporting the lady creates hates for Vinit. The low marking to Debo was taken very seriously when he is singing very good and 10 out 10 to Vinit was overmarking in the mind of public. The belief was engraved and establish by Ismail darbar walk out. The NE people were determined to vote.

As far as zee TV had done, they should not have shown the vote count from time to time. It gave enough opportunity to establish one likes.

Shaan the best anchor. He was so neutral. His marking to both the finalist at 9 out of 10 was perfect.

The show is over, let us accept the result, and wish and hope that Debojit will try to live up with Indias acceptation.

Thank you all. Both were the best.

------ I am in North east last 7 days ------

prakash I would like to add one more point on vinit.ID once appreciated him by giving a 50 rupees note as he was impressed with his performance but on the day of walkout drama ID asked asked him why u r doing like this ,do u feel that debo sing bad for which vinit replied did I mention his name which made the public angry for his reply to ID. it is further added that vinit was giving definition about the music to ID was irritatating, all these incidents back fired him more over ID said to vinit u r a good singer, u r a good challenger who can give a tough fight even now for which vinit has no reply. had he taken not part in the walkout,there was chances to win.

Thank you Mr Prakash for putting forward you view. I truely agree with you. In a reality show, you have to take care of lots of factor. Though he is a good singer, he truely missed to convince the middle aged Indian mind. As for Himesh, he is a new comer with lots of ambition, but one should remember that in India honesty counts more.

As far as Nihira is concerned, I honestly finds her very good. However, she needs to change her attitude a little.

Attitude counts and Vinit and Nihira fails to show it.

As for Vinit falling to himani's Sajish, I would say that it is fault on Himesh part. He have not taken care of all the possibility one may face during such a competion.

AS for Debojit he is the best between the two. He have varieties. Wish him good luck for the future.

As for determined NE people, I thanks them from my heart for the unity shown by them for Debojit.

For the well wishers of Vinit, You have not tried very Hard

Well said, Mr. Prakash!! Debo's win is a truimph of justice against all odds. I am amazed at how cool and composed Debo was through out those trying moments of brickbats from other mentors, walkout by fellow contestants and constant jibes of making through due to NE votes. I hope Debo rises and shines in life while maintaining his humility and posie intact.

Originally posted by: rage797

hand pump ko himesh ne jyaada pump kar ke uska handle kharaab kar diya. excess of every thing is bad.

👏 Too Good...very well said

Originally posted by: Shantibai

That ""lady"(sic???) should be behind bars for what she did that day (while getting prompted by AS and HR chamchaas on the cell phone if you recall!!??)

.

Shanti,

Wonder what that frustrated aunty (I don't want to call her a 'lady') must be thinking about the most stupidest comment anyone can make....so much of venom she had when she yelled 'india ki voice not assam ki voice'....some values these people have...haan????

Exactly, fully agree

Originally posted by: prakashb44

It all started with jatin - Lilit . There were two participants from NE in the Saregama .

Out of them was jayeeta & other debu. The infamous, comment by Jatin-lLalit in one of jayeta performance , the Kotha ka gana ... , was very sad and unnecessary. Jayeta was bold & strong enough to protest on stage. This incident touched the people of NE.Accept it or not inNEyou do not find any good place to learn music &there is hardly any participants from NE in any major music events of national level.People from their was listening to them seriously.

Talking about the mentor, Himesh intially was polite & Humble. He was able to get the no. one on the list of voting and being able to call back Ashiwara & Dilshad. but lately, he adopted a different style.As for Adarsh from the begining was not being able to take on people heart. His low marking to oppenent gharanas was well noticed by the public. many a times he showed his anger in opponent mentor marking . ID have the advantage of being continuously providing lasting hits for the last few years. However, all the mentors failed in hiding the lust for the title. Adarsh & Himesh completely failedto hide their lust.

Talking about Vinit. He is a good singer, probablyinitially the best. But, as the time moves forward his concentrationdrifts to other strategies. Initially his hair style change , Topi comes , love story , walk out etc. this were all noticed by the public.In his love story, HR missed one basic conclusion, the climax . it should have come before the grand finale.Any story,to be a hit needs a verypositive climax .Public was very confused with the story, the subject was unclear.Thoughinitially, it was being able to create lot of atmosphere, lately the motive became very clear.Vinit also co-operate in popularising the story like his comment - Sir please please etc to make the public believe his romance. His image got a stain. 10 out of 10 to most of his song was also not necessary. 10 isonly given to someone who is very perfect.This was over marking.

Secondly, he have not put his mind in the Walk out. I believe it was a trap from Adarsh & Himani . At that stage adarsh have two participants, HR one and ID one . He know for sure that this time one of his beta will be out. Vote trend shows that NE have started voting for their brother. The strategy is to eliminate vinit. Also, vinit was not being able to maintain the top slot in the voting. So, if vinit image can some how be darken a little, Hemu chance of going to top 2 is sure. So he use Himani to trap Vinit. HR was very slow in reacting & over reacted. Himani started by saying that we 3 are quiting & Vinit falls on Himani word & become the spoke person.He missed the Bus. At that time he got 2nd position as far as result was announced, and Shaan called him on stage. A lady burst 'It is India Voice not NE' and HR supporting her by shouting 'Oihi to baat ha' makes vinit a scapegoat. Adarsh, successfully blackens Vinit& HR Image .Vinit losses his innocent appeal. Otherwise he would have got another 10 to 15 lakhs more vote in the final and Debo a little less voting from NE. Every one vote , one can get from his oppenent camp makes a difference of 2. Adarsh, however have made some basic mistakes in his math. He make a flop of himself. Vinit made the mistake. His innocence lost. One should know the reality in a reality show. the public meter depends on lot of factors and each has its own weight.

As for Debojit, he was improving episode after episode. It was well noticed that his improvement, have not got him any positive marking. Adarsh attitude was well known. Himesh should have given some positve marking. Lots of people were clear, what the two mentors are cooking. HR giving 10 out of 10 to Debo with lots of dialogue was well noticed. With these , his'Lets Rock' image was have taken a left turn in middle aged Indian mind .

As for determined NE people , comment to Joyeeta was well in their mind. The lady yelling was taken as " NE is not part of India' and HR supporting the lady creates hates for Vinit. The low marking to Debo was taken very seriously when he is singing very good and 10 out 10 to Vinit was overmarking in the mind of public. The belief was engraved and establish by Ismail darbar walk out. The NE people were determined to vote.

As far as zee TV had done, they should not have shown the vote count from time to time. It gave enough opportunity to establish one likes.

Shaan the best anchor. He was so neutral. His marking to both the finalist at 9 out of 10 was perfect.

The show is over, let us accept the result, andwish and hope that Debojit will try to live up with Indias acceptation.

Thank you all.Both were the best.

------ Iam in North east last 7 days ------

Originally posted by: Shantibai

Binita Singhania lost because his supporters could not send SMS properly They are all english challenged and grammatically so deficient that they should join my Rehab meant specially for such invalids 😉😉😉

SHANTIBAI,TUM SA KAYE HO NAA 😛 !!!
HOPE MY MARATHI IS RIGHT.
I HEARD SHAAN SAYING THAT TO MY FAVOURITE-NIHIRA JOSHI.