Salman Khan behind bars - breaking news ! - Page 9

Originally posted by: seema_17

well... bot are regarding the killing of animals is it not? ofcourse from my perspective i wouldn't blame sallu just yet becuz i myself have committed the crime of killing thru consuming meat. ofcourse many people r saying that we kill animals for food so thats a legitimate reason, but do we not have an alternative? r we dependant of meat alone, that justifies our killing?

I'm talking about the law, Seema ji. Killing of animals that are on endangered list is a crime and from all accounts, look like Salman has committed that crime...
Eating meat is not a crime...

Originally posted by: N Sinha

People might not beleive, but God has finally listened.
I wrote a stream of letters after he killed blackbugs in Jodhpur , right from DJ Jodhpur to many people including Maneka Gandhi, in fact she replied me back immediately, requesting them to yield pressure to put him behind bars for many years.

Justice should be same for all, what about other who were involved and aquitted respectfully. Is it not selective justice? I beleive in justice and everybody should follow laws of the land, but law should treat everybody equally. To me all should have been put behind bar from Salman to Satish Shah to Saif Ali khan to even herions who were involved.

And how is thosss in any way related to Saregamapa. Did like Vinit or Hr, or ID, or Debu, OF GS responsible for this or in any way invovled in this act. I DON'T THINK SO. (maybe HR 😆 ), but still...
Ha, Dick Cheney shot someone. lol lol lol lol
So, please give me the answer to the question ( first sentence) 😉

Originally posted by: riddler100

I'm talking about the law, Seema ji. Killing of animals that are on endangered list is a crime and from all accounts, look like Salman has committed that crime...
Eating meat is not a crime...

well yes the law shld be followed. but i was giving my point-of-view.

my point-of-view does not need to agree with the law. whether eating meat is a crime or not is subjective opinion. ofcourse it is not a crime according to law

Originally posted by: srianne

Do you know how people(atleast Hindus) in most Indian villages catch a chicken to make a non-veg dish that particular day? - the exact same way you had mentioned. So, why don't we charge all of them?.

Because chicken is not an endangered species in India.

Originally posted by: srianne

...there you go, one of the many points I was trying to make. I agree fm_qazi ji. 😊

thank you qazi ji,

that is the point i wanted to make but i got all muddled up 😛

he put it down so concisely didn't he srianne?? 😊

Originally posted by: MrspetloverUS

Fm_qazi,

Are yaar Ek din aapka aur hamara mind bhi mila tha jis din aapne Hema ka aakhri gana "Nahi Samney" suna aur uspar khush ho gaye the. For a minute though 😉. Yaad hai ki nahi??? 😕

Haan haan yaad hai... woh to main aaj bhi kahta last two songs sang by hema was mindblowing( not in HR word).

I had this comment typed up in my first page reply to Jemsji, but let go of it b'cos I thought I might be bringing SRGMP unrelated discussion, but now since all of you all already done that, let me do "bahti ganga me haath dhona"

There is another point of View on this whole case, Which I think you folks are ignoring

A person who is a repeat offender of various crimes, if caught under any crime then he/she should be prosecuted to the highest level(think Capone and Untouchables).

Look I am no great lovers of animal(I myself am one, and I subject myself/my family to C2005, so I have no right to complain about animal cruelty) Jokes aside
Salman and various such dignitaries are caught by some law every other year, Breaking some laws are unpardonable, they get away(you know how). One/any law is able to put them behind bars I say

"Hey prabhu, teri leela ajab, kaise Indian Penal code law banvaya tune"

Am I hypocritical yes, BITE ME

I have nothing against SK as a film actor, I sometimes even like some of his films. But if some film personality flaunts relationship with people who tried to blow up my city, I by hook or crook want that person want him/her behind bars

For me, SRGMP C2005 lost any respectability when they brought on SK on the show and played the jokes of his being "Bhai".

Just my (slanted)POV, you can have one too

Originally posted by: seema_17

she is not encouraging his behaviour respectji... we are just mere spectators. what is wrong according to u might be right according to someone else. the main point of discussion was... if salman was sentenced why were the others let go?

Seemaji - without wanting to take away from the praise that others have heaped on you regarding your "debating prowess" - I would like to make a comment. Seems like you are inter-mingling the issues of legalese with issues on ethics and morality. This - to me is rather dangerous Seemaji.

'Cos - taking a step back - then you would never agree to convict any rapist or a murderer. 'cos what is wrong in someones' eyes is right in others'. And they have their own reasons for doing so. Maybe there were exonerating circumstances !?!?!

On grounds of ethics and morality - we are all guilty of some crime or the other Seemaji - so who are we to cast the first stone????

Whereas - if you see it from a "purely" legal perspective - then the fog lifts from our eyes Seemaji.

I think respect123 ji actually has put this very well (way better that I could...)