Your opinion on music please.....

see mink, no one answers you or post any replies when you are talking logic. Most members want to see aggresive statements so they can scream at the other person. they want juicy stuff.plus i think they are her to pass time. on the other day, this one member starte dtopic with F..K the handpump...finally he PM me and tole me that he was having fun because he was bored. I have started topics like yours as well, but no one cares.
they go to sleep reading topics like these zzzzzzzzzzzz 😆

Hi DF, Thanks for replying. I guess, all the objective people did not like this subjective statement! See Gajji knows what sells 😉 so always creates drama on the sets of Sa re ga ma pa. Art needs diversity, tolerance, debate and criticism to live !😉 😆 Next time will keep this in mind & post here. 😃

You may be right in a philosophical way, but does that mean anyone who participates can feel that he sings well.
I dontknow how familiar you are with American Idol, William Hung was one of the contestants on that, who sang so badly, but it was marketed and he made an album. Now how does that fit in good music? I can understand that people like different kinds of music, but theyshould be pleasing to hear, and ofcourse when it is acontest, obviously you want the best to win, otherwise what is the need for a competition.
I am a carnatic singer, but I dont necessarily like all carnatic singers and why is it that few are more popular. There is a certain aspect that touches your heart which does not happen with every singer and we expect them to do something different andmore than what an average person can sing or do.. So when majority of publiclike it they become famous. But that has not been in the case of recent reality music shows. It is a lot of drama, hype and not a real talent show,but just entertainment. Thats my thought

👏

You are right and actually there might be a difference in opinion about Debo's and Vinit's singing or infact any of the SRGMP singers because they are all good singers.


To autmother: In the same way I wonder how can people like Qazi and Ravi???? 😕 Anyone with music sense can say that their singing ability is the lowest among others.

Originally posted by: sunsha

Music is not SUBJECTIVE, so long as you know the mathematics of music.
The moment you say music is subjective,just goes to show you dont know the ABC of music.

Either you sing it right or wrong, and therez no 2 ways about it.

VINIT is a better singer than Debo in all aspects ..and this statement is an OBJECTIVE statement without imposing it on anyone else. Afterall, I cant impose my OBJECTIVITY on a SUBJECTIVE person, a futile excercise as was on FG. 🤢

WoW Sunsha the great or shd I say Shenshah of music🤢 Rocking Gurudev😉😆 Again your opinions are stated as facts! So you are accusing me of being "soulless droids" or whatever. Agreed, I may not be a perfect spectrum analyzers or may not have "golden ears" like you but I am a music lover/ buff & will remain that all my life. There is no aesthetic judgement which can make a rightful claim on everyone's assent.

Looks like you intend to remove all possible bias from human subjective judgements and opinions😉. The brain has two sides, intuitive/emotional (right brain) and logical/rational (left brain) and I think that you are paying far too much emphasis to the "left brain". And balancing things out a little won't cause an instant, irrevocable descent into subjectivity, either. 😃