challenge to vinit lovers - Page 4

Originally posted by: mojazwal

why not? are they competing for best impersonator award? a good singer who gets to be called "india ki voice" should be able to bring something unique to his or her performance rather than just copying someone else's singing to a tee.

depends on india ki voice age jaake kya karegi...

popstar ya playback singer in bollywood

The following are rational reasons why vineet do not deserve to be a winner versus others:

1. firstly he is copy cat and lacks his own voice which is nether melodous nor has any sur and tal.

2. India Voice cannot be of mimicry artists it should original like nehera,himanai,hema, debo.

3. Above all HR hiping was toooooooooooooo much and irritating everyone with his wicked plans of love,topiwala,handpump, kya yaar sangeet ka show hai ya galli ka chillar mela.

4. Votes have been manupulated to ensure HR is kept happy and his Shantha bai chela wins the flat so that both can live happily thereafter.

do anyone still think vineet should win if so they are equally crazy like HR.

Everyone should understand the game is over and the winners are no more in sa re ga ma pa its reverse engineering, the battle is between two loosers and the judgement would be who is the ultimate failure vineet or debu.

Originally posted by: Mona59

The following are rational reasons why vineet do not deserve to be a winner versus others:

1. firstly he is copy cat and lacks his own voice which is nether melodous nor has any sur and tal.

2. India Voice cannot be of mimicry artists it should original like nehera,himanai,hema, debo.

3. Above all HR hiping was toooooooooooooo much and irritating everyone with his wicked plans of love,topiwala,handpump, kya yaar sangeet ka show hai ya galli ka chillar mela.

4. Votes have been manupulated to ensure HR is kept happy and his Shantha bai chela wins the flat so that both can live happily thereafter.

do anyone still think vineet should win if so they are equally crazy like HR.

Everyone should understand the game is over and the winners are no more in sa re ga ma pa its reverse engineering, the battle is between two loosers and the judgement would be who is the ultimate failure vineet or debu.

be tolerant...dont call ppl carzy like hr only cause the have their own opinion about the contestant..and dont share ur point of view...

as far as voting system is concerned than i have to say...the system is not correct...

cause india ki voice should be voted by india and not by ones hometown..

so frm the starting on..they should have said that hometown votes dont count... like they do in eurovision...

I am not sure I am a fan, but here are some of the reasons why Vinit is more appealing than Debo.
1) Vinit sings with feeling and leaves an impression of wanting to listen to him again. Debo sounds superficial and is forgettable. He is pleasant.

2) Vinit is young, has not lost his kiddish voice, but has the best potential to go far with some training. Debojot will soon fade.(atleast for me)

3. Debo does not have much texture to his voice and can sing certain kinds of songs very well, but Vinit can sing a range of songs and exhibits a range of texture and emotions in his voice.

We can have Vineet if we loose Sonu Nigam but Debo is Debo and he does not copy anybody. If you notice that whwnever Vinit is singing in hgh tones, he keeps the mike away from his ugly face so that we cannot hear dhechu dhechu. With Debo, it is great

vinit's singing, esp. on the really high notes, often comes across more as senseless screaming (rather than skillful use of such an element) ... vinit can sing, but he cannot sing well... he is a talentless hack

Originally posted by: mojazwal

vinit's singing, esp. on the really high notes, often comes across more as senseless screaming (rather than skillful use of such an element) ... vinit can sing, but he cannot sing well... he is a talentless hack

well the same feeling concerning senseless screaming i had with debojit...

debojit should be good as a popsinger

and vinit is good for playback in bollywoodmovies...

Originally posted by: ssabinee

as far as voting system is concerned than i have to say...the system is not correct...

cause india ki voice should be voted by india and not by ones hometown..

so frm the starting on..they should have said that hometown votes dont count... like they do in eurovision...

india ki voice means all of india counts. not just one so-called neutral zone. that is both lame and absurd. each zone, area, or whatever needs to put up (in terms of voters) or shut up. this is a popularity contest, not scientific research. there is no fair or impartial way to decide "who is the best" ... if you do not want to watch a popularity contest, then do not watch srgmp

Originally posted by: mojazwal

india ki voice means all of india counts. not just one so-called neutral zone. that is both lame and absurd. each zone, area, or whatever needs to put up (in terms of voters) or shut up. this is a popularity contest, not scientific research. there is no fair or impartial way to decide "who is the best" ... if you do not want to watch a popularity contest, then do not watch srgmp

hahaha....chill yaar.....

i just told u the way we have it overhere...

aur waise bhi we r all subjectiv...

cause the one and only who can decide wether they r good or not...are the mentors...

oh i can chill....but i wonder why no one pointed out the futility of the voting when nihira was eliminated. no one talked about "india ki voice" then.

oh no, mentors cannot decide anything. not with mentors like himesh and aadesh .... they do not judge based on talent, they judge based on their own egos.