!! EXCLUSIVE UPDATES - 9th Feb 2006 !! - Page 8

Two points to make:
1.Shaan understands HR crookedness to core(Remember HR suppressed Shaan's justification about which zones to count as neutral for Debo and Hemu in previous episode).After SS said he wanted to give 11 points to Vinit,Shaan very cleverly took the chance and requested Pritam to say something more for Debo and then Pritam commented that Debo got the attitude required for the song-Halka halka sa.... which he very much admire).

2.Shaan very cleverly mentioned that all songs today are sung by Sonu.This way he praised Sonu as well as made a point that today all songs were of Sonu and since we have seen that Vinit is not at all versatile and only sings in Sonu-Rafi genre,Shaan wanted to tell the public that today even though Vinit had advantage because all songs were Sonu's but he could not beat Debu by that much extent but only to a minimal extent of 1 point overall)

What do you say friends?

Both DEBOJIT and VINIT were totally equal in yesterday's show , VINIT being slightly better in the first song and DEBOJIT being better in the third . VINIT made a mistake in the second song when he lost it in one of the lower notes. You could tell that by the fact that ID was listening to his KASTO MAZZA with his eyes closed . When VINIT made that mistake , ID contracted his eyebrows in a funny manner to show that there was a mistake . In the third song I would say that DEBOJIT was better than VINIT . So altogether , both were almost neck and neck .BUT , the benefit of the doubt goes to DEBOJIT considering the fact that the ball was in VINIT's court ( All were songs of SONU NIGAM ). DEBOJIT was just AWESOME . He proved what a versatile singer he is . Hat's off to you DEBOJIT 👏

VOTE FOR DEBOJIT

AR Datta,
I disagree with you... I'l put it this way..
Shaan has been a very good comperer, and a fine thread to keep everybody on the platform & outside the platform in harmony. He has at many times did a balancing act. On 9th since SS gave 11 out of 10 to Vinit, Shaan was trying to Balance Debo's side by requesting Pritam to tell something more about Debo. I dont feel that Shaan did it so to overcome the crookdness of HR. Secondly, Shann is an upcoming singer climbing the steps of success & I feel that Sonu Nigam has always been his Idol. That's how he took over SRGMP after Sonu Nigam left. He always had a lot of praise for Sonu Nigam, and that spelt out in y'days episode also. It has nothing to do with advantage Vinit or anything like that for that matter.
It is rubbish to think that Zee TV a/w GS have decided to make vinit as the winner & so everything is being organised in that way. If this was the case then he would have edited the sequence in which HR is guiding Vinit what to tell when asking for votes (after completion of Debo). Did you notice that when Vinit was asking for votes ID immly whispered somethign in SM's ears. What do u think he might hv whispered. GS is trying to bring out the Drama & the level of Enthusiasm & Energy in the Mentors & Judges & everybody in this show. Ultimately GS wants to be a winner !!!
Kamath

Originally posted by: ardatta

Two points to make:
1.Shaan understands HR crookedness to core(Remember HR suppressed Shaan's justification about which zones to count as neutral for Debo and Hemu in previous episode).After SS said he wanted to give 11 points to Vinit,Shaan very cleverly took the chance and requested Pritam to say something more for Debo and then Pritam commented that Debo got the attitude required for the song-Halka halka sa.... which he very much admire).

2.Shaan very cleverly mentioned that all songs today are sung by Sonu.This way he praised Sonu as well as made a point that today all songs were of Sonu and since we have seen that Vinit is not at all versatile and only sings in Sonu-Rafi genre,Shaan wanted to tell the public that today even though Vinit had advantage because all songs were Sonu's but he could not beat Debu by that much extent but only to a minimal extent of 1 point overall)

What do you say friends?

you r right..i just watch the video..and the update was not correctly posted by uselogic..the praise debojit got not mentioned..seems intenally to me...shaan is very fair 4 all contestant...it's good that he highlighted the points...hr has no manners..he didn't let anybody speak..sometime when debojit singing or saying anything or somebody else passing good comment for debojit..look at his face..seems so jealous to me.. i remember THESE 2 HAD DIRECT ENTRY FM SRGMP REGULAR PROGRAMME..AND VINIT WAS THE ONE FORGET THE SONG ON THE STAGE AND STARTED CRYING AND THEN HE SING IT AGAIN....AND DEBOJIT WAS THE FIRST WINNER...EARLIER EVERY MENTOR WANT DEBO TO JOIN THEIR GHARANA..

Originally posted by: kamleshk

I just posted the link to VIDEO.. download and see today 😉

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/topic/201513

Thanks, but when I clicked on the link I got this msg.

"Sorry, only members with sufficient permission can access this page."

Originally posted by: MONICA0819

you r right..i just watch the video..and the update was not correctly posted by uselogic..the praise debojit got not mentioned..seems intenally to me...shaan is very fair 4 all contestant...it's good that he highlighted the points...hr has no manners..he didn't let anybody speak..sometime when debojit singing or saying anything or somebody else passing good comment for debojit..look at his face..seems so jealous to me.. i remember THESE 2 HAD DIRECT ENTRY FM SRGMP REGULAR PROGRAMME..AND VINIT WAS THE ONE FORGET THE SONG ON THE STAGE AND STARTED CRYING AND THEN HE SING IT AGAIN....AND DEBOJIT WAS THE FIRST WINNER...EARLIER EVERY MENTOR WANT DEBO TO JOIN THEIR GHARANA..

I would like to flashback certain things....

1. Debo is in ID's Gharana. When the Participants were grouped into Gharanas, first the Mentors had the choice. ID got the first chance to select his fav. & who did ID select.. Remember.. He selected Niladri !! Not Debo. (U r saying that every mentor wanted Debo to join them !!!)

2. Some of the very first few episodes I missed.. But after the participants were grouped into Gharanas, I'v watched all the episodes. I would like to say here that Vinit is the only person who has right from the begining till now got thru.. Green card !! Never was he in the yellow zone or in the bottom three zones.. Every other participant (including Hema & Nihira..) before their elimination have either been in the Yellow Zone or the Bottom Three !! That also speaks about Vinit's Performance Consistency.... Shouldn't we appreciate that !!!!

Kamath

One thing i want to say
Vinit was awesome in all the three songs..NO CHILDISH VOICE..he has been very consistent..GOd Bless Him
And debu was also very good in Piyu bole 😊

Originally posted by: ds_kamath123

I would like to flashback certain things....

1. Debo is in ID's Gharana. When the Participants were grouped into Gharanas, first the Mentors had the choice. ID got the first chance to select his fav. & who did ID select.. Remember.. He selected Niladri !! Not Debo. (U r saying that every mentor wanted Debo to join them !!!)

2. Some of the very first few episodes I missed.. But after the participants were grouped into Gharanas, I'v watched all the episodes. I would like to say here that Vinit is the only person who has right from the begining till now got thru.. Green card !! Never was he in the yellow zone or in the bottom three zones.. Every other participant (including Hema & Nihira..) before their elimination have either been in the Yellow Zone or the Bottom Three !! That also speaks about Vinit's Performance Consistency.... Shouldn't we appreciate that !!!!

Kamath

One mor thing !!! ID used to call Debo as Tension Kumar !!!! Remember.

After Debo's Hamma Hamma & ID's chumma, did ID started putting hopes on Debo. ID had max hopes from Niladri, Nihira, Twinkle & lastly Debo in the earlier stages of the competition.

Whereas right from the begining HR has been very optimistic about Vinit.. later on he started calling him his one man army !!!! Vinit has stuck to his task quite appreciably... isn't that applorable .

Kamath

Debu wa tension kumar and look where he is now. This shows improvement in him. Wat abt Vinit? Fter getting all green cards he is forgetting his lines now. We judge them for their present perfomance not past and Debo is better now than vinit.
If Vinit wins coz of HR"s tactics i would say SHAME ON ALL OF US for letting HR misguide us all n make fool of us. Hemu or Nihira should have been winner but since they are gone thanks to dirty politics of HR. Ihave been saying allalong that if Vinit loses it would be coz of HR not coz Debo sings better or NE votes.
HR is a fulltime jerk who cant even say good abt other singers even when they sing really good. SHAME ON HR. Hope next year he isnt menotr coz if he is i will not watch saregamap

shaand himself sang "naam gum jayega" ..looks like he was nervous...he said tomorrow the guest singers will be Kunal, shreya and sunidhi....i am not STILL SURE whether the results will be declared tomorrow or it wil be extended..lets wait till tomorrow..

well keeping aside all the arguments today perofrmance wise, i thought VINIT was better than DEBO.. my honest opinion... my request to VINIT..as i have said before , thanks HR for all his support but leave him and join ID .....it is like drugs, it feels so good initially but internal it will make you hollow...

Dear All,

Zee is scheduling the Grand Finale on 24-Feb-2006 from 9:00 PM onwards which was LIVE TELECAST from Mumbai.