Here's why there are no judges - Page 2

Shw was very articulate, confident...definitely a lot of gray cells

Originally posted by: rare2005

even priyanka chopra made some knowledgeable comments (i use word "even" because i didn't expect her to comment so well)

Well, she sang here in NY and did well. Sang a medley. So I was not surprised

Originally posted by: raghav64

Well, she sang here in NY and did well. Sang a medley. So I was not surprised

and she was very composed when she commented as opposed to ayesh takia (i don't mean to make any derogatory comments on ayesha, but just an observation)

Originally posted by: raghav64

Well, she sang here in NY and did well. Sang a medley. So I was not surprised

Would love to hear her.

Everybody entitled to their opinion

I don't understand this rigging allegations. 2 simple questions WHY and HOW.
There is nothing wrong in getting any person as a guest and by the way Ayesha was there to plug Ghai's movie and she was supposed to be there with Mallika Sherawat.
About Ayesha's comments I think she represented and articulated well attitudes of millions of watchers/listeners and not the real and psedo-musicmaster population here on the forum and out there in the world. I think the show is fantastic and caliber of singing is much higher than any other show on the tube in India. Of course IMHO.

Most of the guests have been jokes. They were not there as judges but at public figures present to promote their own work.
Sanjay Leela Bhansali, Kunal, Priyanka, Tabu and Subashji were best of the guests. If only we'd had more like them!