Two Interviews: ID n HR

Thought of sharing two interviews which i saw today..

HR's Interview on Current Bollywood's Aaj Ki Dhun:

-> He has a current bank of 1000 tunes.. Can you imagine that? he composes three tunes each day...now what to say is it good.can you expect quality songs from him? No way...he has a bank of 1000 tunes , which means he has that many in the kitty.but guess i think, if you compose three tunes a day then i am sorry you are not CREATING tunes but MANUFACTURING tunes...as long as we are getting 1000 stupids films a day , people like hr will keep on manufacturing 1000 tunes for us...

-> He says that in order to succeed , you need to be versatile and hit sixers every day.( looks like we have heard the sixer thing some where).. he says i give all type of music , like contemprary, western and classical..Can any one tell me , which song of him was classical? I dont know how long can he be successful by telling all these shit?

-> He will sing exclusivley. Thank god, the more exclusive he becomes in his singing , the better for us.. Atleast we can listen to his howling exclusively.

-> He want to reach out to the whole world? oh my god, now whatever respect world had for indian music , is now going to go for a toss.

-> He says that , you have to come up with something so that people remember you, otherwise withing 6 months people will forget you..guys did we forget salil choudhary,anil biswas, naushad, roshan, madan mohan, roshan, sdb,rdb, LP and the list goes on...NO NO definitely not...did we forget ID, JL, ARR..jsut because they are not releasing something in every three months...looks like he should be in the field for advertising..are we selling colgate, pepsi, that we should do this..come on guys we are creating MUSIC.. please dont commercialise MUSIC....

ID's Interview on ZOOM TV:

poor chap.he should have got some good movies..but as i mentioned in one of my post in reply to N Sinha's post..today the music will be driven solely by the genre of movies released in coming times..as long as we have movies like Aksar, Jawani Diwani,Shaadi se Pehele and many others....people like JL, ID will be jobless.. i am sorry but we as a audience has failed you..there is no body to listen to good music and soon kishore and rafi DUDES wil remembered through their remix versions..dont get suprised when "badan pe sitare lapete hue", will be remebered as sung by Harry Anand , rafi chap would be remembered as somebody who actually dubbed it so that harry dude can sing for it...

He was asked , why did he go out of SRGMP . he said because he thought nihira is the real winner and he was very depressed when she was voted out from last 5..he said , he has high respect for Gj,,he could have sued him , for leaving the show..he said he came back becasue of Gj and he want to make sure that that injsutice is not done to anyone else..when asked , was this a staged drama..he said, had he had to go these gimmics, there are thousand ways to do it...whatever he has done it, he always does from his heart and he only fear KHUDA....

Well , isn't it that this article is so biased. Whatever HR does is wrong, and whatever ID does is always correct...yes ...good food for thought... okie this is a test for every body....remember your god and or any one whom u respect the most..close your eyes..and listen to whenever HR speaks and when ID speaks..who sounds genuine...i think you will get your answer..

3 tunes a day and he has a bank of 1000 tunes....... even three tunes a day...what a joke........

i dont know, people say i am biased against HR..but what is he doing to stop me form biasing against him.......nothing

HR se behtar Anu Malik Hai..Hez given us many gr8 hits in 80's,90's

Originally posted by: uselogic

Thought of sharing two interviews which i saw today..

HR's Interview on Current Bollywood's Aaj Ki Dhun:

-> He has a current bank of 1000 tunes.. Can you imagine that? he composes three tunes each day...now what to say is it good.can you expect quality songs from him? No way...he has a bank of 1000 tunes , which means he has that many in the kitty.but guess i think, if you compose three tunes a day then i am sorry you are not CREATING tunes but MANUFACTURING tunes...as long as we are getting 1000 stupids films a day , people like hr will keep on manufacturing 1000 tunes for us...

-> He says that in order to succeed , you need to be versatile and hit sixers every day.( looks like we have heard the sixer thing some where).. he says i give all type of music , like contemprary, western and classical..Can any one tell me , which song of him was classical? I dont know how long can he be successful by telling all these shit?

-> He will sing exclusivley. Thank god, the more exclusive he becomes in his singing , the better for us.. Atleast we can listen to his howling exclusively.

-> He want to reach out to the whole world? oh my god, now whatever respect world had for indian music , is now going to go for a toss.

-> He says that , you have to come up with something so that people remember you, otherwise withing 6 months people will forget you..guys did we forget salil choudhary,anil biswas, naushad, roshan, madan mohan, roshan, sdb,rdb, LP and the list goes on...NO NO definitely not...did we forget ID, JL, ARR..jsut because they are not releasing something in every three months...looks like he should be in the field for advertising..are we selling colgate, pepsi, that we should do this..come on guys we are creating MUSIC.. please dont commercialise MUSIC....

ID's Interview on ZOOM TV:

poor chap.he should have got some good movies..but as i mentioned in one of my post in reply to N Sinha's post..today the music will be driven solely by the genre of movies released in coming times..as long as we have movies like Aksar, Jawani Diwani,Shaadi se Pehele and many others....people like JL, ID will be jobless.. i am sorry but we as a audience has failed you..there is no body to listen to good music and soon kishore and rafi DUDES wil remembered through their remix versions..dont get suprised when "badan pe sitare lapete hue", will be remebered as sung by Harry Anand , rafi chap would be remembered as somebody who actually dubbed it so that harry dude can sing for it...

He was asked , why did he go out of SRGMP . he said because he thought nihira is the real winner and he was very depressed when she was voted out from last 5..he said , he has high respect for Gj,,he could have sued him , for leaving the show..he said he came back becasue of Gj and he want to make sure that that injsutice is not done to anyone else..when asked , was this a staged drama..he said, had he had to go these gimmics, there are thousand ways to do it...whatever he has done it, he always does from his heart and he only fear KHUDA....

Well , isn't it that this article is so biased. Whatever HR does is wrong, and whatever ID does is always correct...yes ...good food for thought... okie this is a test for every body....remember your god and or any one whom u respect the most..close your eyes..and listen to whenever HR speaks and when ID speaks..who sounds genuine...i think you will get your answer..

No doubt. ID's interview is good and sensible . HR has become a laughing stock and joker and some time talks crook. if he is having respect for talented singer he would not have humiliated nihira 'that her chapter is closed. He has passed a rude remark on her instead of expressing his sympathy for her exit from the show and it prooves that he is very arrogant. and for him vinit is the only talented singer in the whole world.

no i am not trying to compare but i have just written my perpective about the two interviews, i heard in a span of 10 minutes...

Originally posted by: uselogic

Thought of sharing two interviews which i saw today..

HR's Interview on Current Bollywood's Aaj Ki Dhun:

-> He has a current bank of 1000 tunes.. Can you imagine that? he composes three tunes each day...now what to say is it good.can you expect quality songs from him? No way...he has a bank of 1000 tunes , which means he has that many in the kitty.but guess i think, if you compose three tunes a day then i am sorry you are not CREATING tunes but MANUFACTURING tunes...as long as we are getting 1000 stupids films a day , people like hr will keep on manufacturing 1000 tunes for us... most..close your eyes..and listen to whenever HR speaks and when ID speaks..who sounds genuine...i think you will get your answer..

Uselogic, Corretion. Its Contract Manufacturing, because he outsources the job to other wannabe MDs. kyoh ki, aaj kal bilkul time nahi miltha.. composing keh liye.. He is too busy thinking about new gimmicks. Also has to think about alternative thareeka (backup plans) if the current gimmick flops...

i had got the answer a long time ago, ismail darbar knows music to the core. not only does he compose well but he understands sur and the singer. kavita krishnamurthy once said that ismail darbar is the only music director who understands the tonal quality of the singer and gives the songs accordingly.
he has also been fair to give points in srgmp to singers who were not in his gharana too.
hr may last for another year with the same kinds of tunes turned over and presented. on the other hand he has messed with vinit's talent because even vinit has singing with a nasal tone. according to me debo has gone far more than vinit. vinit was singing better earlier. ]
it is alwasy said that when are parents criticise, it is for our improvisation and only they will be knowing it. by hyping vinit so much, he has only spoilt the thinking of vinit as well as vinit has become over confident. the very fact that vinit could say that we know what we sing and how we sing is a very bad statement to be made. it just shows the ghamand he has. no hard feelings vinit fans, but i have stopped voting for vinit after this side of him was exposed. i felt bad and taken for granted. not fair vinit, hemu and himani.
but from now on my votes are for debo.

Originally posted by: sailingspoon

100 tunes??OMG usme se 999 are imported from pakistan,korean,chinese and rest one is from lakshmikant pyarelal.dont you think this guy would be outdated very soon like baba sehgal who said RAP later became CRAP??? yeh season hain bhai for this kinda music jab mausam badalti hain tab yeh music bhi badal jati hain but classic music always stays there.SLOW AND STEADY WINS THE RACE.so ismail is definetely a MAESTRO.you cant compare that joker with ismail

see i think he is bluffing...even i can say i have a bank of 1000 tunes..who will verify that....did u ever see any MDs saying that i have 1000 tunes or shouting that i have been make raag based tunes...boss if u have made it, then no need to brag about it, people will themselves know about it..... he himeslf know about it.......anyways i am waiting for Id's next album to release... then somebody should tell HR that new releases in three month is not enuf to keep u in the minds of people..one good album is enuf to make a permamanent place in the hearts of music lovers...

3 tunes per day ... 1 he makes up and the other 2 he gets from his snoring or singing when he has a cold

Unbelivable!!!
3 tunes a day?
and still such good music?
this guy is talented no doubt.