ID and Debo Cunning and Arrogant - Page 3

ou're from North East, I wish the people out there and the people out there beat you up ...

Exactly !! this is the culture you have which I wanted to bring it out ..😆

i red somewhere ulfa is supporting debo and caaled zee tv also.

It was wrong on I Darbar to stage a walkout that day, he was the one who started all this, He did this bcoz he knew that debo had sung really bad , that's why he got very less point , it was the only way he could have saved him..... u r right he is cunning and arrogant....
He was telling that AS and HR had pushed Nihira out, but the truth is AS and HR had always given Nihira 10 or 9 out of 10 , they had never questioned her abilites .... Debo was the one who got less pts , becoz he sang really bad, guys I have done MA in music, in know he is not good , Try to remember his last performances his voice always cracks in between , He was singing the qawwali with no josh , it was like a sad song.... EVen when he sung for Gladrags Mrs. India contest , .... his voice cracked more then three times in a single song.... he doesn't deserve to be in top 5, instead of Nihira ...he should be out, I don't have anything against NE , I respect all the regions and religions , i am from north india and i still support Hemachandra.... Coz its all about singing guys.......

Originally posted by: vishwa_chetan

I believe ID is cheap and uncultured ediot. He suppose to be one of the good music directors. Why does he act like nuts? Debojit has luck and more soft corner than his singing talent.

I just cannot believe this. Do you even watch this show with your eyes and ears open (i am not asking about your brains! so do not get mad please) ! Which mentor other than ID has come to the center stage to appreciate the other mentor's contestants? Do you remember AS or HR coming to stage even for Nihira?

Wake up and understand the difference between a mentor and an agent.

This is my first post against someone's comment but I just could not stop myself. I have noticed that ID has also started doing "ma ka sapne" tricks for Debo and he is right. If others c an do why can't him?

Nihira lost because of ID. He thought Nihira does not need and publicity or marketting because India's janta will understand the true music. SEE he was wrong. MARKETTING is the key, which HR has done for VINIT,nnot although he has overdone it. Debo cannot spend 2 lakhs, he ccaannot ask votes for his love and bijli ka bil so let it be for region. SAREGAMAPA is not about music, that got over when Nihira left. Now it is marketting fight.

thanks for stopping by

This is very unfair post. I liked AS in the begining but the everyone now know the reality of AS and HR 😡 . HR is the shameless person, doesn't know ABC of hindi music..CHOR KAHIN KA..ID has been a neutral mentor since from the begining and He always praise singers from other GHARANAs if they sing really well..I like ID the most now. He doesnt do any conspiracy at all. This is HR and AS playing this cheap game.

Guys, Debojit is the best and versatile singer among all three and he deserves a lot. It is unfortunate that other mentors never praised him. Vineet is too young and needs lots of guts to be in a position of Debojit. Hema is certainly better and i would consider him equal to Debo.

Think in cool minds. ID is like SANGEET KA PUJARI, and the originality always displayed in his music.

ID, DEBO KA YALGAAR--INDIA KE MUSIC KA KAREGA BEDA PAAR....... 👏 👏 👏

No ID not cunning -- he is sadly the opposite, How else could he let Nihira
lose?

HEy Guys....

Sorry if Iam being blunt.. But why do u feel that ID is being Cunning.. I donot know him personally but from the episodes I have seen the kind of encouragement he gives to the students.He is the most neutral judge. Have u ever seen him bluntly scolding the kids even before the gharana. He has made every student comfortable as possible. More than that he has not done something what other judeges have done. He has never compared their voices to the original singers knowing very well they cannot be compared. We may say nihira has voice like shreya or Ujaain is like sunidhi.But the fact remains the same that u cannot compare it. Each have their style. AS and HR always used to compare.. Infact even J & L have done so...

If ID has scolded it is his own student.. and he has never overhyped anyone and one has to appreciate the fact that despite this much conflicts and problems.. he has never allowed it to come in the way of students he has toned them to that extent....

J&L are very emotional.. More than practical they r emotional.They just blurt what they have in mind.. Becoz of this.. One incident which happened few months back was one student was singig a song from "Mughal E Azam" and she did sing well according to her capacity ( dude.. they r just new to the stage)...they just overreacted saying it is like a kotewali..How will one react.. !! May be ID does have a short temper He has tolerated all the nonsesical acts...but this time he cannot another student going a torture..

AS is sure a silent killer and so is HR..indirect killer.. But when it comes to directing music.. they have their own styles and attitudes.

Cheers....

Rami

Originally posted by: skw549

I looked at 19th video online. A man like ID quits show and comes back and when his candidate "Debo" was declared highest he never expressed the suprise/loud-clapping/ etc. Infact he looks at Debo's wife with sort of some accomplishments. That means ID knows ahead of time Debo is going to massive votes..this is possible only when he knows that rigging is goin on

He came back because Debo, asked him to. He felt bad when Ismail left while he is still in the competition, and wanted to know why Ismail would leave him just like that...Ismail realized that he needed to be there to support Debo..it is not like ne one else in SRGM is.

SO baath ki ek Baath:

ID is transparent but you guys like drama so you deserve AS and HR. Enjoy the nautankis with HR and AS.

indians r so naive. ID openly makes a statement tht walkouts gain u alot of votes n ppl still sypathise him. ID is smart! i say all the 3 mentors r egoistic freaks but yes ID is comparatively better. cleverest among the fools is not a scholar, in other wotds best among the bad does not mean he is gud. debu is innocent though, just as innocent as vinit hema n himani