walking out ritual...who started - Page 2

I guess ID did this to gain people inerest towards him and that happened. In other words ID knew that Debu sang bad . He lacked in sur @ some places but to keep him and debu in compition after vineet got highest votes. He playeed this game and he won this game by getting highest votes for debu.

Originally posted by: preetie

saregama: ismail ji walked out after debo's not so good performance not after nihira's result. even so may be these three contestent feel that debo is not deserving so why bash them for it. mentors are walking out so contestants are learning from them. regardless of the reason.....it is all about being disatisfied of the outcome.

true ismailji walked out... but look at who he is... this will not affect his career, he is not 17 and he has already given many fabulous albums.... lemme give u an example... its like a rabbit sees a lion hunt a wolf for food, and the rabbit deciding to hunt a wolf too. u cannot compare the 2. these contestants future is depending on these and many other MDs.... do u really think they will want a singer with that much attitude.... and its not for them or the mentors even do decide who is undeserving and who isnt. its the public who decides and the public has decided... bas khallas.... these conestants must have agreed to the rules of the game before playing so wat is the point in crying fowl now

Originally posted by: seema_17

true ismailji walked out... but look at who he is... this will not affect his career, he is not 17 and he has already given many fabulous albums.... lemme give u an example... its like a rabbit sees a lion hunt a wolf for food, and the rabbit deciding to hunt a wolf too. u cannot compare the 2. these contestants future is depending on these and many other MDs.... do u really think they will want a singer with that much attitude.... and its not for them or the mentors even do decide who is undeserving and who isnt. its the public who decides and the public has decided... bas khallas.... these conestants must have agreed to the rules of the game before playing so wat is the point in crying fowl now

seem: it is not about attitude...it is more like protest from these young talented singers. all I am saying is that mentors started this ritual of walking out which led to contestents following the same path. This whole thing is like circus to me. I don't think public voting is credible anymore because most of ppl start voting based on emotions than based on performance. As far as natak is concern everyone is playing the public---vinit, hema, debo, mentors etc etc.

Originally posted by: preetie

In my opinion: Ismail is a good guy and honest. HR over supports vinit even when his performance was so so.

Now everyone is bashing hema, vinit, himani for walking out of the contest. Isn't that is what Ismail ji did last time. So is it fair to say that he started this ritual. If you don't like the way things are going then just walk out.

Ismail's walk out and teary wife syndrome resulted in high votes for debo inspite of not so good performance. Isn't this promoted walk out in positive way to these three contestents.

sorry don't mean to offend anyone.

I totally agree with you. Although I like ID as Music Director and as Mentor both very much. He is the one who started walk out first and at that time we all praised him for doing it. He also didn't walkout for Nihira otherwise he would not be present for friday's show and walked out with NIhira on thursday. He walked out because Debo's less marks.

Now this 3 kids did walkout may be encouraged by their mentors and everybody wants to crucify them. I wrote this reply in one of the threads yesterday also nobody replied back.

I think we should still vote on their talent and nothing else.

preetie i agree with u that ismail is really sincere and all. but, with u agreeing about vinit and the rest walking out then thats bull. and u saying that debo didnt sing good, thats bull too. HE SANG SO WELL THAT day and then adesh that &^$&^%&^^ just gave him a 6. everyone has always been against him. and so when he got a lot of votes, ppl walk out. i didnt see anyone else walk out when vinit r hema or himani get a lot of votes. its all bloody politics. no one wants an poor man to win.

I don't think other contestents are super rich. so poor man's analogy is bull as well. remember vinit's mother bought him guiter with electricity bill money. debo has had struglle just like many people in this world. so are we going to make someone big because he or she is poor....it doesn't work that way.

Originally posted by: kaunhaiwoh

preetie i agree with u that ismail is really sincere and all. but, with u agreeing about vinit and the rest walking out then thats bull. and u saying that debo didnt sing good, thats bull too. HE SANG SO WELL THAT day and then adesh that &^$&^%&^^ just gave him a 6. everyone has always been against him. and so when he got a lot of votes, ppl walk out. i didnt see anyone else walk out when vinit r hema or himani get a lot of votes. its all bloody politics. no one wants an poor man to win.

u r absolutely 100000000000000000% right preetie

Originally posted by: chukkna

There is no politics in ID walking off. He was totally hurt with Nihira out and bad remarks by other mentors to Debojit.

The walkout drama infact started long back when Jatin Lalit stopped coming to the show aftre Sharib was out. How can you forgte that?

I am not a big Debo fan, I always wanted Hema/Nihira to win. But looking at all these nataks and the pride other singers are having(be it their attitude or Mentor's manipulation) I wish Debo wins.

jatin lalit left cuz their challenge was over after sharib left!

ID did a natak..if he really wanted to leave..y didn't he leave after nihira was out?????????? he left when he realize debu didn't sing it well..n he got low pointz too... n luckliy ID drama worked................more than that the thing that worked was sympathy for debu..if AS n HR has treated him equally n would have given him 9s n 8s on his qawali performance..then he would have gone by now..........people voted 4 him cuz they felt bad 4 him..even i did the same thing..after watching that episode...i felt that he wasn't that great...he sung it well but ofcourse his performance didn't deserve a 10 or highest votezzzzz🤢

just curious. wasn't it AS to be the first one who walked out of the show? this was after the confrontation with ID way before agnipariksh...judges were KK and OP.N (Controversy was regarding joyeeta)😕

come what may, a challenge is a challenge & if you have accepted it so far, you shd carry on till the end.
people can discriminate but it does not mean that you form a faction & quit. this is quite immature behaviour & is condemned