Vishal responds on Twitter - Page 8

Vishal is so useless as a judge........keep saying "genuinely" and "honestly" all the time , but there is nothing "genuine" or "honest" about his comment or behavior. 😕

Originally posted by: sunandshine

Sid ki bhasha mein bole to "gaadi total ho gayee"😆

actually Atleast not like the actually highly publicised toyota recall actually. actually People continue to buy actually hordes of toyotas in US actually.

actually The show should be started again actually with all the original 16 contestants and without drama...actually.

Originally posted by: Nishita123

Vishal is so useless as a judge........keep saying "genuinely" and "honestly" all the time , but there is nothing "genuine" or "honest" about his comment or behavior. 😕

Saawan beeto jaaye was one of the finest performance by Sniti and this dude is telling her...."honestly", sur bahot chute !! 🤢

When Ghazaloo baba sings Bijuriay , he goes overboard and praise below average singing like anything !!! 🤢

And I also seriously doubt his knowledge of music and sense of Sur - no offence to his fans ( if there are any !! ) but this is my pov. No need to agree with it.

part of patkartha.

Originally posted by: sunandshine

Sid ki bhasha mein bole to "gaadi total ho gayee"😆

''Gaadi bula rahi hai, seeti baja rahi hai.. chalna hi zindagi hai, chalti hi jaa rahi hai...''...now siersng this in new style..

Guests naach rahe hain,

Mentors udham machaa rahe hain..

comments kyun nahi aa rahe hain

Singers sar khujaa rahe hain...😉😉

If you see the vidoes of previous SRGMP...the judges used points to the sur and other shortcomings of a contestant in detail manner.even the high and low notes and top of it they use to tell the names of different Raaga the song is based...like for eg. Raag malhar, Yaman Kalyan, Pahadi, etc...

Originally posted by: Nishita123

Vishal is so useless as a judge........keep saying "genuinely" and "honestly" all the time , but there is nothing "genuine" or "honest" about his comment or behavior. 😕

Saawan beeto jaaye was one of the finest performance by Sniti and this dude is telling her...."honestly", sur bahot chute !! 🤢

When Ghazaloo baba sings Bijuriay , he goes overboard and praise below average singing like anything !!! 🤢

And I also seriously doubt his knowledge of music and sense of Sur - no offence to his fans ( if there are any !! ) but this is my pov. No need to agree with it.

Their ability to detect "sur chute" was questioned by Asha Bhonsle Ji in the maha guru round, angry after all praises from mentors to a singer after a performance of a female singer, which was like "Bolo sur hili thi ya nahi?" and Vishal Sekhar was very much part of that panel of mentors!!

Originally posted by: cosworthkid007

part of patkartha.

you mean part of patkatha ? script ?

Originally posted by: gopalbhai

Their ability to detect "sur chute" was questioned by Asha Bhonsle Ji in the maha guru round, angry after all praises from mentors to a singer after a performance of a female singer, which was like "Bolo sur hili thi ya nahi?" and Vishal Sekhar was very much part of that panel of mentors!!

Yes I remember that. Last season atleast they had this Magaguru concept , this season they dont have that also !!

Originally posted by: musicmuse

Indradhanush said Vishal sent a series of response to me (Vagabondoc) on twitter

I said

[quote]Singing takes backstage & show gets converted into a ruckus, stars (like Ranbir) do naag dance, many describe this as hooliganism[/quote]

Vishal; Look, I understand your sentiment. Shekhar and I discuss this too. But having fun is not wrong, as long as the singers improve.

I said

[quote]all miss old SRGM, when the stage was school of learning. Lookin froward for positive constructive unbiased opinion from mentors[/quote]

Vishal; Singers have to learn to be performers too. But you will admit that they've improved. We've worked hard and long with them all.

I said; Where are things going wrong

Vishal; we hv genuinely great contestants, and they are learning well. Sugandha, Mugdha, Rini, Kamal already have studio exprnc with us.

It is not possible for him to pinpoint exactly where because he himself does not know, i feel😳

I am seriously doubting his knowledge on indian music, it sounds a bit harsh😳, but, i am getting more and more cynical and sceptical

Sorry, i dunno anything about pentagram😳

Originally posted by: Indradhanush

He himself has confessed that he doesn't have knowl to be a judge on a semi classical round some time back on twitter.