Originally posted by: paratha
I was really sad when Mitika and Naina were eliminated. I think Sara reached pretty far with her talent. I am not saying she was not good but she got good reward by getting in top 8. Naina and Mitika also deserved to be in top 6-8 at least. No one in the forum made any fuss when they got eliminated.
Well said. I agree with you. Elimination of Mitika was the shocker of the show - no offense - even Asma staying in the show is no big shocker than that!! I felt they were mocking at Ashaji - since Ashaji clearly said when she was judging the first rounds that Mitika is superb and has extraordinary voice and talent, and that she sang in one go the very song that Ashaji couldnt record in one go and could never sing in stage.
Sara reached as far as her talent would get, and Mitika and Naina didnt. Of course, all of them were sacrificed for the sake of Asma - probably in an attempt to kill our age old music industry!!!
Maybe it was never raised as a big fuss in this forum because they were eliminated before the heat started to set in for the competition and fan base. But if they had stayed, I am pretty sure they would have acquired a big fan base by now. Despite being prematurely eliminated, they are still residing in many of our hearts...