sara the best - Page 3

Originally posted by: paratha

I am still wondering why such a big deal over Sara's elimination. I thought Naina and Mitika were far more talented than Sara.

Originally posted by: Little SK

i think sara was really the best , faisla buhat gallat hua hai

now she is out i think then yashita must win

and if yashita not then asma

1. sara

2. yashita

3. asma

can i know your favourite top 3

Originally posted by: akanna

This topic had its round already before, with top three and bottom three picks by many members. Anyway, since it is recycled, I will go with the remaining ones left.

My top three: Vaishali, Prathibha and Soumen - I am okay with either one being the winner. 😃

Debo, Yashita and Zaheer are okay. 😊

Asma - NO WAY, I have to lose my mind to say otherwise! 😉

Originally posted by: akanna

FHK, are you sure?! Your Kingji will be heart broken by these choices - you know how much he hates Debo, even the very name will make him fuming!!

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

Zaheer ko jo respect milne chahiya woh nahin milte - baray ufsos ki baat hai, humain itna tang nazar nahin hona chahiya
Please I am not trying to get in to any arguments - but due respect should be given to the talent.

Originally posted by: akanna

I do have respect for Zaheer, and he was always my second best among the four Pakistani contestants this year. With all due respects, I cannot connect to his songs - I have been trying to feel the connection every week but in vain so far. The same problem I have with Yashita too. ...and Asma - no comments.

Either the singer should have "the" voice plus sur or "the" look plus sur on a TV show to be appealing for the audience - IMHO. Prathibha has both voice and look with sur of course; Vaishali and Soumen have the voice with sur; Asma has the look without the sur; Debo has the voice with sur often; Yashita has the voice with sur and some look too; Zaheer has the voice with sur. Despite all these, when it comes to connecting with the songs, I dont feel it for Zaheer or Yashita - no offense. It's a personal thing and I cannot force it to happen - it has to occur naturally by listening to the singer.

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

Yeh jitnay bhi hain in sab mein flaws hain - aur bhai appearance ka ganay sey kiya talaq hai, aur log Lataji aur Ashaji ko talent ki wajha sey pasand kartay hain appearance ki wajah sey nahin, connection usi waqt hota hai jab connect karnay ki kosish kartay hain.

Shaid isi wajah se log asma ko vote kartay hain.
Hum logoon kay zahan chotay hain
Yahan baat Pakistani singers ki nahin aur mein kabhi Pakistani singers ya Indian singers ki baat nahin karta aur mujhe yeh bhi maloom hai kay aap kabhi bhi Pakistani singer ya Indian singer ki baat nahin karogay.

Sorry if I am being harsh.

Originally posted by: akanna

Please translate - if you may. I am not fluent in Urdu or hard core Hindi. Sorry. 😊

Originally posted by: Khatarnak

Not a problem - all the singers (contestants) you have mentioned they all have some flaws and I do not understand what appearance has to do with a singer or singing as a matter of fact. People appreciate Lataji and Ashaji because of their Talent not because of their appearance or how they look, speaking of connection you can only connect to some one when you appreciate the talent and forget about the personality.

This Saregama appears to be a popularity contest rather then singing and that is the reason why Asma has survived to date - appealing personality right?.

I am not talking about a Pakistani or an Indian singer and if that's the criteria then we are not doing any justice and I do know that even you do not discriminte on the basis of religion, region, and nationality.

Now this is an addition to my original comments

The problem is once we form an opinion then we do not want to deviate from it (no matter how they perform) - The perfect example is even after Amanat's memorable performance (Tujhe Naraz nahin) there are/were people not willing to give him a credit.

Yes Shujaat is a very good singer but he is very inconsistent and the consistency is the key to success, there is no harm in giving a credit to the talent instead of being stubborn, when you say he is ok (that means you are saying he is just average which he is not). All the remaining contestants with the exception of Sara are very talented and it is hard to tell who is the best.

Sorry if I am being a little harsh, but there is nothing personal and no hard feeling please.