This Is a GREAT Track for Sumer Banna

napstermonster thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Look Guys:

As I sat there watching the mother of the year throwing her mentally challenged son under a bus, I couldnt help feeling...happy. Of course, then I come to the forum and find people having the exact opposite reaction. So I sit there, shame faced, reading everyone's posts, and feeling embarassed for my odd reaction. And then I think...hmm.


No one is remembering something the CVs have consistently done with Sumer---They have given HIM, and not Samrat, an actual personality. While I think Samrat is basically a cardboard cutout with a constipated expression that they move from location to location, propped up behind Maithli -- with Sumer, from the first scene, first intro, they have given him a character.


And like it or not--that is not a fully black character--purely because he has been under his mother's control for so long, he is basically her minion. Not her partner. Left to himself, he really has only two desires in life, both grey shaded, not endlessly black--he doesnt give a damn about anything family-oriented, and he wants to go to Jaipur. He is loyal to his dreams, and to his mother.


I hope the actor forgives this analogy if he reads this, but he is like a badly brought up dog, frankly. The puppy is not a very smart creature when its young, and it absorbs what it sees, and if its been trained to do harm, it will harm anything and everything its master points it to. It will snarl and snap at anyone (like Rudra /Paro / Danveer) who threatens its bone (Jaipur dream). AND it will not understand when its being used for evil--because it knows nothing else but to listen to its owner.


The CVs have in one episode emptied out the entire bag of Sumer's past wrongdoings. Ones I almst forgot about--like the kidnapping track--came out today, in front of the entire family. The only thing that Sumer has to himself is the money hes borrowed against the Haveli--which had nothing to do with Rudra or Paro because it happened before they showed up.


Nothing else is left. Sab paap saamnei aa chukein hain. Why would the CVs do this, as well as the careful character building--even the comic moments, the funny dialogues--if THIS son was not going to finally finally show some growth? I mean, if they needed an ally for Paro later--Samrat is much more suitable. But they chose to focus on Sumer, and they did so from the beginning.


There are two things that pleases me about this track. One is that Sumer's mind-control from his mother--and you cannot deny he loves that vicious piece of work--well, that love, that mind- control is broken. His expression when he realized what was being done to him made me feel a little sad for the guy.


The second thing is--he is genuinely slightly stupid, and CANNOT plan all this. And there is no way Rudra cannot see it now. I mean, he kidnapped the wrong bhabi. He is the scapegoat for some heinous things, and yes, he assisted in evil--but he knows no better. Now that he has been betrayed in the worst of ways, there is only one way for this character to grow--UP. Unless the CVs decide to bring Laila in through him, and he and Laila join forces, there is no reason for him to really give into another evil track against Paro/Rudra.


He cannot have anything concrete against Rudra or Paro--they did not betray him. He has nothing against his father, brother or Maithli--they dont know anything. If he has an enemy--it is Mohini. And the glimpses of a pretty dumb, misguided guy with a tractor wala dil, and the plans to build a Paro-Mahal--that guy, is still there, washed clean by his mother's fake tears. He is standing nude before everyone right now, as exposed, and as vulnerable as a child would be, if its mother gave it poison instead of milk. He truly wanted to save her, he was truly frightened she would be taken away. And then, his dawning comprehension about what she was doing...it was pretty powerful.


Knowing Paro, knowing she will see the mother's act as the evil betrayal it is, and knowing Sumer's pain for being so betrayed--I cant help seeing Paro reaching out to him now. I dont know, maybe she is too focussed on all things Rudra-- but I would think very good thoughts of her nature if she cared for another hurting person, after Mohini is exposed, no matter how misguided that person was.


We might be seeing...dare I say it...a friend for Paro, a potential future supportive figure. Maybe a grey character.. but not an evil one. And one who is capable of making decisions un-influenced by a viper parent. So far, RangRasiya has consistently surprised me with HOW they have first created, and then changed their characters (Dilsher's role from first week till now, anyone?) And they don't waste their time with useless character building that goes nowhere (like IPKKND's NK or Payal) .


I have hope, baisas.
I like Sumer's earrings. I like his crazy shirts. Maybe now, he will have a redemption of sorts--and I'll like his actions too. BUT: Oh yeah, one thing-- if he marries Laila..I'm out.

Edited by napstermonster - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

39

Views

4.9k

Users

35

Likes

185

Frequent Posters

Navyya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
If Mohini is thrown out then so will Sumer...Either both stay or both are thrown out.
Aruni. thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
abhi ata hoon

Originally posted by: napstermonster

As I sat there watching the mother of the year throwing her mentally challenged son under a bus, I couldnt help feeling...happy. Of course, then I come to the forum and find people having the exact opposite reaction. So I sit there, shame faced, reading everyone's posts, and feeling embarassed for my odd reaction.


That's exactly what i felt too šŸ˜† For the first time in a long time, i loved every scene of the episode, and come to the forum to find many many thumbs down posts

You have to give it to Mohini. She had the most chalak dimaag in this story so far, scheming and making sure no one suspects her - she does a super fine job at the most part. I thought she will blurt out the truth about laddoo, when she was supposedly poisoned - but she didn't. Then i thought she will accept her crimes and plead for forgiveness, or try the pity card, saying she did all of this for her haveli - but she didn't. Man i totally did not expect her wriggling out of that one!

Originally posted by: napstermonster

Knowing Paro, knowing she will see the mother's act as the evil betrayal it is, and knowing Sumer's pain for being so betrayed--I cant help seeing Paro reaching out to him now. I dont know, maybe she is too focussed on all things Rudra-- but I would think very good thoughts of her nature if she cared for another hurting person, after Mohini is exposed, no matter how misguided that person was.

We might be seeing...dare I say it...a friend for Paro, a potential future supportive figure. Maybe a grey character.. but not an evil one. And one who is capable of making decisions un-influenced by a viper parent. So far, RangRasiya has consistently surprised me with HOW they have first created, and then changed their characters (Danveer's role from first week till now, anyone?) And they don't waste their time with useless character building that goes nowhere (like IPKKND's NK or Payal) .


Umm... will she see it? As it is, Mohini did a fine job of convincing everyone, except perhaps Rudra, who knows Sumer can't be that awesome and Mohini can't be that seedha. But an interesting point - I would love to see at least one non-cliched friendship in this story - Paro-Laila or Sumer-Paro, or Rudra-Maithili... šŸ¤”
Edited by aruni50218 - 11 years ago
Guinea thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
I get a feeling , he will be thrown out with his mum but I so wish its only mohini ...a wonderful track could be built around him , his redemption and maybe even a love track between him and paro's cousn nandu bais 😊
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Great post, NM ... I'm also a little surprised at the outpouring of emotion against Mohini throwing Sumer under the bus. All it does is put her beyond redemption, while ... as you very rightly pointed out ... puts Sumer ON the path to redemption. Rudra, Paro and Danveer know he is too stupid to have done all this planning ... and that Mohini is sacrificing him. How that works out for Mohini, I don't know ... but probably Sumer will be more careful in letting himself get drawn into her plans int he future. Of course Mohini will also be on the back foot for quite a long time now.
But if he marries Laila ... NO!!! 🤢
asmi279 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I dn kno NM..I think they will throw out both of them to bring this track to a closure..bt RR's cvs always surprise me, so they might take on the track u suggested..wd luv to see that play out :)
napstermonster thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: babyji

If Mohini is thrown out then so will Sumer...Either both stay or both are thrown out.


Honestly, if Mohini had just confessed to everything and not tried to twist it onto Sumer, I think she would NOT have been thrown out. Rudra said--How about you confess now? If you wont, I'll call the police, shall I? He didnt reach for the phone, call the BSD or do anything other than threaten. She is the one who ups the ante. Rudra would not have brought the police (he tells the doctor to keep quiet about all this) if she has just confessed, and cleared Paro of any blame/guilt. I dont see him doing that to his Kakusa--not even throwing her out of the haveli himself.


Mohini had a clear way out--she could have confessed, begged for forgiveness, been treated coldly by everyone. A few taunts, some anger and she could have lived to fight another day once everyone calmed down and a few months of "prashchith" passed. Her husband is too weak a man to stand up against her permanently. Rudra would have stayed silent for his Kakusa. And Paro would listen to him. She would never trust her, but she wouldn't be making any phone calls.


The fact she did this to her son--this is probably going to be the betrayal that Danveer cannot take, when he finds out about it tomorrow. And Sumer will be quite punished enough, by his mother's betrayal. I dont see them tossing out both characters--too many losses in the Haveli. Danveer is a weak man, and Rudra wont take the decision on Danveer's behalf. I dont see him losing his wife and then a devastated Sumer, who got tricked into almost going to jail for Mohini as well.
Edited by napstermonster - 11 years ago
SherryGS thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Minion is my preferred name for Sumer. You got that totally right. They are the best pair on tv, well were... Anyway, I cannot see Rudra allowing a friendship to blossom between Paro and Sumer, that would be something. hahha. Yes, his mother had total control of his pea brain so let's see what happens now. Hope the poor guy doesn't end up in jail with those "cheap men." LOL. They may like his wild shirts too. hahaha.
Totally agree with you on Samrat! Doormat, furniture, stick of wood, what else... UGH. Boring. Maitali needs to move on... šŸ˜†
Great episode though and I think the little minion has learned a very hard life lesson.
shona. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
With this Sumer will be given some development, he will have the chance to leave mummy's palu and start thinking for himself
Brillient move by the CVs
KhushiParo thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
As much as I love to see KcM punished even this Sumer track today
I'm satisfied. He's a partner in crime so this time he's exposed next time in a
more dramatic way KcM.
At least she had the taste of ladoo she made.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".