QH trp 2.5 - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

3.6k

Users

14

Likes

209

Frequent Posters

Ramlath thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani



ShaJan--highly promoted! Said to be 'fresh, new' start and beginnings of new story executed very well, etc etc.

SaHil for two days, was a surprise, only about three scenes, denouement after climax of previous week.



agree and that was holi week too😊
224529 thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: KhatamKahani


I know he went away for shoot, but I am talking about after he was back. SeHan was never given as much space as is claimed afterwards.

And you could see them adjusting by third week, when he was still there, the lesser focus and space for SeHan.

And again you say 20 percent, I say more than that was taken.

You keep saying that's what dropped the ratings, except Billi was always prominent, and so was RaHaFa. SeHer was tied with Sanam. It was when SeHer got an independent track with ReHan/SeHan it dropped.



They were not given space afterwards because SS himself confessed that the prod house was adjusting his dates as per his movie shoot schedule. He is also an active part of production and script discussion/changes. He barely had time and that resulted in very tiny scenes of SeHaan. It was not due to any drop. He himself told us that the team had better, longer scenes for SeHaan but he couldn't do it due to time constraint. You keep insisting that SeHaan and Seher and Rehaan dropped the TRP but I don't agree with it. The max screen space character are to be blamed for that. I know it was about 20%, you can go and check..it's available easily on YT..maybe some episode had 30% of so on their scenes but no more than that. The max scenes were still of Billi and SaHil. Not even RaHaFa at that time..though, I think it was mostly HaFa then and Ra was missing.

And Billi may have been prominent but that doesn't mean the audience will lap up anything shown with her..same with SaHil. Their track then was really dull...some contest? Total Dud. But again that's my opinion..you guys may have thought it was awesome.

And regarding Seher ..we can all see the drop in the TRP's after she went missing. She is what is interesting to watch in the show. Her character is so different that audience can't help but love her. Not the forum members though but the TRP audience. We can keep debating but I am going off to watch a movie and have to start getting ready. So I will end this by saying that SaHil fans will obviously blame SeHaan for the TRP drop and SeHaan fans will in turn blame SaHil for the TRP drop but no one can refute that the show was going to be shut when SaHil was at it's peak..even KV and SurVir couldn't stop it..only after Seher came did the TRP become stable enough that the channel gave it a year long extension. Now you can again claim Seher was not the reason but you can again see that the TRP is decreasing with her being MIA. It clearly proves who is the USP of the show. I'm done for now. Take care. Cinderella is calling to me. 😆 And please ignore any typo's or spelling mistakes. This reply was typed in a hurry. 😆
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: In-Sanity-Metis



Haha. There was no SeHaan after that because of their break up and SS going away for his movie shoot. I was talking about their screen space DURING the Kohinoor project. It was 20% only ...most of the screenspace was to IM drama with sanam+billi+sahil. That's what dropped the rating since they had the most screen space and the track for them was not very interesting...Aahil was falling for her and not treating her like dirt like the audience like seeing the hero treat the heroine. The swap actually increased the ratings because even though she was acting as "Sanam" it was Seher and the audience loved watching her in IM.


I agree Swap track held steady after the drop that during Kohinoor and SeHan track. Swap track stopped the bleeding and actually did start to slowly increase.
And who else got a good amount of screenspace during that swap track? Aahil (and AaHer).😆

Edited to add. And I was probably the biggest "defender" of swap track while it was going on and challenging assertions that swap track was bringing down ratings.
Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: Catz.


s 2 had opened to a rating of 2


And? Situations were completely different. Nothing like how S3 was executed.

S3 was led in with good execution, using S2 to lead into S3. It was done very well. S2 was brought up from rubbles, S3 had so many things going for it.

What did S1 end with and what did S2 end with?
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: In-Sanity-Metis



They were not given space afterwards because SS himself confessed that the prod house was adjusting his dates as per his movie shoot schedule. He is also an active part of production and script discussion/changes. He barely had time and that resulted in very tiny scenes of SeHaan. It was not due to any drop. He himself told us that the team had better, longer scenes for SeHaan but he couldn't do it due to time constraint. You keep insisting that SeHaan and Seher and Rehaan dropped the TRP but I don't agree with it. The max screen space character are to be blamed for that. I know it was about 20%, you can go and check..it's available easily on YT..maybe some episode had 30% of so on their scenes but no more than that. The max scenes were still of Billi and SaHil. Not even RaHaFa at that time..though, I think it was mostly HaFa then and Ra was missing.

And Billi may have been prominent but that doesn't mean the audience will lap up anything shown with her..same with SaHil. Their track then was really dull...some contest? Total Dud. But again that's my opinion..you guys may have thought it was awesome.

And regarding Seher ..we can all see the drop in the TRP's after she went missing. She is what is interesting to watch in the show. Her character is so different that audience can't help but love her. Not the forum members though but the TRP audience. We can keep debating but I am going off to watch a movie and have to start getting ready. So I will end this by saying that SaHil fans will obviously blame SeHaan for the TRP drop and SeHaan fans will in turn blame SaHil for the TRP drop but no one can refute that the show was going to be shut when SaHil was at it's peak..even KV and SurVir couldn't stop it..only after Seher came did the TRP become stable enough that the channel gave it a year long extension. Now you can again claim Seher was not the reason but you can again see that the TRP is decreasing with her being MIA. It clearly proves who is the USP of the show. I'm done for now. Take care. Cinderella is calling to me. 😆 And please ignore any typo's or spelling mistakes. This reply was typed in a hurry. 😆


I said almost half and I stick to that. If you combine the first two weeks, I say SeHer-Rehan track amounted to almost half. And oh, RaHaFa doesn't count. Because RaHaFa was pretty much always a constant before and afterwards. Whatever is after RaHaFa, yes it does amount to almost half.

And you keep talking about his film schedule, i keep talking about how SeHan were used after he came back. Look, I am not calling Rehan responsible for anything. I am saying independent track on SeHan and Seher.

Makers have all kinds of track and stories lined up. But in the end, the will go with what gives them ratings or what's easier to give them ratings on a week to week basis. I have always credited the story of QH2 and then the factors involved in it to its success. It's why all of QH2 except for RaHaFa parallel track kept to that story and hardly diverted. If they did divert, they came right back to that QH2 story.

@bold. Come on, be consistent. So the TRP drop of week after Tanveer's death is because SeHer went missing? She was only got hit by the truck on Thursday! She was there that whole week and was 'ended' on Thursday.

And so what about the next week? Did it stay the same or did it marginally increase? Either way, it should've dropped then for S3 opening. Because Seher was "killed" the Thursday prior.

And again, to the rest of your Seher point, I will reiterate my point. Seher works when tied with Sanam. Not independently. How was Seher used when she entered? Introduced and shown as a con artist, yes and then almost running into Sanam and Tanveer, then into IM and later the hospital where Sanam was, with Raziya chasing her along the way.
Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#26
And I too am off. I will wait till the next round, which I am quite confident will back me up further.
tejaswie thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#27
, QH has got good trps only in those weeks when drama was high , like sahil marriage, seher's entry week, swap, killing attempts on sanam, seher by tannu . trps during poligamy and black magic bs were steady between 2.7 to 3 .. where rehaan and tanveer's death tracks again brought 3.3 trps .. so all in all high drama made QH stable till now .. so now i wonder whats there to create more drama in season 3? even sanam getting back her memory will not bring in much trps , all the shaad jannat shashi kapoor bs is also trash ! soon misbah will end end her shashi kapoor's character and will show SK is dead, when she will come to know about her mom , the track then will shift to india . SK is just a temporary character to create drama .. so no drama can bring back the ratings from now on ...
b4 sanam2 was confined to do only black magic, now that they came to showing her like a vampire and serial killer, they cant go on with her creepiness for long , here misbah was revealed to be SK , so even if they bring new character or new aahil, show wont work, infact in my point of view even if kv stays show wont run more than 2 months as except for giving a positive end to sahil and showing their happy moments for one month with their babies n stuff, nothing much drama can be weaved around them ...
in either case, the count down begins for the show .. no offence to anyone, its only my pov ..
Edited by tejaswie - 10 years ago
latanzia thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 10 years ago
#28
@Khatamkhani and @Tejaswie
I agree with you guy a 100% Season three had one of the best scope of any show with so much potential but then they mess it up with the lie and from there it went downhill.
Sanam 2 Character was not thought out properly it was a rush job, this character is a loose cannon that gul can do anything with at the disgust of fans.

What is the role of SK in this show what was the purpose of revealing his true identity so soon in the show and at what cost the trp did not increase, it did not have any impact.

Now what will bring in the drama, Sanam memory and going back to India, tanveer daughter getting to know about her mother's truth and the rinse and repeat cycle of trying to kill Sanam all over again, or do they think that a the mess between Sanam/Janat- Sahad- Ahil And Sanam 2 Will pull the fans, What is there.

I think some of the fans of this show just bury their head in the sand or just sugar coat every thing, this show is a dead duck just waiting to fall. What is suppose to bring the trp is not, how long will fans put up with watching AG and her bs and i think we all had enough of tanveer, now her daughter please spare us.

This new season could have been done so beautifully that the trp would have increase, show sanam fighting to get back to her husband, show Saher fighting for her life, as for Ahil let us see him suffering and pining for his missing wife, the way Asad was when Zoya went missing After the wedding disaster, instead of this BS they are showing.

Look what is happening in JA, you see how Ekta is drawing her fans back to that show, pain and suffering draws us in, this is what gul should done with this season.

Sorry for the long rant, i am just mad.

Edited by latanzia - 10 years ago
KhatamKahani thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#29
^^ One point. SK--Misbah reveal was this week. It's will factor into TRPs which come out next week.
But anyway, I agree with your and tejaswie's post above yours.
Edited by KhatamKahani - 10 years ago
Orla thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#30
Waiting for more dip n d ratings..that is when the cv's will understand the importance of kv..m happy that kv s leaving from this sinking ship..
Edited by Enigmatic_Angel - 10 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".