Aahil Vs Rehaan!!! - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

38

Views

3.8k

Users

16

Likes

229

Frequent Posters

chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: micshy

i still dont get the purpose of this whole Aahil vs Rehan stuff,

from the very first day Aahil was shown as a rich spoilt brat,albeit with a heart of gold but that heart he used to hide form all except his loved ones

Rehan was his only confidante, his little brother, his personal assistant, who seemed to be a nice guy.

their characterizations has been clear from the first day itself, theres no comparison between both, although ppl might compare their actions but they have been in different circumstances, so comparing the actions and responses is also not fair.

although Rehan's character has been mostly consistently shown as such he was, there have been some ups and downs with Aahils. the only thing i hated is that how they had made Aahil dumbed down when he was initially shown as a smart manipulative business man, the writing has to be blamed for that, during the whole swap track inorder to accomodate their illogical story they did injustice to Aahil's character and the problem started from there.

what wrong decisions he is making in his relationship has nothing to do with how smart or how understanding Rehan is, i have always stated that Aahil has been influenced by many ppl and his behaviour nowadays may be due to that infkuence but he has to come out of it on his own nad i would like to see him fighting his battle himslef, to get to see his mother's true nature himself and i hope Sanam aint by his side when he actually gets to know the truth, although previous few days have somewhat changed my anger toward shim after reading some opinions here , have pacified my anger towards him a ibit, but i still want him to see the truth by himslef, nad realize how wrong was he to beleive his mom over Sanam, nad that guilt and repent will be his redemption


I agree with U dear...😳

Aahil HAS TO connect the dots by himself..I think that is why every attempt by Sanam is going in vain...he has to discover...by himself...👏


chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: -RohitMaxwell-

Sorry if you find my reply inappropriate coz everyone should be given scope for discussion thats what the discussion forums purpose... i aint seeing anyone offensively comparing Ahil vs Rehan... Didnt Ahil get a chance to use his brain? i wont say luck was only factor for Rehan. He saw Sunehri on road, later called Sanam to get confirmed... Ahil saw Sunehri in tops when Shaikhs wives came but he didnt use his brain... he was just content with Sanams reply.. he never could differentiate Sunehris behavior... during swap track... i didnt watch that time but i think he got many times to identify twins... and he is too much blinded by ammis love to even use his brain.. its Rehan who uses brain... both has different characterization to even compare... & i guess Ahil never gave Sanam a chance to explain herself... he loved... trust .. later trust went to drain... he at least could use minimum brain to get out of this trap... thats what i expected... who wont be betrayed if they are blind???


Yaari,

I love Shehzad and enjoy Sehan...but there is a huge disparity if I try to compare AAhil with Rehaan...

When Rehaan met Sunehri, she was not impersonating SAnam...and he was lucky to get SAnam on the line...the circumstances are so different...He never had to question..because Sunehri did not deceive as Sanam...

With AAhil...Sehar was trying her best to con him..and every time he doubted...she came up with an excuse...and the bad moments started adding up, until it started corroding his faith in himself first...and then in their love...and finally now, Sanam...At the beginning of the twin swap, he was thrown off track because he was busy feeling guilty and undeserving of SAnam..

Seeing Sanam in modern dress..it can easily be explained as Sanam's effort to look 'modern' for a business Associate...something he never thought about twice...

If Sunehri had kidnapped Sanam and then appeared in front of Rehaan, acting to be Sanam and have a change of heart after AAhil ill treating her, trying to trap him...he would have fallen too...circumstances are different...Sunehri had a different agenda then...😉


SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: chicksoup


Yaari,

I love Shehzad and enjoy Sehan...but there is a huge disparity if I try to compare AAhil with Rehaan...

When Rehaan met Sunehri, she was not impersonating SAnam...and he was lucky to get SAnam on the line...the circumstances are so different...He never had to question..because Sunehri did not deceive as Sanam...

With AAhil...Sehar was trying her best to con him..and every time he doubted...she came up with an excuse...and the bad moments started adding up, until it started corroding his faith in himself first...and then in their love...and finally now, Sanam...At the beginning of the twin swap, he was thrown off track because he was busy feeling guilty and undeserving of SAnam..

Seeing Sanam in modern dress..it can easily be explained as Sanam's effort to look 'modern' for a business Associate...something he never thought about twice...

If Sunehri had kidnapped Sanam and then appeared in front of Rehaan, acting to be Sanam and have a change of heart after AAhil ill treating her, trying to trap him...he would have fallen too...circumstances are different...Sunehri had a different agenda then...😉




Great points here...but i just wanted to add one thing to complement yours..😊

Actually given how everything that had played out during the swap, it would still come off as Rehan a bit more worse in not being able to differetiate Sanam and Sunehri...Simply because he already knows about the existence of the lookalike and had already spent time with her to be even familiar with her behaviour but STILL even he did not figure out the truth...

It was easier for him to finally straight forward question her about being Sunehri when she let slip the slightest yet one of the most apparent differences between Sunehir and Sanam which was that of Religion...And as you say Sunehri ofcourse didn't want to keep conning Rehan at that moment.
But honestly the simple truth is that for the cvs to carry on with the swap they had to make both the brothers dumb and Rehan even dumber, in this sense so they won't figure out the truth...
Edited by SheAish - 10 years ago
SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: GitaIyer

All the characters here have their share of mistakes. But Rehaan and AHil cannot be compared. Two different characters reacting to situations under different conditions. Both have their share of wrongs and reasons for it too.

Rehaan revealing himself as Tannu's son is not gonna make diff in Ahil's love for his ammi. It may get further strengthened.

Sanam too doesn't trust Ahil fully, maybe that is why she is not forthcoming with swap truth, She doesn't have faith that Ahil will believe her and wont go and reveal all to his Ammi. Seher has seen Ahil's love for Sanam, Sanam's love for Ahil, Ahil accusing Sanam and Ahil's anger on Sanam. She should reveal the swap truth to Ahil. Seher is definitely wrong there.

But Rehaan, Seher and Sanam being wrong Does not make Ahil's treatment of Sanam right? His belief in his Ammi is understandable. His ammi has spetn 12 years in prison for him. And that is a fact, which no one can deny.

And that's why its better the swap truth is not revealed to him any soon. He needs to come out of the guilt trap and see the real face of his ammi on his, without anyone showing mirror. else he will always have trust issues in future.

Lovely Post Soup.



Gita, I believe it is very unfair and cruel to not let Ahil know about the twin truth until he can figure out the real face of Ammi.

Simply because yes he worships his Ammi, but neither is he a totally brainless idiot who won't accept HARD evidence against his Ammi, whether Sanam is there with him or not...
Him siding with Sanam in many previous occasions including the stabbing at Kohinoor is clear enough proof that he had absolute trust in Sanam and without ABSOLUTE EVIDENCE AGAINST HER, Ahil would not believe Sanam capable of murder attempts had his trust not come into question due to the swap...
I know you have a different opinion about this but I just wanted to highlight this one point and then I'll leave you in peace... promise😆

See the swap did not just make him question Sanam's love for him due to the distance that Sunehri kept with Ahil...it also showed him "Sanam" behaving with Tanveer in a different manner, including ill treating her infront of his guests at the party...granted she was drunk but, anyone would know that you don't throw around some random person like that if you don't harbour pretty harsh ill feelings towards that person and you are used to behaving like that with people who cross you, just like she could not stop from showing her love for Rehan at the function while she was under the influence...

Also this small point also came to play in my opinion although lame it may sound:
Remember those last few moments when Ahil was holding her arms and looking at "Sanam" desperately to see if he should trust her or not...that was a really crucial moment...I'm sure no one could claim that Sanam would have behaved the same way as Sunehri at that moment...Where Sunehri showed disbelief, shock and perhaps anger, Sanam would have just totally broken down at that moment in front of Ahil and I'm not sure seeing the hurt and agony in Sanam's eyes he would have been able to cast her off as guilty at that moment.
But unfortunately for Ahil and Sanam, it was Sunehri 'helping' out Sanam here thus actually just her being there also contributed to total break down of trust at this crucial moment.

Edited by SheAish - 10 years ago
Raingoddess thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15
Thank you so much for this post! 👏 As Pragya said truly its refreshing and you have an impeccable writing style which I really admire! I am glad we all overcame our anger and disappointment towards ARI and have begun to think logically to defend him! I love Aahil and maybe thats where the anger came from. I was not just angry at him but angry n hurt for him and its really devastating to see what Billi does to him! From day one, I liked Rehan and it was clear that Aahil and Rehan are very different people. Aahil was shown to be a slightly ruthless, carefree rich brat while Rehan was shown to be kind, easy going and a very jovial guy. It was not until his secret during the graveyard episodes was revealed that any other information was given, though the audience has already figured it out. From there was my only issue with Rehan was him hiding the truth from Aahil. He has seen and felt guilty over Aahil's love for his Ammi yet has done nothing about it. He has heard from the cat's mouth of her lack of concern for Aahil and her plans to give Rehan the property. Not saying that Rehan wanted it, but despite knowing the truth, he has never tried to do anything. I am pretty sure the graveyard scene was not their first interaction. Its not just enough to say I am not part of this. Staying out of a crime may prevent you from being a criminal but knowing a crime is happening and stopping it makes you a good n honest person. When you know a crime is happening and you stay mum, it does make you an accomplice, especially when the person committing the crime is your mother. While its true that making Aahil see the truth would be difficult, Rehan still could have tried! He was the only person other than Billi whom Aahil trusted. As for his new plan of action, I am proud of him for taking a stand against his mother but this doesnt make him any better or any more "heroic" than Aahil. It just shows that given facts, he will side with the truth. Rehan had many facts, before and now whereas Aahil has none, yet Rehan was dragging Sanam to the outhouse and it was not until Sunehri identified herself that he reacted. I love Rehan and Shehzad was brilliant in that scene but if I can be angry at Aahil n point out his mistakes, I can very well do the same for Rehan. 😆 So while I am really excited to see what he does, I don't see how one can compare the two brothers in terms of personality and how they are reacting to the present situation. Yet people are glorifying one by bashing the other lol


I agree with each and every aspect of what you have written! I have said this many times too. Rehan had a childhood that came with its issues but is much better than what Aahil faced! Going by his interaction at the orphanage, he liked it there and probably made friends as well. He was reluctant to leave that place. Aahil on the other hand, was not only abused but made to believe that he killed his own father and has send his blind, helpless step mother in prison in place of him. Despite having wealth, he has spent nights in pain, hunger, fear and god knows what else. He has been molded into the person he is by Billi who taught him to be cold and ruthless towards his enemies. She gave him "freedom" to act as he pleases, to party, to drink, etc... He grew up with Khala n Khalu who never gave him any attention. This created the image of the rich brat ARI. But the audience and Sanam slowly saw the side of him that Billi ruthlessly tried to bury and destroy. The side that craved love, had fears and insecurties and went beyond just a golden hearted rich man! All his life there were so many question left unanswered which probably made him question his fate. Why did his father beat him? How did he end up killing someone? Why does his Ammi make him do things that are correct, because she is saying it, but doesn't agree with what his heart wants? Now to add to it, there are more questions. For example, why did the woman he loves suddenly distance herself? Why did she claim to be perfectly happy with the nikah and run away without any notice or reason? Why is she back? Why does Ammi hate her and vice versa. From the last two episodes, he just looks broke and tired and honestly its kinda scary to think what the truth will do to him. Aahil has felt rejected thus far but now he will feel deceived and betrayed by someone whom he gave away his life for. Rather than Billi sacrificing for him, Aahil had basically written his life away to her. He spent a life full of guilt, without any true love and only worshipped her, only to be betrayed. He kept his promise of not letting any woman be as important as her until Sanam came and he fell devastatingly in love with her. He trusted her and felt cared for. His view on things began to change when once again everything was snatched from him leaving him with so many questions. To add to that the constant guilt that Billi piles on him. So now for that same mother who has done so much, he has to let go of his love. While I am angry at his words, I honestly cannot blame him!
I love Aahil with his flaws, insecurities n vulnerabilities! I am very angry with him for his words but I cant hate him! I loved his character so much and still do! Aahil has many reasons to love his Ammi n the strength n extreme extent of his love was established since day one of the leap. He believes that he has killed his abusive father n then his blind step mother had to take the blame and suffer! A woman who is blind had to go to jail for him n lost many years of freedom n luxury that he feels she deserved! Honestly if he turned his back on her I would call him ungrateful. I said this many times, we know she is a devil, he doesnt! Its so devastating to see how Tanveer plays him. He has been kept in the dark by everyone and still is. So I definitely agree that Aahil has been constantly betrayed and accused by his loved ones. At the end of the day Aahil is the hero, the one full of angst, intensity n junoon! He is the tortured hero with flaws n faults n thats exactly how I love my heroes! For me, there is no comparing the two bros because they are very different! Period! I find all that comparing n glorifying really funny but hey whatever suits them lol But thanks for writing this much needed post! Excellent job! 👏

Edited by Raingoddess - 10 years ago
Raingoddess thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: -RohitMaxwell-

Sorry if you find my reply inappropriate coz everyone should be given scope for discussion thats what the discussion forums purpose... i aint seeing anyone offensively comparing Ahil vs Rehan... Didnt Ahil get a chance to use his brain? i wont say luck was only factor for Rehan. He saw Sunehri on road, later called Sanam to get confirmed... Ahil saw Sunehri in tops when Shaikhs wives came but he didnt use his brain... he was just content with Sanams reply.. he never could differentiate Sunehris behavior... during swap track... i didnt watch that time but i think he got many times to identify twins... and he is too much blinded by ammis love to even use his brain.. its Rehan who uses brain... both has different characterization to even compare... & i guess Ahil never gave Sanam a chance to explain herself... he loved... trust .. later trust went to drain... he at least could use minimum brain to get out of this trap... thats what i expected... who wont be betrayed if they are blind???


@Bold But what blinds him? Not wealth, not power but love. Love for the woman who sacrificed her life for him. Does that mean him being betrayed is ok? Does it making him deserve all that betrayal? I think you know the answer. Its unfortunate that he is blinded, not just by his Ammi but by those around him who refuse to tell the truth. Its high time the blind fold comes off.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: SheAish



Gita, I believe it is very unfair and cruel to not let Ahil know about the twin truth until he can figure out the real face of Ammi.

Simply because yes he worships his Ammi, but neither is he a totally brainless idiot who won't accept HARD evidence against his Ammi, whether Sanam is there with him or not...
Him siding with Sanam in many previous occasions including the stabbing at Kohinoor is clear enough proof that he had absolute trust in Sanam and without ABSOLUTE EVIDENCE AGAINST HER, Ahil would not believe Sanam capable of murder attempts had his trust not come into question due to the swap...
I know you have a different opinion about this but I just wanted to highlight this one point and then I'll leave you in peace... promise😆

See the swap did not just make him question Sanam's love for him due to the distance that Sunehri kept with Ahil...it also showed him "Sanam" behaving with Tanveer in a different manner, including ill treating her infront of his guests at the party...granted she was drunk but, anyone would know that you don't throw around some random person like that if you don't harbour pretty harsh ill feelings towards that person and you are used to behaving like that with people who cross you, just like she could not stop from showing her love for Rehan at the function while she was under the influence...

Also this small point also came to play in my opinion although lame it may sound:
Remember those last few moments when Ahil was holding her arms and looking at "Sanam" desperately to see if he should trust her or not...that was a really crucial moment...I'm sure no one could claim that Sanam would have behaved the same way as Sunehri at that moment...Where Sunehri showed disbelief, shock and perhaps anger, Sanam would have just totally broken down at that moment in front of Ahil and I'm not sure seeing the hurt and agony in Sanam's eyes he would have been able to cast her off as guilty at that moment.
But unfortunately for Ahil and Sanam, it was Sunehri 'helping' out Sanam here thus actually just her being there also contributed to total break down of trust at this crucial moment.


I agree with U here as well as in the response on Rehaan ...he knew the possibilities...yet even he was duped...makes him dumber..

This crucial moment take...👏👏👏

Actually what purpose did it serve o send Sehar in place of Sanam there? None other than what you pointed out...all Sehar did was pout and roll her eyes!😉..which she did brilliantly!😆
SheAish thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#18
^^ Chicksoup,
I think sending Sunehri in there at that moment was the cvs "brilliant" idea of setting the stage for the revealing of the Sunehri to Rehan...😕😆.
chicksoup thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: SheAish

^^ Chicksoup,
I think sending Sunehri in there at that moment was the cvs "brilliant" idea of setting the stage for the revealing of the Sunehri to Rehan...😕😆.


That too!😆

But seriously...Sehar was just hanging around..not helping..just staring...her lack of interest palpable..Sanam would have worried over AAhil ...tried to help in spite of being pushed away..Sehar just stood like...she was there to watch the drama...😆..and why did she walk back once Tanveer's drama was over?😆 Sanam would have stayed on to make sure AAhil was fine to..there is a big difference between how the twins want the revenge...Sanam cannot see AAhil hurt...she wants Bili to be exposed..Sehar wouldn't care, unless it was for Sanam...every time AAhil hurts for his ammi, Sanam hurts with him..whereas Sehar yawns!😆
GitaIyer thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: SheAish



Gita, I believe it is very unfair and cruel to not let Ahil know about the twin truth until he can figure out the real face of Ammi.
I know lot of things have been unfair and cruel on varying degrees on all the four protagonists. All 4 have suffered due to Tanveer and also due to each other.

Simply because yes he worships his Ammi, but neither is he a totally brainless idiot who won't accept HARD evidence against his Ammi, whether Sanam is there with him or not...
Him siding with Sanam in many previous occasions including the stabbing at Kohinoor is clear enough proof that he had absolute trust in Sanam and without ABSOLUTE EVIDENCE AGAINST HER, Ahil would not believe Sanam capable of murder attempts had his trust not come into question due to the swap...
I know you have a different opinion about this but I just wanted to highlight this one point and then I'll leave you in peace... promise😆
Your point taken. 😊 But I still believe things would've reached this stage for Saahil irrespective of the swap, maybe a lil later. Billi wouldn't have let Saahil in peace. But no point in arguing over what could've happened or not. Ok, now I too will leave you in peace.😉

See the swap did not just make him question Sanam's love for him due to the distance that Sunehri kept with Ahil...it also showed him "Sanam" behaving with Tanveer in a different manner, including ill treating her infront of his guests at the party...granted she was drunk but, anyone would know that you don't throw around some random person like that if you don't harbour pretty harsh ill feelings towards that person and you are used to behaving like that with people who cross you, just like she could not stop from showing her love for Rehan at the function while she was under the influence...
True that. An intoxicated Sanam back then would've just danced and not thrown around Tanveer. 😆. Maybe she would have. SHe knew the Nawab truth by then (though not asya truth). And before Kohinoor, she had challenged Tanveer too. So, internally, she would've been harboring hatred for Tanveer for destroying Ahil's life. And under intoxication, the hatred would've shown. Maybe or maybe not. Again its just guesswork on both our parts.
Also this small point also came to play in my opinion although lame it may sound:
Remember those last few moments when Ahil was holding her arms and looking at "Sanam" desperately to see if he should trust her or not...that was a really crucial moment...I'm sure no one could claim that Sanam would have behaved the same way as Sunehri at that moment...Where Sunehri showed disbelief, shock and perhaps anger, Sanam would have just totally broken down at that moment in front of Ahil and I'm not sure seeing the hurt and agony in Sanam's eyes he would have been able to cast her off as guilty at that moment.
But unfortunately for Ahil and Sanam, it was Sunehri 'helping' out Sanam here thus actually just her being there also contributed to total break down of trust at this crucial moment.
Sending Sunehri at that moment was stupidity by twins. It didnt serve any purpose. As you said, it set the scene for Sehaan reunion.
In fact Tanveer was counting on Ahil falling for Sanam's tears yet again, Hence her dialog "Ahil uski massom chehre pe mat jao".
Maybe Sanam's breakdown would've softened Ahil, and he may have believed Sanam to be innocent. Lots of Mays.😉
But my question is does Sanam have to be injured or broken down or suffering for Ahil to believe her. He needs to believe her without Rehaan showing proofs and in spite of Billi's brainwashing. For this he needs the nawab truth. Swap truth can only ensure current Saahil reunion. But He has to decipher the Nawab truth and unmask his Ammi so that he can be freed from the guilt trap and set stage for permanent Saahil reunion. Oh I forgot Sanam2.

It was nice chatting on characters and story and different POVs.
Have a good day.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".