Logic Hunters - CC (Revamped) - Page 114

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

Hey Sru..I just wrote an emotional rant on my damaged baby Asad in Sangeeta di's thread😆

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

Ya man...he is really damaged and the forum is busy glorifying Zoe🥱

I posted this on two threads..tell me if this makes sense😆

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

I posted this on two threads..tell me if this makes sense😆

I for one do not get the stand the characters and the forum want to take...

If the marriage is valid in the eyes of all...Asad did nothing wrong...he did not trade or loan Zoya...he by no means could allow another's wife to stay in his house...uptil here he thinks the marriage is valid...even if accidental

When he goes to SM..he sees the Qazis there..who officiate an already invalid marriage...coz they have all forgotten..Zoya's abbu's name was wrong...

So safe to say at this point of time...all three of them think it's valid and none of them know that they have signed on a divorce paper..and they are sure it's a temporary arrangement...Asad was not aware of this until Ayaan told him..mostly because Zoe told him it will be tough to return from where he is sending her..marriage means a lot to her

In that case Asad did no wrong..he only left Zoya at her husband's place...when Zoe's screaming a refusal in front of the Qazi's should have made it invalid right away, it wasn't done...who is Asad to give into her demand even if she says she does not consider this a marriage? Ayaan came and told him that it's temporary and he wants to let Zoya know...that's it...but Zoe already considers this temporary..

When Ayaan and Zoe do not share a room, are taking this as a farce..how does Asad talking to Zoe labelled as infidelity? Aren't Ayaan and Humz thinking of each other?

We all need to decide...if it's valid then Asad is not wrong in leaving Zoe there..and if it is invalid then there is no infidelity involved...Asad being wrong and it being infidelity cannot happen at the same time...

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

Oh man..Whats all this talk about infidelity? I don watch the show and you managed to confuse me further😆

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

😆..even i do not see it re...but it seems that Asad called Zoya up...so it seems that's infidelity...now read and tell if it makes sense😆

Originally posted by: rogerrocks

Ah i get it..Ok IMO even if Asad thought the marriage is valid, he had no right to force his opinion on Zoya..Its Zoya's life and her decision to make..If he thought the nikah is valid, its totally his prerogative to refuse to get married to her..But he had no right to dump her on Ayaan..Zoya on the other hand always speaks out of turn and never really bothers to listen to Asad..So i don get what made her shut up and go with the flow😕 Even now, i don get why she keeps ranting instead of leaving right away..Not to Asad's house but to NY..She is supposed to an independent girl..I think they both are being totally dumb and silly & this forced arrangement is illogical as hell😕😆

About the call, i guess Asad doesn't exactly see her as Ayaan's wife and still thinks its a temporary arrangement..So i guess its fine to call her😆 In fact, i do believe that the moment he thinks this marriage is for real, he'l distance himself from Zoya..And think its totally Zoya's prerogative not not pick his call..So yeah, why are people debating over this?😆 The story itself is illogical dammit😆

Originally posted by: starsinmyeyes

I posted this on two threads..tell me if this makes sense😆

I for one do not get the stand the characters and the forum want to take...

If the marriage is valid in the eyes of all...Asad did nothing wrong...he did not trade or loan Zoya...he by no means could allow another's wife to stay in his house...uptil here he thinks the marriage is valid...even if accidental

When he goes to SM..he sees the Qazis there..who officiate an already invalid marriage...coz they have all forgotten..Zoya's abbu's name was wrong...

So safe to say at this point of time...all three of them think it's valid and none of them know that they have signed on a divorce paper..and they are sure it's a temporary arrangement...Asad was not aware of this until Ayaan told him..mostly because Zoe told him it will be tough to return from where he is sending her..marriage means a lot to her

In that case Asad did no wrong..he only left Zoya at her husband's place...when Zoe's screaming a refusal in front of the Qazi's should have made it invalid right away, it wasn't done...who is Asad to give into her demand even if she says she does not consider this a marriage? Ayaan came and told him that it's temporary and he wants to let Zoya know...that's it...but Zoe already considers this temporary..

When Ayaan and Zoe do not share a room, are taking this as a farce..how does Asad talking to Zoe labelled as infidelity? Aren't Ayaan and Humz thinking of each other?

We all need to decide...if it's valid then Asad is not wrong in leaving Zoe there..and if it is invalid then there is no infidelity involved...Asad being wrong and it being infidelity cannot happen at the same time...

If I can answer this
Marriage valid invalid is debatable so we will leave it
Yes he cannot have another person s wife in his place he could have thrown her out but no he forced her to stay in Ayan s house without asking her permission that makes it loan trade
Staying with hubby or not is totally zoya s wish and again making her sign those papers is again bad on his part

Next he stopped dilshad questioning ayans family stating she is ayans wife now

I feel cvs are responsible here they are neither clear with what they want or what to show
They just want zoyaan now so all illogical screenplay

I am not a zoya fan but different situation will arise where zoya will choose her dad over asad then we will criticize zoya

Originally posted by: nebuna

If I can answer this
Marriage valid invalid is debatable so we will leave it
Yes he cannot have another person s wife in his place he could have thrown her out but no he forced her to stay in Ayan s house without asking her permission that makes it loan trade
Staying with hubby or not is totally zoya s wish and again making her sign those papers is again bad on his part

Next he stopped dilshad questioning ayans family stating she is ayans wife now

I feel cvs are responsible here they are neither clear with what they want or what to show
They just want zoyaan now so all illogical screenplay

I am not a zoya fan but different situation will arise where zoya will choose her dad over asad then we will criticize zoya

The writers are confused..Bas😆 They are keeping it open ended so that they can take it whichever way they want depending on the TRPs😆 So what if the leads are butchered or the characters appear dumb and confused in the process😆