From a VIEWER's and from a WRITER's view!-EDITED - Page 2

Originally posted by: Joavssk9

hey thanks -ElmoFuj

Originally posted by: Noe123

Appreciate your views and yes, it is clear that from the very start we have been given hints about a possible triangle.

But, I do have a problem with this triangle if it involves Ayaan-Zoya marriage, because I feel that is so against the character of Zoya. Zoya believes in marriage and believes in keeping the wedding wows. And, Asad and Zoya are exactly same in this matter. Asad won't do a 'fake' engagement even with Zoya, because he considers it a sacred ceremony and a commitment for lifetime. Today when he will put ring in her finger, he won't verbalize it, but will silently commit himself to her forever. And, it seems that Zoya is ok with fake drama, but deep down she knows what she feels about Asad and that's why she goes along with it. Do you think Asad would do something like this for Tanveer even if his beloved ammi asked to do so? And, do you think Zoya would agree for such an arrangement with Ayaan? I don't think so. Asad and Zoya's fake agreement has more truth that many other peoples's real relationships. It is not enough for me that Zoya won't love Ayaan ever. Yes, I know she will never love Ayaan, but the words 'Qubool Hain' have an halo around them and they are the corner stones of the show. Neither Zoya nor Asad will utter these words without meaning them.

Thanks to Ekta, Indian TV has trivialized marriage, divorce, affairs, kids-out-of-wedlock. But, they are not trivial. These things happen. They can have reasons behind them. Sometimes they seem wrong but are the most real things. But..but..but, they affect people. They change lives. And, most of the times things never go back to being same, like Rashid-Dilshaad & Shireen. Playing musical chair with life partners is Ekta's game and I hope Gul knows better.

From the writers' point of view, you have raised two important points;

- Asad and Zoya need to understand each other's importance. They need to get separated, miss each other, pine for each other, learn to value each other and come back together stronger. But, instead of Ayaan-Zoya marriage track, a track - which several forum members have predicted - of Asad coming to know that Zoya belongs to enemy blood and the conflict that he will go through and what Zoya will go through - has lot more potential and has unique flavor to it.

- Ayaan needs to grow up. He needs to do something for his brother, for his family, for Humeira. I understand that if he falls in love with Zoya and sacrifices her for Asad, it will be big. But, there can be other ways to make him grow up - Humeria's illness, Shireen's death (I have a feeling Shireen will die eventually). Writers can get creative, that's what they are there for. If he falls in love with Zoya and sacrifices his love before it ever reaches marriage, I am fine with that.

Originally posted by: sree07

Wonderfully written. 👏

Gul always makes it a point that she tells us the theme of her story in the first few episodes itself. Be it ipk or be it QH, She had set the theme already. We just have to see the initial episodes where ayan says 'i think a girl will come between us' and the camera focuses on Zoya standing between the brothers. There she sets the theme.

So now when the story is going steady and when it is approaching its one of the high points, i think its better not to fret. Just enjoy Gul's magic.

Originally posted by: blessing-beauty

Very well written post :) the writeer needs to give a chance to show what they have to show :) otherwise if we viewers interfere it might ruin things :) I have been saying this ever scene QH start...Go wid the flow of the show and let the makers n writers show what they have planned. They r telling us a story :)