Arshad as director for Qubool Hai

qent thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#1
Lalit Mohan is the current director of the programme and he is doing an excellent job. Gul's direction has also been very good. Can anyone please tell me if Arshad is also directing Qubool hai at the moment or if Lalit Mohan is directing the programme by himself? What do you think about him as a director? I still remember how badly he messed up Iss Pyaar Ko Kya Naam Doon after Lalit Mohan left. The show became rather boring. What are your opinions?
Edited by qent - 12 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.9k

Users

8

Likes

20

Frequent Posters

210272 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
lalit Mohan is directing, can you tell me how he is I heard lots of praises of him
qent thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I guess Arshad is praised for directing dramatic scenes but doesn't anyone agree that IPKKND did become less interesting after Lalit Mohan left? Did no one notice even the slightest bit of change? By the way is Arshad directing Qubool Hai with Lalit Mohan or is Lalit directing it by himself?
Edited by qent - 12 years ago
Jayne thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#4
A movie is a director's baby...they know the complete story and can set the tone right from the beginning shot.

A director for daily soap operas can only do so much...the continuing story has to be good...and Arshad Khan got a crappy storyline to work with once Lalit Mohan left in IPK (Feb onwards - the Swami track, the businessmen frauds, etc.)

The director for QH is listed as Lalit Mohan Sharma... I wonder if this is an attempt to distinguish between two people with names of Lalit Mohan, or if it is the same guy just adding on another name at the end.

Either way, I think the direction so far is just fair... with moments of being either very good or very bad. It does falter here and there, i.e. scenes that could be shown with more depth don't make much of an impression, but one never knows who has directed which scene. From what I understand, when one director leaves /finishes their shift, the other takes over.

Too many cooks spoiling the broth?

Jayne

Edited by Jayne - 12 years ago
Gurmeet4Drashti thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#5
Hey ...
Arshad directed some amazing scenes in QH ... As well as Iss pyaar Ko ...
N Lalit is also a fantastic director ...
I'm enjoying the show as of now ... :-)
shanakyasharan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#6
arshad, lalit n gul all 3 r directing.saw arshad during mangalpur scene videos..
626918 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#7
Lalit Mohan is an amazing director and he is doing an amazing job with QH... As far as IPK is concerned, well it was good till February last year when Lalit Mohan left and Arshad made IPK hell... Lot of people think IPK shut down because of fans but no...l it shut down because it really sucked... I don't think anyone can deny the fact that the serial lost its charm and it's story after February...

I'm not saying that Arshad is a bad director... But I think when a director first starts directing something, he should complete it and not leave it half way because only the director who starts off with it knows the story and understands the character the best because technically they are the ones who are the first ones to establish the characters and story in the way it is in the beginning and that's how the audience sees it... When you change directors half way, they bring their own vision in which is evident to the audience and they don't like it... It makes the story and characters inconsistent and choppy... Arshad is a great director and so is Lalit Mohan... They both have great potential to produce great work but I feel that since Kalit Mohan started directing, he should stay till the end..

This is a huge reason why IPK went to the garbage... It really sucked and was painful to watch after February because of director change... The story became sloppy and it lost its track... Hence why it ended up where it did...

I hope it doesn't happen with QH
Edited by Tanvi_124 - 12 years ago
anihabhi thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: Jayne

<font color="#0000CC" face="Geneva, Arial, Helvetica, sans-serif" size="3">A movie is a director's baby...they know the complete story and can set the tone right from the beginning shot.

A director for daily soap operas can only do so much...the continuing story has to be good...and Arshad Khan got a crappy storyline to work with once Lalit Mohan left in IPK (Feb onwards - the Swami track, the businessmen frauds, etc.)

The director for QH is listed as Lalit Mohan Sharma... I wonder if this is an attempt to distinguish between two people with names of Lalit Mohan, or if it is the same guy just adding on another name at the end.

Either way, I think the direction so far is just fair... with moments<font size="3"> of being either very good or very bad</font>. It does falter here and there, i.e. scenes that could be shown with more depth don't make much of an <font size="3">impression</font>, but one never knows who has directed which scene. From what I <font size="3">understand</font>, when one director leaves /finishes their shift, the other takes over.

<font size="3">Too many cooks spoiling <font size="3">the</font> broth?</font>

Jayne
</font>



Exactly because of those crappy tracks Lilith left ipk but arshad was there till d end..I don't know why people never recognize him.. He is very gud at intense scenes..now I guess Lalith is directing with arshad..there is no such diff that we could say Lalith is directing d show..arshad is really good..with out Lalith also arshad could have made all these scenes wonderful..by d way arshad is really gud at romantic n emotional scenes..
Edited by swathikogchint - 12 years ago
Kv89 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#9
Hi !dis is d dirst time i am commenting😉i guess both r good:-)I hav followed ipk from almost d beginning to the end.i hav been watching qubool hai from epi-1!.if u take arshad's capacities as a director,he's simply awesome in creating scenes,which are emotional,involve a lot of acting nd extracting it from d actor!well fr example-arnav's high point in ipk,khushi's breakdown,anjali's breakdown,especially scenes like d one in which ,khushi brings arnav from d kidnap nd widout words ,these two express a lot.nd lalit mohan, I believe is a director, who simply believes in logic!he can direct scenes which hav no content nd still make it look magical!for example,if u take d almost kiss scene,karvachauth scene, dese r simply scenes which v 😊hav seen in many serials,bt to create dat impact nd intensity,it takes lalit mohan:)Also if u hav seen d lag jaa gale scene,which has gul directing it,she made the simple steps btwn yash nd aarti,look like dey wr on their honeymoon!such is d impact of a director:)

Getting d mood right fr d actors,extracting exactly Wat they visualise,making wise decisions in d story nd putting life to screenplay nd grooming them in their characters.such is their work nd all three are more than explainably good:-)
Such is d impact of a 4 lions show,making u want for more :)😊

Related Topics

Qubool Hai thumbnail

Posted by: jyoti06 · 7 years ago

Qubool Hai C r e a t i o n s G a l l e r y # 21 _______________________________________________________________ Please post all your creations

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".