Divya's honesty, Sarita's evolution - My take

ruchisahay thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#1

Divya was back to being honest - to herself, to Gaurav, to Raj and Kamla. That got me wondering - was she ever dishonest even when she lied to Raj (about Sarita's impending death)? We all know that her intent and her feelings were always honest. We all thought her lying to Raj was against the character and morally wrong. But today when I thought back I realized that maybe she did it because it was the right thing to do. Being honest is not exactly a function of speaking the absolute truth always. She wanted Raj to confront the guilt and accountabilities he was ignoring for a long long time. We also know that Raj values life and understands physical hurt and danger far better than emotional abuse. So, maybe lying to him is the only thing that would have worked and since Divya honestly wanted things to work out, she lied.

I faced something a little similar last week - I needed to start my 2 year old kid in playgroup. First 2 days were a nightmare, he howled and screamed and I was in tears myself (listening to his cries from outside his school gate) and picked him up pretty quickly. I had almost decided to drop the idea for now when his teacher asked me to stay with him at school for next 2 days. I did that. After those 2 days, I told my kid that I was going to use the washroom, even handed him my car keys (which his teacher later smuggled to me). We continued this way for next 3 days - my kid was very secured thinking I was close by and happily mingled with his teachers and other kids. Yesterday, I told him I needed to go for grocery shopping and would return pretty quickly to get him - he was completely okay with that. So, that little lie prevented a lot of sorrow and tears both for my kid and me. It was lying but was it a betrayal and morally incorrect?
Isn't that similar to what Divya did. With purest of intentions, she did what would work. I personally don't think she was ever dishonest. And I absolutely loved when she broke her Gaurva's engagement. It would have been very dishonest to marry him in her current state.
Coming to Sarita - from a woman blinded by her own pain, immersed completely in her own goals, she became this new person who acknowledged others, was decisive and no longer afraid to face the world. Though her world continues to revolve around Raj and her asking Raj to select a groom for her does not sit well with me, I can live with it. After all, evolution is life long process, you can't have all of it in a day.
She wants Raj's happiness, no two ways about that but I don't think she is disregarding Divya's feelings either. Haven't we all accused her of being oblivious to Divya's pain - well today she wasn't. Hasn't Divya herself given enough hints that she is not over Raj (by confessing to Sarita how tough it was for her, by rushing to Raj's first-aid when she saw him in pain, by multiple slips about how she and Raj used to be)? I think Sarita was trying to do for Divya what Divya had tried to do earlier. She wanted to give back their lives (exactly as it would have been if Sarita wasn't there). Her disregard for Gaurav was jarring, but so was Divya's lack of concern when she had walked out of her wedding without any prior explanation. Maybe, since Gaurav is not a main character, CVs consider his fate and feelings inconsequential. So, both female leads act accordingly 😊.
I also loved that she voiced what she wanted and is no longer trying to hide anything from others - out of fear or embarrassment. This Sarita is far easier to fall in love with. In fact, I had always sympathized with Sarita - today I really liked her.
Since I am in admiring and forgiving mode, I will not talk about others including Raj of course 😃

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

852

Users

3

Likes

12

Frequent Posters

aimf thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#2
wonderful post, very nicely expressed.
Myra.nelly thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#3
I guess thats why my parents never sent me to preschool 😆
Coming to Divya, she always knew shes doing wrong by lying but that was the best way to make him react, what can b more shattering than someones death...but it wasnt right coz besides waking him up she had another reason, him to fall for sarita, and that was the real manipulation...
ruchisahay thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Myra.nelly

I guess thats why my parents never sent me to preschool 😆
Coming to Divya, she always knew shes doing wrong by lying but that was the best way to make him react, what can b more shattering than someones death...but it wasnt right coz besides waking him up she had another reason, him to fall for sarita, and that was the real manipulation...

😆
Manipulation yes. But Raj gave her that kind of power over himself and he had been walking the path of self-destruction / self-pity for last 10 years. Looking at the kind of person Raj is (the one who does not understand anyone's emotional pain), would any other way work? In the larger interest of making Raj come out of that mode and accept the reality, it was a necessity. Divya had both their best interests in her heart and so I don't find her dishonest. I don't think she was trying to make him fall for Sarita through that prophecy - it was more to make him aware of Sarita's pain and acknowledge his own responsibility to her.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".