pratha is not samar singh’s wife!

hey guys,

today i had hindi extra class in skewl..n we were doing a lesson called"swaraajya ki neev"..n it was a kinda history lesson..so our teacher to make things lighter was telling us rajput tales!!:D ..in tht she started talkng abt samar singh n said tht samar singh's wife was PADMINI the most beautiful princess on earth!!n it seems there is a famous fort called"chittor ka kila" n muhammad ghori(2) attacked tht fort....i dunno how far it is true..but my hindi teacher is a major in history also..n she herself is from rajasthan..n u know wat?? a female in r class watches PRC n she LOOOVES samar singh..the minute our teacher mentioned samar singh's name she was totalllllly blushing..n her face had becum red!!!:D ...neways shyama..u tell.... i'm confused abt who is samar's real wife!!

noways padmini was wife of some another king i had recently visited to chittor n there it was told tht padmini was wife of some king i dont remember the name

hi cool raddy
i m rashi
plz tel me ur name

As far as I have heard, Rani Padmini was Rana Ratan sen's(of chittorhgarh) wife.

Also I have heard Samar singh came much later to the time of PRC.

now i m totally confused abt history. according 2 'Prithviraj raso ka adhyan' by Dr.Vijay Kulshestra. samar singh marry pratha. I got this info from some one else, but donno someone else also told the same

hey guys,

today i had hindi extra class in skewl..n we were doing a lesson called"swaraajya ki neev"..n it was a kinda history lesson..so our teacher to make things lighter was telling us rajput tales!!:D ..in tht she started talkng abt samar singh n said tht samar singh's wife was PADMINI the most beautiful princess on earth!!n it seems there is a famous fort called"chittor ka kila" n muhammad ghori(2) attacked tht fort....i dunno how far it is true..but my hindi teacher is a major in history also..n she herself is from rajasthan..n u know wat?? a female in r class watches PRC n she LOOOVES samar singh..the minute our teacher mentioned samar singh's name she was totalllllly blushing..n her face had becum red!!!:D ...neways shyama..u tell.... i'm confused abt who is samar's real wife!!


wahah she was blushing..?whahaah i should haf been thr to see her face! it wld haf been sooo funn! haha but niway... i don actually know the story.. so .. :D thnx 4 letting me know!

hey guys,

today i had hindi extra class in skewl..n we were doing a lesson called"swaraajya ki neev"..n it was a kinda history lesson..so our teacher to make things lighter was telling us rajput tales!!:D ..in tht she started talkng abt samar singh n said tht samar singh's wife was PADMINI the most beautiful princess on earth!!n it seems there is a famous fort called"chittor ka kila" n muhammad ghori(2) attacked tht fort....i dunno how far it is true..but my hindi teacher is a major in history also..n she herself is from rajasthan..n u know wat?? a female in r class watches PRC n she LOOOVES samar singh..the minute our teacher mentioned samar singh's name she was totalllllly blushing..n her face had becum red!!!:D ...neways shyama..u tell.... i'm confused abt who is samar's real wife!!
wah !!!! she was blushing !!! waise this history is really confusing hai na ??

Oh c'mon Radhika....do you honestly think that the Maharajas in those times had ONE wife??:p They had many...but some were more renowned.....so,we know only them....as for the fact that Pratha was Samar Singh's wife,its true;as I got it from a book.."The Tales Of Rajput Chivalry"....so its not false!!!;)

Oh c'mon Radhika....do you honestly think that the Maharajas in those times had ONE wife??:p They had many...but some were more renowned.....so,we know only them....as for the fact that Pratha was Samar Singh's wife,its true;as I got it from a book.."The Tales Of Rajput Chivalry"....so its not false!!!;)


god u guyz r so interested in history!!:eek: i'm kinda shocked to see that!!u know what,i hate history like anything,i mean studying history but watching it is u know kinda fine to me!!lol!!

pri

hey guys,

today i had hindi extra class in skewl..n we were doing a lesson called"swaraajya ki neev"..n it was a kinda history lesson..so our teacher to make things lighter was telling us rajput tales!!:D ..in tht she started talkng abt samar singh n said tht samar singh's wife was PADMINI the most beautiful princess on earth!!n it seems there is a famous fort called"chittor ka kila" n muhammad ghori(2) attacked tht fort....i dunno how far it is true..but my hindi teacher is a major in history also..n she herself is from rajasthan..n u know wat?? a female in r class watches PRC n she LOOOVES samar singh..the minute our teacher mentioned samar singh's name she was totalllllly blushing..n her face had becum red!!!:D ...neways shyama..u tell.... i'm confused abt who is samar's real wife!!


yes u are right my dear, pratha is not at all samar's wife.Samar singh had changed himself after prc made him realised who is and what is king? i dunt know from where this confusion is flowing from,well ur story is perfect samar's wife is not at all pratha.
shayama

hey guys,

today i had hindi extra class in skewl..n we were doing a lesson called"swaraajya ki neev"..n it was a kinda history lesson..so our teacher to make things lighter was telling us rajput tales!!:D ..in tht she started talkng abt samar singh n said tht samar singh's wife was PADMINI the most beautiful princess on earth!!n it seems there is a famous fort called"chittor ka kila" n muhammad ghori(2) attacked tht fort....i dunno how far it is true..but my hindi teacher is a major in history also..n she herself is from rajasthan..n u know wat?? a female in r class watches PRC n she LOOOVES samar singh..the minute our teacher mentioned samar singh's name she was totalllllly blushing..n her face had becum red!!!:D ...neways shyama..u tell.... i'm confused abt who is samar's real wife!!



yes u are right my dear, pratha is not at all samar's wife.Samar singh had changed himself after prc made him realised who is and what is king? i dunt know from where this confusion is flowing from,well ur story is perfect samar's wife is not at all pratha.although in ancient years many kings had more than one wife.but prc or rana pratap had only one.even ,the story i know is that samar also had one wife.may be he loved one but he had only one wife.
shayma

Arrey noooo.....Samar Singh had many wives and and among them Pratha was one......if you ever have the chance to read Todd's "Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan" or the other bk which I mentioned,you'll find its True!!!!:o

still i m confused.

According to 'Prithviraj raso ka adhyan' by Dr.Vijay Kulshestra.
D id ull know that Sanyogita was prithvi's 7th wife
she was d 3rd 1 whom he kidnapped n married.
he marrid Jammavati wen he was 16 [kidnp]
2. Inchini who was bhim devs wifes sis & b.d wanted 2 marry her
3.Padmavati [kidnp]she had heard abt pr5ithvi from a parrot so it is said in d book
4.shasivruta he claimed a war 2 marry her
5.indravati{ i think she was bhims daughter}
6.hansavati
7.sanyogita. Inchini was very angry abt this marraige she was actuaally leaving d house
It is also written tat samas singh married Pratha prithvis sis
pundir has his head cut in 1 of d wars
Inchini saved prithvi number of times
d part abt sanjam was: prithvi was fallen ver badly hurt. eagles were trying 2 eat his eyes but sanjam gives his own flesh 2 d birds n saves prithvi.he gets a part of prithvis rajya for this" .

I got another info from another site. there they says there is different different versions. it is here u may like to know tat (ref: http://www.the-week.com/24feb22/currentevents_article10.html )

Prithviraj Chauhan-Samyogita
Forbidden love
Tales of yore thrived on bloody wars and lovelorn hearts. It is small wonder then that bards loved to sing of the love between the warrior Prithviraj Chauhan and the ravishing princess Samyogita.

Prithviraj, heir to the Chauhan dynasty, succeeded to the throne of Delhi after the demise of his father, Anangpal, in the latter half of the 12th century. His exploits are recorded in the Prithviraj Raso, a work by Chand Bardai, believed to be his court poet.

The story goes that the Chauhan dynasty was not on good terms with the nearby Gahadawala dynasty. Things would have been uncom-plicated had not Samyogita, daughter of king Jayachandra of Gahadawala, fallen in love with Prithviraj. Though she had never seen him, she had fallen in love with the tales of his bravery and decided to marry no one but him. Soon fate forced her hand.

Jayachandra had decided to celebrate winning a series of wars. He decided to use the occasion to hold a swayamvara and he invited all the neighbouring kings except Prithviraj. To add insult to injury, his statue, in the garb of a dwarapala (watchman), was erected at the doorway.

Samyogita was devastated. She wrote to Prithviraj, baring her heart, and asked him to come and claim her as his bride. He came incognito and hid behind the statue of himself. When the swayamvara began, Samyogita, not seeing her lover, garlanded the statue. At that, Prithviraj stepped out from the shadows and carried her away, after defeating those who opposed him.

A furious Jayachandra followed with his army. But in the fierce battle that ensued (some say it took place after the first battle of Tarain where Prithviraj defeated Muhammad Ghori, thus establishing the time as between 1190-92), he was defeated.

But this is where the romance ends. Many historians question the authenticity of Samyogita. According to D.C. Ganguly, the author of The Age of Prithviraj III (Bharatiya Vidya Bhavan's History and Culture of Indian People), the details of the marriage given in Prithviraj Raso are so improbable that its authenticity may be reasonably doubted. Roma Niyogi, another historian, offers a different viewpoint in History of Gahadawala Dynasty. "Though the story by Chand Bardai is romantically appealing, it is not corroborated by any authentic evidence," says Niyogi.

R.B. Somani thinks otherwise. In his book Prithviraj Chauhan and His Times, he has cited the four points on which the authenticity of Samyogita has been challenged:

u Prithviraj Raso is full of inaccuracies.
u Prithviraj Vijay (a more reliable work, which refers to Prithviraj's marriage with a princess of extraordinary beauty) does not speak about Samyogita by name.
u Other contemporary Persian works do not quote any incident of abduction.
u Two other works-Rambha Manjiri and Hamir Mahakavya-are silent about Samyogita.

Somani feels that the authenticity of characters popularly known through the centuries cannot be challenged on the basis of negative evidence alone. He says that the Prithviraj Vijay refers to Prithviraj falling in love with Tilottama, a heavenly nymph, who is reborn as a princess to marry him. This is similar to the Raso, which says that Samyogita, in her previous birth, was a heavenly nymph named Rambha.

Furthermore, both Tilottama and Samyogita are said to have fallen in love without seeing Prithviraj in person; and they both lived on the banks of the Ganga-Samyogita lived in Benares. "Both these characters are somewhat analogous," says Somani. "Though not the sole proof, this gives us an idea that there is some res-emblance between the story of Samyogita referred to in Prithviraj Raso and Tilottama mentioned in Prithviraj Vijay."

Whatever be the truth, for lovers everywhere it is the romance that counts. Let it rest at that.

Pundir will hav his head cut off??:(
sob.sob:(

Pundir will hav his head cut off??:(
sob.sob:(
I have decided tat i will not read anymore article on it. bcoz it has many versions n many confusion. so better i should wait 4 the show. wat was the real picture don't know. today i read another article abt how prc was captured. they fought from morning 2 don but ghori cd not able 2 catch him though ghori attacked him when everybody was sleeping n hindu didn't figt don or dusk. then ghori offered mard-a- mard fight n offer prc in tat way he cd save his solder. prc agreed but it was a trap. after fighting sometimes kutubuddin cut the leg of prc's horse n he fall down. then they give sign 2 their solder 2 come n captured him. but i don't blief this story also. i don't think prc did this. it is impossible. i wanted 2 the history but never undersant it will tat kind of a complecated story.

I have decided tat i will not read anymore article on it. bcoz it has many versions n many confusion. so better i should wait 4 the show. wat was the real picture don't know. today i read another article abt how prc was captured. they fought from morning 2 don but ghori cd not able 2 catch him though ghori attacked him when everybody was sleeping n hindu didn't figt don or dusk. then ghori offered mard-a- mard fight n offer prc in tat way he cd save his solder. prc agreed but it was a trap. after fighting sometimes kutubuddin cut the leg of prc's horse n he fall down. then they give sign 2 their solder 2 come n captured him. but i don't blief this story also. i don't think prc did this. it is impossible. i wanted 2 the history but never undersant it will tat kind of a complecated story.

everythin soo confusing