642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Sorry.

But the show is boring, inconsistent and not coherent in its story, narrative and characters now.

It's failing to justify itself from history POV.

As fiction it is still worse nowadays as story is overturned, characters are shown one day and disappear other day.

Same kind of ads and precaps.

And can someone tell me what's with the sepia-type tone in all scenes? Everything looks yello be it inside or outside, day time or night time, humans, animals or objects!

What have they done to Pratap's training and developing friendship with Bhils and Rana Punja?

There was a time when I'd watch each episode eagerly with rapt attention, drop everything to watch only this with full concentration. Now? It's a bore!

New actors are listless too except Rao Surtan and Bairam Khan.

The engagement and connect is no longer what it was till a month ago.

Many questions arise on how they handle things be it history-wise or even logically.

Like how JB didn't recognise Panna earlier but sudenly recognised her later. And how she knew details of US being saved by Panna? Or why US didn't keep Panna with him? She wasn't there at that time! So she knew it as folktale or family gossip?

Whatever! Show is meh now. And the pale yellow tone everywhere irks me a lot! It's almost distracting.

Created

Last reply

Replies

18

Views

2k

Users

12

Likes

25

Frequent Posters

bitblue thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
For me its still worth watching. i would prefer to watch this show over all other shows are coming. but yes do agree with you as other actors work is so promising any new entry needed to be prepared form day one.
I hope they show pratap more organized then just one man army all the time.
but sill love this show 😉
Edited by bitblue - 11 years ago
Proud-India thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
I still love the show.We can't expect always more.

Sorry to say but i can see from last 1.5 months you are thinking too negative for show Be Positive.

And do not expect that as you want to see they will show like that.

As per example you want to see JB as former queen but they will not show like that It is writers,directors point.

Sorry if you feel bad
Justitia thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Proud-India

I still love the show.We can't expect always more.

Sorry to say but i can see from last 1.5 months you are thinking too negative for show Be Positive.

And do not expect that as you want to see they will show like that.

As per example you want to see JB as former queen but they will not show like that It is writers,directors point.

Sorry if you feel bad


As per my personal viewpoint, I agree with @Skepblun. When you have so many questions about the story like where are Sajjabai & Shakti right now, what is going on with their life, why have the writers suddenly made JB seem so frightened of DB, etc., it does seem extremely frustrating when these questions don't get answered for weeks together.

Yes, I can perfectly understand that the director/writers might have their own reasons for twisting and changing JB's personality so much & making her so scared of DB - even if JB's present behaviour is MOST unlike that of a Rajputani & a Kshatraani. But then, at least, give the viewer some clues as to what JB's plan really is against DB. First she asks Pratap to be banished from palace, and then she wants to make him take "oath" of not touching weapons!!! Yes, all this might seem entertaining and all, but what's the point of putting in so many multiple plots when the viewer is left completely confused about what is exactly being shown?

I know some viewers don't like to analyze TV shows and movies while watching, they just "watch" it. But there are others (like me, for instance), who like to analyze and completely understand what is being shown, so that the story makes sense.

And, if certain questions about the plot don't get answered for weeks together OR if there is some kind of difference between what is being shown and what happened historically, watching the show does seem frustrating to a great extent. I have now started following only the WUs as a result of it.

Like I said, this is my personal opinion only. If you like the show, you are perfectly entitled to your views as well.
Edited by shani88 - 11 years ago
Proud-India thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
We will get surely answers in nearest future.

There is big creative team + history finding team + Great writers...They have knowledge of history better than us.

We have many new twist & turns to watch...We can't leave show at middle.

When generation leap will be occurred it will be more interesting
ak75 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
I find the Rao Surtan track boring. But then every serial has ups and downs. So this phase will pass . I am waiting for something more interesting.
642126 thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
Manan

I am not negative. I am only saying things as they are in my opinion as a viewer.

A lot of costume dramas on Doordarshan were also badly handled but none so incoherent after showing a lot pf promise like MP.

I don't believe in things like we must have faith in team or stick to the show.

They are not functioning to the standard they were once earlier.

Tracks are starting and ending abruptly.

It's not just about how JB behaves.

After seeing TV shows especially of today's times I won't say writers know better of history than anyone else.

And forget history. I clearly said it is not making an interesting watch even as fiction.

Till yesterday it was Bhils, now suddenly it is about Rao Surtan?

Where's the consistency?

I am still watching the show but only out of habit or more like a routine. The difference is that once the show used to draw me and my family as viewers whereas now we have to stick to it.

Regarding popularity and all, the ratings charts show everything be it TVTs or user generated surveys on Ormax. I don't have to share anything on this.

The same PH's shows like JKR were so good even if we throw aside history and focus only on fiction.

Where's the excitement in MP?

Cast is getting poorer. That girl, Heera (?) who's supposed to be brave or daring doesn't look like her character one bit.

Shani88 has put it across very well what I feel and wanted to say.

As viewers we'll give feedback as we want.

Sony doesn't bother I guess. FB posts, emails or tweets yield nothing.

Whether they stick to facts or take creative liberties, it is important to keep it coherent and interesting.

The gurukul track was labelled as boring but I think it was far better and at least had consistency unlike tracks now where characters go or come in picture every other day abruptly.

Ab woh baat nahi rahi. CVs need to pull up socks. The show should be earning more viewers or ensure it retains viewership it had earned...instead of overhauling story like this.

The "yellow" faces thing is something I used to point out earlier also. And now even more. This sepia tone is distracting.
Proud-India thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
But my request do not leave to watch show.

Many interesting tracks will be come soon.

I am now agreed with your points...But May be after leap it will be interesting.
cherryberry293 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
Sadly I have to admit it that my favorite show has turned out boring 😔
What @Skep and @Shani said , is exactly what I am thinking. This current track isn't making any sense to me. What was the need to bring Bundi here??? They could have shown Panna Dai in some other way.
Frankly speaking all these new ppl in show aren't impressive except BK and Rao Surtan.

Like @anu Di said, I find this Bundi track tad boring. Yesterday I watch episode but got so bored dat started playing on phone, earlier I used to put everything aside and sit in front of TV. My father used to ask me abt epi if he misses a single thing. Me and whole family watch MP nd v all love it but now v watch it more of a habbit nd not as with interest.
@Shani is ri8, I can't keep my brain aside while watching film or show. I do analysis nd questipns do come in my mind.

I have noticed one thing abt Contiloe's shows, they start every show with a bang, with impact, impressive looks but as the story progresses CVs control gets loose on it this same happened with Veer Shivaji don't know what's d problems with them???

Cant v all mail Contiloe or give feedbacks on their website?? I don't know if it will work or not but v all can give a try and try to save this amazing show from going sloppy, can v all do this together???
ak75 thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#10
No wonder TRP has come down..

Sony
  • Kitchen Khiladi: 683 (801)
  • Amita Ka Amit: 658 (815)
  • Nandini: 1014 (1035)
  • Jee Le Zara : 1617 (1556)
  • Maharana Pratap: 2680 (2772)
  • Bade Ache Lagte: 2068 (1860)
  • Adaalat 1896 (2846)
  • CID 3229 (5292)
  • Crime Patrol 2940 (3423)
  • Comedy Circus 2436 (2379)
  • KBC (Fri-Sun) 3796(3960)
Edited by ak75 - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".