Hypocritical much? - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

57

Views

6.5k

Users

34

Likes

376

Frequent Posters

lrlpam thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#51
Ok now,when the hell did she say that she wanted him replaced?! That's the difference between useless bashing n constructive criticism...atleast listen to her interview,dammit,u guys always read btw the lnes n make ur own assumptions. So what if she wasn't frnz with him! She wasn't even frnz with rati in MJHT! U can't be frnz with anybody n everybody n btw who exactly was frnz with Mr. attitude?!

Farhan wasn't bashed bcz he wasn't frnz with sanaya,he was bashed bcz he made it out to be the reason behind his exit...he brought sanaya's personal life n a different fandom into it as an excuse for his bad acting! N if v hadn't moved beyond sarun,v wouldn't have accepted anuj too! Yes,I agree that the storyline is weak but that's completely off-point. V all had decided to watch for sanaya knowing a saas-bahu saga wouldn't be that good but FK had even closed that option for us!

P.S - As someone who saw sanaya in her 1st show n didn't become a fan of hers till MJHT,I don't hesitate in saying that sanaya in LRL was 1000 times better than FK. M saying that bcz the 2 have been compared in many FK-defense posts!
GodhuliLogon thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 12 years ago
#52

Originally posted by: showviewer

Please give me the link where she said Sanaya said that she wants Farhan replaced. The only one I saw where she even commented on replacement, she said that IF there is a replacement, then she wants a good actor, looks don't matter, and this is something she has always wanted in all her co- actors. In this interview the question was edited out, so we don't know the question she was asked. If there was another one, where she said Farhan needs to be replaced, please share the link...that would be appaling.


In Raj Baddhan radio interview she refrained from talking about replacement rumours and said Farhan is new and getting better.

She was answering fan question in Team Sarun interview when she said that she knows that particular fan and family is watching Chhanchhan for her, and she will work hard to continue to entertain them. She was addressing her IPK fans through Team Sarun.

She did say in Team Sarun interview that Farhan and she are not friends, but cordial enough to shoot scenes. I don't remember her saying she did not like him and that she wanted Mohit to be the lead instead, which FK is speculating in his interviews.

In all the interviews during launch of the show she asked her fans to give him chance. In the article dated June 5th, she said such encouraging words for FK. Proof below


http://www.bollywoodlife.com/news-gossip/sanaya-irani-chhanchhan-is-not-trying-to-change-the-world/

When FK was in the show he said Sanaya was very cooperative and had no tantrums. Now, he says she never greeted him from beginning! Proof interview below


http://www.tellychakkar.com/stardiary/i-dont-mind-romancing-sanaya-farhan-khan

Then, he said he had refused lead role in Ekta Kapoor show before, but he took up Chhanchhan now because he has same space as Sanaya. Proof following articles

http://www.bolegaindia.com/gossips/I_took_Chanchan_because_it_provides_me_equal_space_to_Sanaya_Irani_says_Farhan_Khan-gid-27418-gc-16.html

http://www.tellychakkar.com/news/ekta-kapoor-offered-me-kaisa-yeh-pyaar-hai-i-declined-it-farhan-chhanchhan-khan

Now he saying he is second lead. So, who is a hypocrite here?

BTW, Sanaya will be first to agree she was not great when she started out and therefore she took up smaller roles instead of lead roles to improve her acting and Hindi language skills. You will find these answers in her April 2012 London interviews. Easy to find links.




you answered it so nicely.. this is the best reply here ..

Hypocrisy 😲
mads thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 12 years ago
#53

Originally posted by: Krishma042

Is what I feel some Sanaya fans are (and I know I may be the only one with this opinion)


don't worry, we have been facing these allegations ever since MJHT days😆 and I wonder why Sanaya and her fans are always called hypocritical. The definition of hypocrisy is - the state of pretending to have virtues, moral or religious beliefs, principles, etc., that one does not actually have (source : wikepedia).

Therefore, it is NOT (in contrast to popular belief), changing one's opinion after getting aquainted with the truth - that is acceptance of reality. It is also NOT modulating one's beliefs as time passes - that is growing up. Thirdly, it is also NOT hypocrisy when two similar things are treated differently because the situation demands it to be treated so.

Moving on...

Sanaya in quite a few interviews said that Farhan and her are not friends, in one said that she wants him replaced (wonder how she would have felt if one of her co-actors in her first show had said that about her publicly, because lets face it,she was no better in her first show - everyone deserves a chance) in another said that she knows that people are only watching the show for her and in one she even went ahead to say something like unfortunately it's the love story track with that boy(note: she didn't even take his name).

I sincerely do not remember one single interview of hers where she said it in so many words that she wants FK replaced. And trust me when I say that I have watched almost all of her interviews. And if I rewind back to the very first interview of CC, I remember Sanaya asking everybody to give FK a fair chance. The statement she made about people watching the show only for her was totally uncalled for though, I believe that too and she should not have said that. But apparently the interview was for SaRun fans, who were indeed watching the show only for her. Anyway, this I still agree with you that it was not right on her part to give herself the highest credit especially when she is normally known to tone down herself a bit, so this came as totally un-Sanaya.

How fans reacted to this: Oh she is so honest, we need more people like her on this earth, the queen of professionalism etc etc

Well, her professionalism has been spoken about by all of the people who have worked with her previously, including directors, actors and every other people she has come in contact with. When so many people unrelated to her can praise her professionalism in many different situations, I think we can consider it to be the truth. We definitely dont need more people like her ... 😆 ek hi kaafi hain! 😳

Now what Farhan said in this interview: That Sanaya and him are not friends, because she doesn't like him, which is true(and its ok not to be friends with every co-actor); that he was being blamed for the low trp's because of lack of chemistry with her, when he was just playing second fiddle which is true- I have read so many people saying that they were not watching because of him, but if you truly did want to watch for Sanaya I don't understand how just one actor, whose character was not even that important was putting off fans from watching. The truth is this show is no good, and the main reason for it being its poor storyline, followed by the poor direction, screenplay, background score etc. Lastly he said that people are not over sanaya and barun, which is another truth, Sanaya herself kept comparing her chemistry with Farhan with that of Barun in one of the interviews and said that the lack of friendship between her and Farhan was one of the reasons for the poor chemistry- but you are an actor at the end of the day- and not a very good one at it if one can clearly see how uncomfortable you are doing scenes with certain actors, she can not be friends with every actor she works with.

I agree with your last statement - when you are a good actor, your personal relationship with your co actor should not reflect on screen. And it didnt ... her expressions in all the scenes have been spot on. But is that enough? Your statement is irrelevant when it comes to romantic scenes and creating chemistry, because even when you put in your 100%, if the person in front of you does not react, what can you do. Chemistry cannot be created by just one person. And definitely not between two people who are so uncomfortable with each other. If not friendship, atleast a basic comfort level is a necessity for creating a watchable chemistry. Take any remotely good chemistry between two actors and you'll find what I say is true. As for her, her first big love story was with Mohit, where their offscreen romance bloomed alongwith the onscreen one, so there was not question of comfort zone here. Next came Barun, with whom she instantly clicked, and she did say in an interview that she will never share the same chemistry with Barun offscreen with anybody else. So we might as well hope for the longest of times that we will not be able to see her sizzle that much with anybody else (sigh..so much for my Viraf-Sanaya dream project ). Then came FK, with whom she failed to click (for various reasons) and the chemistry failed to click with the audience too. Now its anuj, with whom she seems to be very much attuned, and the chemistry is magically improving. So conclusion being, she needs to be comfy with a co-star to create a good chemistry, for a love story, a comfort zone she felt totally lacking with FK. But, it was not just her - others did not gel along well with him too. He was always aloof in every interviews, so one can imagine he would be that too on the sets. It was something about his nature that did not gel well with others. In these situations, I find it hard to believe his claims that she was the only one being cold towards him - maybe she was, but she wasnt the only one and that certainly should NOT be the reason for his "quitting" the show.

How fans react to his side of things: he is doing all this for publicity, he is so unprofessional, etc How different was what he said to what Sanaya had been saying all this time?

Again, read my first paragraph. The difference is this - while only FK has allegations of Sanaya being "rude" from the day he was chosen over Mohit (much in contrast to his first interview where he called her helpful and co-operative) and 100 other people claim her to be a very warm person (in her entire four yr career), three other people apart from Sanaya have shown their displeasure towards FK and/or his acting skills (in just two months), I think I will say that FK is wrong in this situation for two reasons - one, for being so unprofessional as to wash dirty linen in public (even though he was partially responsible for dirtying it) and second, for putting the entire blame of his exit on Sanaya, I mean, do not accept that the reason for your "qutting" the show is your abysmal acting skills - fine. But why blame someone else for your exit? As if producers are dancing around Sanaya's wishes - this is not just a blame on Sanaya, but on the entire Optimystix PH.

Edited by mads - 12 years ago
sanga03 thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#54
i trust sanaya.she is very honest and down to earth person.if she not become i frind with farhan .so whts a big deal.inspite of this she always said everyone to give chance to him.
golpokobita thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#55

Liked your post.. didn't want to quote since it was very big.
I just want to add one point ..
TRPs didn't depend on Farhan, true..
But he was a serious distraction for the viewers, (at least for me!)

I started watching the show with lots of expectations, tried to take the good messages it offered but, Farhan's acting was such a distraction, i had to stop watching it..
So the point is, I agree with him.. he wasn't supposed to bring viewers to Sanaya's show.. BUT that does not mean he would make existing viewers leave the show! Which he actually did!
Krishma042 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#56


This is my way of giving you a standing ovation. This is what a post should be - facts with proof to back them up...this is how the TM should have presented her post and if she didn't have time to provide the proof then she should have saved her post for such a time that she could do so. I guess it's a case of striking while the iron is hot and jumping on the antiSanaya bandwagon. I think we should put that replacement interview on a sticky so everyone can see it again and we should provide a written update so no one can misunderstood it and everyone should have to watch it and read it before they're allowed to use it as a refernce.
The other thing that struck me is that people who without any basis are attacking Sanaya are defending the TC interview by saying it's gossip ( I think that's what FK's PR company said - damn I should get the link😊) but if so who was it that gossiped with them...any guesses?


Nope, I simply put it out there before I would forget what I had to say. So after yesterday's TC article on what Sanaya had to say(which obviously I don't believe coz it comes from TC) would like to know if your opinion has changed about Farhan's interview in TC being exaggerated?
AnjanaYYZ thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#57
Sanaya says wanted him replaced and she did obviously prefer Mohit. That is Kinda Obvious. D'uh why wouldn't she? But, Farhan's the villain had the nerve to say it outloud instead of con't the pretence. How dare he!🤣

Congrats to Sanaya fans, who don't even watch the show because of him! They can finally watch. I look forward to seeing ChanChan become a HIT. 😊

Farhan acting was crappy and he's a brainless human being for daring to say anything regarding the honest Princess Sanaya. Got it.😆
Edited by AnjanaYYZ - 12 years ago
PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: Krishma042



This is my way of giving you a standing ovation. This is what a post should be - facts with proof to back them up...this is how the TM should have presented her post and if she didn't have time to provide the proof then she should have saved her post for such a time that she could do so. I guess it's a case of striking while the iron is hot and jumping on the antiSanaya bandwagon. I think we should put that replacement interview on a sticky so everyone can see it again and we should provide a written update so no one can misunderstood it and everyone should have to watch it and read it before they're allowed to use it as a refernce.
The other thing that struck me is that people who without any basis are attacking Sanaya are defending the TC interview by saying it's gossip ( I think that's what FK's PR company said - damn I should get the link😊) but if so who was it that gossiped with them...any guesses?



Nope, I simply put it out there before I would forget what I had to say. So after yesterday's TC article on what Sanaya had to say(which obviously I don't believe coz it comes from TC) would like to know if your opinion has changed about Farhan's interview in TC being exaggerated?


Agree with you Krishma. Now TC has come out with Sanaya's rebuttal for Farhan and whatever anyone may say - Sanaya was wrong on commenting on mental health of Farhan. If now the fans of Sanaya are coming out and saying TC is exaggerating the things because Sanaya is very polite and is down to earth, then I think TC did exaggerate the things in Farhan's interview too because the same interview came out in Hindustan Times and in that there is no mention of Farhan dragging in Mohit's name in the mix. So we have to give benefit of doubt to Farhan too - maybe TC did add in the spice of Mohit's name to make the post explosive. Any way I do hope this saga of 'He said, She said' is really kept behind by both the concerned persons. All said and done I should say I am little disappointed in the way everyone is fueling the things - media/fans/bashers.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".