hiltler papa,taani n sharon scene

Tr and ss fans both welcomes to do a healthy descussion :-)

Well yesterdays epi has instigated alot ov fights in da forum.many people r question taani abt y she made a remark on sharons upbringing eventhough they dont bond very well. if all da fans either tr or ss fans would have watched da papa sharon n taani scene with positivity they would have noticed tht before da upbringing wala dialogue taani was trying to justify sharons attitude to her tauji by saying tht she is da diva ov da college n vry popular by saying this she was trying to tell her tauji tht sharon never meant to be rude to him by heart(eventhough i think sharon did a commendable job by answering back hitler papa :-P) by this popular sharon wala dialogue she was actually trying to defend sharon in front ov tauji. By da upbringing wala dialogue taani meant tht sharon has been bought up lyk a diva n so when she finds anything wrong she is nt scared to state her opinion which she did in front ov tauji. So i would really request all da fanbases to stop fighting over these little things wht i really think is tht cvs are doing a poor job on da screenplay these days
PS i loved sharon in yesterdays epi da way she answered bk to tauji was bang on :-) n taani is such a sweetheart perhaps da most relateable character in d3 she proved to be a gr8 sister n gs in da last scene my love foe her has increased after yesterdays epi :-)
N yah lastly plz dont fight on this post it was solely my own pov on yesterdays epi:-)

I disagree...dnt take me wrng bt in context nd timing f delivery f dialog made whole scene wrng...it seen like she was supporting her tauji...he was pissed with sharon nd dailog made luk taani too support tauji...

Originally posted by: Swaronvrushan

I disagree...dnt take me wrng bt in context nd timing f delivery f dialog made whole scene wrng...it seen like she was supporting her tauji...he was pissed with sharon nd dailog made luk taani too support tauji...

see there r always two sides ov a situation if u see taani was supporting her tauji but she was also nt against sharon when she told her tauji abt sharon :-) actually da whole dialogue delivery was done in a poor way n da main theme ov my topic is tht if sumone is to be blamed foe yesterdays scene it neither sharon nor taani da poor screenplay ruined da essences ov da scene! Da scene could have been executed ina better way :-)

Bang on post dear...at last someone thought the same as me.

well i completely disagree with you..i have many reasons for this ,

1. if tani wants to defend sharon, there are many other ways to do that, e.g. sharon spoke about lack of love n passion that dad has towards swayam. Tani ,should have explained thsi to tauji much before but she just keeps seeing swayam getting insulted in front of dad...

2. using that particular dialogue to defend is so lame, esp. with her expressions in that scene made me feel like she wants to demean sharon rather than anything...if u have such dialogues in mind, u better shut up n dont defend...coz clearly after this tauji has got negative impression

3. why tani has to be scared all the time? does she waana change n be a strong gal, esp., after break up? considering only she has the tolerable relation with tauji she should be the one to chnage his opinion about swayam using neutral tone n language with him, but she wholly ignores this issue and moreover she has already accepted that tauji dislikes swayam n she cant do anything about it..

at least i did not find any positivity in that scene...cv had ample opportunity to make tani strong n speak up for swayam like sharon did but they ultimately failed, be it dialogue writing, screen play or execution...

I agree with the TM... I managed to watch the scene in the same perspective. I thought both Sharon & Taani were right in their own way .. and there was nothing about demeaning Sharon when Taani brought out the 'upbringing' part. Besides the fact that Sharon has been brought up like a Diva.. IMO, it was meant to highlight that Sharon has been brought up with the freedom and sense of independence that not many do ... and her attitude comes from that freedom .. which is not wrong. I also felt that Taani did not want Tauji to judge Sharon wrongly or make an opinion of her so quick.. which is why she spoke about Sharon.

Originally posted by: Eksie

I agree with the TM... I managed to watch the scene in the same perspective. I thought both Sharon & Taani were right in their own way .. and there was nothing about demeaning Sharon when Taani brought out the 'upbringing' part. Besides the fact that Sharon has been brought up like a Diva.. IMO, it was meant to highlight that Sharon has been brought up with the freedom and sense of independence that not many do ... and her attitude comes from that freedom .. which is not wrong. I also felt that Taani did not want Tauji to judge Sharon wrongly or make an opinion of her so quick.. which is why she spoke about Sharon.

I really am glad that Sharon spoke it out the way it was to Papa Shekhawat. And with this.. I feel and hope, the Papa Shekhawat track is coming to a closure.

About this debate wrt to what Taani said is right or wrong ... guess its a matter of perspective and how you look at things.

firstly i thought d same bt then taani's expression turnd it into something else she said chodiye tauji that made everyone thnk something else i think lil change in that dialoug was necessary..

Originally posted by: Twinkle_d3

firstly i thought d same bt then taani's expression turnd it into something else she said chodiye tauji that made everyone thnk something else i think lil change in that dialoug was necessary..

Originally posted by: Twinkle_d3

firstly i thought d same bt then taani's expression turnd it into something else she said chodiye tauji that made everyone thnk something else i think lil change in that dialoug was necessary..

ditto...her expressions conveyed something different..

I really Luv ur positive post...👍🏼