Competition or Charity?

Page

Next Last

Rana

@hamzanuha

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Sanjeev Kapoor has lost it! If he feels that choosing Yasmin over Devyani was because her need is greater! 😡 🤢

My Assessment -

Now before people start attacking that there was no innovation in her dish, I would like to say that neither of the dishes had any. Yasmin made egg curry, finished by baking, while Devyani made omelet, just layered it. So neither 'innovated'. So the score is equal.

Both were given free & helpful advice by the judges, Sanjeev being magnanimous in going to both contestants.

Vikas was sweet & gently reminded Yasmin that none supported her. Result - Yasmin cries 😭 (Was it a ploy to derail Yasmin?) Devyani was visited by Kunal who gravely listened to her plans & suggested she do something more as a mere omelet was not enough. Result - Devyani frantically concocts a dessert 😕 (Was it done to put more pressure on her that they have more expectations from a cook of her calibre?) Now the score is equal again.

Judging :- Yasmin is told by Sanjeev that her curry is dry otherwise it's perfect while Vikas says the rice is not up to Yasmin's standards. Devyani is told that her dessert is a flop by Sanjeev while he compliments her layered omelet. Kunal rates the main dish good while the dessert was too sweet. Score is equal again. (I want to know why can't they show the 3rd judge tasting & commenting?)

The show deals with cooking & therefore the result too should be based on the cooking & not on the charity or partiality of the judges!

By stating Yasmin's background as the reason for her being declared safe, Sanjeev Kapoor has shown his or SP pathetic mentality (most likely SP). But why did the others have to nod sagaciously in agreement? 😡

They have taken away from Yasmin's achievements by that one statement. First they pressured her to use her super shakti & now this. It has left a bad taste on the whole & tainted a good contestant.

I'd like to end this with Salman's dialogue:

Mujh pe ek ehsaan karna

Mujh pe koi ehsaan mat karna

Quote

Frequent Posters

raj-avin

@raj-avin

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

I agree they shd use all 3 judges to taste each dish and judge and i think there shd also be criteria s like presentation, taste, consistency- according to how it looks , touch and taste and the 3 judges shd give marks individually on these criteria s so that there is no room for anythg other than cooking. They cut all these short to use the rest of the time for dramas.

The show has reached its final half and we yet dont know what the criterias are and how they reach a particular decision.😕

and to top it all they make unfair rules in the name of surprise twists like in dhaba and chowpati and , the most recent one being wildcard dramas.🥱

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Komal

@kritikakk

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

LOL Rana... excellent post!

if SP n sanjeev kapoor wants to highlight Yasmeen's background n charity for her being saved rather then her genuine talent for cooking... then my 1 n only question is why didnt they use this to save khoku? she was illiterate, and also had a big disadvantage n a background story, so why not "charity" saving her??

this season is ridiculous, n judges shld be mindful how they r presented due to their reputation! stop giving into SP's dramebaazi on a reality show!

Quote

Rana

@hamzanuha

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: kritikakk
LOL Rana... excellent post!

if SP n sanjeev kapoor wants to highlight Yasmeen's background n charity for her being saved rather then her genuine talent for cooking... then my 1 n only question is why didnt they use this to save khoku? she was illiterate, and also had a big disadvantage n a background story, so why not "charity" saving her??

this season is ridiculous, n judges shld be mindful how they r presented due to their reputation! stop giving into SP's dramebaazi on a reality show!

@ Bold - Hey, why didn't I think of that! 👏

Edited by hamzanuha - 12 years ago

Quote

Raina

@Raina101

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

Vikas Khanna is just adding ornamental value to the show.
Honestly, it's a waste to have him on the how.

But on second thoughts, Vikas is very soft hearted, I'm not sure he would make a rational decision ( not that any of the judge make rational decisions).

Quote

Anu.007

@Anu.007

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

Originally posted by: hamzanuha

@ Bold - Hey, why didn't I think of that! 👏

Khokhu dint cry and advertise her background in each and every episode.. She broke down only when she was eliminated.. It is mandatory that every time they are in dangerzone they have to start sobbing out as much as possible to be eligible for charity ..

Quote

bhagyathara

@bhagyathara

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

the best dramebaaz wins .

Quote

jyothi

@jyothi-

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

I agree.

Channel may decide who has to be eliminated.Here between yasmin and devyani channel must have told the judge to eliminate devyani.

Quote

Rana

@hamzanuha

Dazzler

Posted: 12 years ago

But, then Doyal has shown brilliance at times

So maybe in terms of innovation, she shld stay

Quote

knownstranger

@knownstranger

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#10

Rana I just have a small doubt by any chance are you confusing MCA with MCI coz in MCI innovation takes 2nd or 3 rd place emotions crying stories are 1 n 2.Doyal does irritate no doubt but she cannot constantly cry like yasmin which is wat SP wants so Doyal will be out.What better innovation can u ask for than an Anda curry

Quote

1 2

Competition or Charity?

Related Topics

Explore Topics