Onir the only sane one - Page 2

Originally posted by: Ashi22

How can Onir be sane one he gave up on Purvi stupid demand just like Arjun, I really hated him when he said to Purvi Tumhara bacha mar chuka hai😭

I never have seen such jhoota Docter all my life,

Originally posted by: sashashyam

My dear,

As to why he is sending Purvi back so soon, it is obviously because if she keeps on having hysterical fits like the one she had in front of the incubator room, the fat will soon be in the fire as far as her great secret is concerned. Secondly, it would obviously be better for her state of mind to be away from the baby. He was planning to accompany her at first, but then there was the breathing problem for the baby. As for checking her, we do not know that he has not done that, and then again, she can get any further treatment needed in Mumbai.

You did not see any burst of emotions in Onir's scenes because he underplays his emotions beautifully, and uses his eyes far more than his voice. The problem in Indian TV is that high pitched hysterical scenes are preferred to subtle emoting, and are taken to be the hallmark of great acting. His scenes with Purvi this week were all splendid, and on both sides, but in very different ways. And when he looks back at the baby crib in Ovi's room after leaving Purvi's baby there, one can see the sadness at having to give up the baby he was so looking forward to having in his life. You just have to watch more carefully, as these are nuances, and not in your face gestures. I loved his acting style, and I was pleased that so many others seem to share my opinion.

I am afraid I cannot understand your 'Has anyone noticed how lightly Onir is taking the situation?". Taking it lightly? He is worried sick, about his Mishti, about how to get her over her obsession with the baby she gave away despite his objections, how to make sure the baby is safe and comes out of the incubator, and so on and on. It is just that he does not go about weeping and wailing about them; that is what is called a strong, self-controlled and disciplined personality.As you have noted yourself, Onir is the only strong and sane person in this whole situation.

And if, as someone speculated, Purvi's uncontrolled hysteria when the baby has breathing problems is a precusor to her becoming emotionally and mentally unstable, Onir's plate will not just be full, it will be overflowing. Perhaps this is what the CVs were hinting at in that Manav-Onir conversation, where Manav made Onir promise that woh kabhi bhi Purvi ka saath nahin chhodega. That sounded strange to me, but this idea might explain it. Let us see.

Why on earth should he turn negative? Surely you do not want him to do so? Can we not have an honest, caring and decent character around without wanting him to sprout horns like Satan? Onir is like another Ekta Kapoor favourite, Rajat Kapur in Ekta's BALH, a perfect gentleman, and that is the way he will stay.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: sashashyam

The factual position in this matter is that the police can act only if the affected party or parties lodges a complaint and files an FIR (first information report). The only affected party in the pregnancy report is Purvi, and no one else has any legal locus standi in that matter, not Archana or anyone else. And Purvi is hardly going to complain about the doctored report, which,incodentally, is actually prepared by that Dr.Braganza, as she states herself.

And I do not see what doctoring the report has to do with Onir turning negative - towards whom? Purvi? But he gets that done only to save Purvi!

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: sashashyam

Yes, of course,my dear, he should instead have said, Yes, Mishti, here is your very own baby.Would you like to hug it and kiss it? And encouraged her to have another hysterical crying jag, laying claim to the baby after having given it away of her own sweet will, and saddled him with the job of switching them. Aap isme mera saath denge na Onir? Weeping all over him, grabbing his hands and clinging to them, and the poor fool is as putty in the hands of his Mishti.

He is, as you note, not sane, but as Shakespeare said long ago, a man in love is by definition not sane. Onir is a besotted idiot for ever having got involved with this demolition machine of a woman, who does nothing but damage the men unfortunate enough to fall in love with her. First it was Arjun, now it is Onir. Both of them should rue the day they ever set eyes on her, but of course neither will do so. Instead, both will follow her around like tame poodles, and pander to every insane demand of hers, whatever the cost to themselves.

Shyamala B.Cowsik

Originally posted by: Sakhile

Hi Shyamala

I agree with you regarding Onir's truly great acting in the last few episodes. I too believe that he is worried about his Mishti and wants to get her away from the babay so that she does not inadvertently with her insane conduct let the truth out.

However, I think he is staying behind at the hospital as he is suspicious of Mittal. He had overheard Mittal and the doctor speaking and had at that moment decided that he must find out what is going on. I don't think he bought Mittal's story that he was at the hospital because Punni had told him about the accident. Up to the point when he over heard Mittal and the other doctor, he was intent on taking Purvi to Mumbai as he had said to Manav that he and Purvi were shifitng to Mumbai when he had asked the nurse to prepare the disharge papers.

Originally posted by: SNoshin

Great post 👍🏼 Even I feel the same. During the baby switching time, he doesn't seem to care much. Also, in yesterday's episode when purvi got hyper seeing the baby can't breath, did you notice what onir said? He said, mishti YOUR baby is dead. Though we know it's Arjun's baby and onir is very much aware of this fact, still he considered the baby of his own (at least that's what he says). Then in front of everyone he should have said OUR baby is no more, but he said YOUR baby. This dialogue caught my attention 🤔

Originally posted by: Missscarlett

Onir is the only sane one? Lol... I seriously think he has fallen madly in love with 'mishti' which has rendered him completly unable to make a sane decision! He is a doctor for god sakes! Hw could he support purvi in this baby swapping thing? He is an experienced doctor who must have done like a hundredz of deliveries. He knows d mental state of a women who has just given birth! Most importantly hw could he say 'tumne jo yeh faisla liya hai woh bilkul sahi hai' to purvi? Really??noone cant say that she is wrong , that man not born till now in this earth 😆 I gt so mad @ that statement! In wot universe is wot purvi has done correct??? And i was also astounded by the ease that he said 'hummara baccha maar chuka hai' to purvi! what he can say without this ?our baby now in an incubator 😲 and also in front of family !!!! 😲
Onir has that much sense that if purvi says close to the baby then she might get hysterical!she is not heart disease patient and DR onir knows it , now she need to accept the real fact ,if she can accept then she will be ok , if not then she will get lots of psychological problem Where was his brain wen purvi asked him to swap d babies? ''' mera saath dengi na onir '' who said that ?. if she can blackmail a kharros boss then easy to blackmail already a super human being Didnt he grap the gravity of the situation? The long term effects to this? Ovi is purviz sister. Itz obvious that purvi is going to run into her and her baby at some point or the other. What did onir want? That purvi should cut off all her ties with her family in the pretext of 'tumhe humare bacche ko bhulna hogga'. without this what onir can say that you shouldnt have to forget our baby , you should have to think always about our baby so that psychological disease can affect you , is it ?Dr onir is either way too dumb to grap the gravity of this baby donation situation or way too smart as in he might have seen this as a golden chance to get rid of arjunz baby and have 'misthi' all for himself! whats the need of using this baby , ? onir already get a golden chance by getting married her , he has a marriage certificate I really hope that Arjun finds about the truth about the baby and sue Onir and Purvi so very hard! Both of them should land up in jail for d idoitic things they are doing! will arjun able to do that ?

As for as acting goes, i neither find onir interesting nor engaging. He is too boring,bland and one dimensional. And neither does he have any out of the world chemistry with purvi. And i have given up watching PR bcause of all d footage he is getting.