PERSUASION:way to reveal the secret

Earnshaw09 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
After eight years a light of hope seems to unleash all the old memories,end all the pangs,and make the world freeze at one moment when Rishi feels those fingers touch his;and deep down his heart he knows who it is.The darkness holds much more than its depth,screaming out that the end to his pain has come;that Rishi's prayers at the shrine of Goddess Durga,has been answered.And Rishi's faith in his belief that his beloved cannot leave him on half way,becomes stronger when he sees Indira's face(who,the world now knows as Zara)in the day light.And fate seems to have designed a reunion of Rishi and Zara in a dramatic way,when Zara comes to SN;her steps inside the house makes Rishi's heart go faster,her presence makes the house fell like home once again.Everything implies that Indira is back:Zara's choice of food,her anger,her attraction towards Indu,and her heart calling out to Rishi whenever she sees him.Indira has come back as Zara,and this is shown again-n-again.The story and the CVs persuade us to believe in Rishi's believe that Zara is Indira.

But now,with the look-alike of Indira in an asylum in Pakistan,the story takes a different interpretation,not because the belief of the audience is shaken;but this interpretation that,this character might be Indira,is raised because the story and the plot is persuading us to believe so.Similarities in habits are shown between Indu and this character;this character is shown to draw sketches of a little girl on the walls.And moreover,the characters are now forcefully persuaded to behave and act in such a way that,we're convinced that the look-alike of Indira from Lahore is Indira.Characters like Indu,who once believed that she shares a lot of similarities with Zara,that she gets along well with this stranger;now suddenly is convinced that the other character is her mother;that Zara cannot be her mother(inspite of the fact that,her father,Rishi,truly believes Zara to be Indira;the fact that she shares so many character traits with Zara).On the other hand,even Rishi is made to contradict his belief by calling Zara with her name,whereas he has been calling her "shrimatijee" from the moment Zara entered SN.


These strange behavior of Indu,Rishi and others in the story raises many questions,such as,how is Indu so certain that the look-alike of Indira from Lahore is indeed her mother,when she never saw her mother?Isn't she suppose to believe whomever her father believes to be Indira?Why is Rishi calling Zara as Zara,and not "shrimatijee",when he had been so certain that Zara is none other than his Indira?Besides,can there be any mother on earth,who doesn't recognize her own flesh-n-blood,no matter even if the face of her child has changed?Well,all these questions remains unanswered,but one thing is clear,as far as I'm concerned,that we're being persuaded to believe in whatever the story and the CVs are telling us to believe.But in the end,it is Zara,who will be revealed to be Indira.And if at all the character,who has come from Lahore,is disclosed to be Indira,than this would be the most unusual and unexpected contradiction of any story.Although actor Rati will be playing the role of Indira in the end,yet,it will be hard to accept this concept.For me,I'm persuaded by Rishi's belief that Zara is indeed Indira.Those of you who share the same belief do share your views;but those of you,who doesn't agree with this view,please refrain from replying.

Created

Last reply

Replies

14

Views

1.5k

Users

13

Likes

52

Frequent Posters

Salmanisthebest thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
really agree with yur post specially to these lines n question




These strange behavior of Indu,Rishi and others in the story raises many questions,such as,how is Indu so certain that the look-alike of Indira from Lahore is indeed her mother,when she never saw her mother?Isn't she suppose to believe whomever her father believes to be Indira?

yyy she is shown always against to rishi decision??????koi 8 yr old itna bhi natak nahi karata🤢n rishi se zayada y she has problem with zara she has been always sweet to her n saved her life her dad n her sweta mom life many time then y she is against her...infact indu shuold b shown loving zara more now as she is exactly like her real mom indra in look as well as in behaviour so y she dislike her its fail to be understand in HD




exactly my problem with indu is exactly like this yyy writers show this thing with indu... u said it correctly thats make me feel indu role so irritating


Edited by tabu31noor - 13 years ago
kiran_rati thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
i really and totally believe zara is indira
waiting for secret to reveal

Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#4
fully agreed with your post..i firmly believe mumbaiwali as indira & most importantly i have full faith on rishi's belief that he cant make any wrong decision regarding his shrimatiji..even on friday we could see the pain & love for his wife.

Regarding indu even i am failed to understand her strange behaviour with her parents..i mean when her father himself is insisting that zara is her mother then why she is against it?? has she seen her mother for real? just because of the finger prints matched (woh bi kitna sach hai god knows) she is against rishi..because of her this nature i have started to hate indu
Salmanisthebest thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Ranjinikishan

fully agreed with your post..i firmly believe mumbaiwali as indira & most importantly i have full faith on rishi's belief that he cant make any wrong decision regarding his shrimatiji..even on friday we could see the pain & love for his wife.


Regarding indu even i am failed to understand her strange behaviour with her parents..i mean when her father himself is insisting that zara is her mother then why she is against it?? has she seen her mother for real? just because of the finger prints matched (woh bi kitna sach hai god knows) she is against rishi..because of her this nature i have started to hate indu



finger print matching bhi to dekho kis tarah kar rahe hai jaise hand writing mila rahe hai😆naked eyes se aiase hi...😕bus they have to show indu is against rishi so she believe other 1 indra not the one whose father belive is indra😡
Edited by tabu31noor - 13 years ago
Ranjinikishan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6
my major prob with indu is she talks like an experienced lady instead of 8 yrs kid..never ever thought that one day i will hate my inshi'd kid like this & a big thanx to ila mam for this😡
Edited by Ranjinikishan - 13 years ago
light_28 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7
You always write correct posts essential for the hour and i agree with your post 100%.
Cvs have indeed persuaded us to believe anything and everything. And they call it to be a mystery. In my sense its d most incoherent story . The only coherence i can feel is when i see rishi's belief in zara being Indira.
I agree wid u that if they show d othr luk-alike as indira it wud be the most inappropriate story.
Also i nevr expectd them to play everytime with science( context to DNA and Fingerprints)
One more branch of science that can reveal the truth is Gynaecology. Real indira wil show signs of pregnancy but nt delivery. And d real Zara if she has never concieved or never had any relation wid malik will show signs of virginity. Or if she has a daughtr she wil show signs of delivery. An forensic-Gynaec examintn cud have also been used in the show. It wud also give the viewers awareness n knowledge. I wish something logicl is shown.
RamziMeriJaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#8
I too believe that Zara is non other than Indira ! True love can never lies , Rishi's love is pure .
TBDRESS thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#9
Your points are right on the mark. The writers of HD seem to only have 1 trick up their sleeves-suspense. Sadly, what they don't understand is that people watch the show for characters and their relationships. They have made a mockery of all the characters and their relationships in order to continue with the suspense. They have failed miserably because if I can't relate to the characters, what makes them think that I will care about the suspensful happenings in their lives? But like you said, if the Lahorewali is proven to be Indira, this show will lose the little continuity and relatibility that it has left.
sakshi1 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10
Very nicely written. Yes Zara is only our Indira. Hope CVS will not mock the true love that Rishi holds for his shreematiji only and believes that Shreematiji is Zara. Hope CVS will show the true love ZaShi/InShi.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".