We're all thinking about Aarti's love, what kind of love it is, what kind of love Yash would need to feel in order to acknowledge it, and whether it will take him forever to return it consciously.
My thing is, I hope that Yash's love is dealt with much better than Aarti's. PV is a very well written and planned show. But for some reason, one of the biggest developments was handled with outright laziness. They handled other storylines with so much care, but for Aarti's love realization they used the oldest (and least convincing) trick in the book.
I hate it when a 3rd party character puts the idea of love out there. This show is much better than such foil tricks. Whenever (lazy) writers want to introduce a new love interest (or further an existing one), to put the word "love" into everyone's minds they have a 3rd character state it. Like for example: "I know you love her". And its always supposed to be such a big intense moment. And people are supposed to go "omg, they do. Why didn't I see it before?" Spare me. I hate it on the CW, but usually it passes muster, because love isn't the premise of the show. And characters have multiple love interests in the space of a season. So time constraints are present, and they throw things together whichever which way they can. But here, on PV, and other hindi shows, love is the story. ArYa is the show. Why such laziness?
I am not saying Aarti's love seems unconvincing. I'm saying not enough time was spent to make it as convincing as I think it is meant to be. I believe her love. But sometimes I have problems believing that she believes it. Or if she isn't just terming the beginnings of love as "love personified" and using it to justify the following of G3's orders. Man, I am talking myself in circles đ
Basically, I don't think I am supposed to be as confused about her behaviour as I am. I have a suspicion that others in this forum (who are trying to convince me Aarti is just plain in love, and that she isn't consciously working on "plan make Yashu happy") are right. And that Yash will crush the beginnings of love with Aarti's upcoming confession. And that we are all supposed to be so heartbroken. And that will make Aarti even more jaded in love. And that it will also be the first time the word "love" was dared mentioned to Yash in relation to Aarti. What Shobha did for her, Aarti will do for Yash.
I am supposed to be fully lost in her love and adore every moment of Aarti's love dream, but I am not. I feel slightly annoyed whenever she tries to get Yash to do "husbandly" things for her. Mostly because I am not sure if she is doing this out of love, or if she is doing this because she thinks she is supposed to. I don't think the audience is supposed to be confused. Which makes me more confused, because I am, yes, confused. đđ
Writing is manipulation of words, but when such typical writers tricks are used (and in such an offhand manner), it feels like they think the audience is slightly dimwitted. They work so hard to show us the story and not tell it. But then for one of the most important developments we were literally told what to think. And that always leaves me feeling unconvinced. Like there is more to it. When there probably is not.
How would they have done it otherwise?
Well, couldn't Shobha have just had her "re-love" story going on, and Aarti have noticed, and then couldn't she have drawn the connections herself? I get that she doesn't understand what it is to receive love, but she understands what its like to be in love. So any realization on her part (without 3rd party intervention) would have been convincing. Why have Vidhi and Shobha and every one under the sun harp on an on about how in love Aarti is?
Instead of devoting the time and attention to convincing the audience that yes, she was in love, they just told us she was. And then they step by step ticked off Shobha's provided symptom list. I understand that a part of it was they wanted us to take the journey with Aarti. They wanted us to go with the checklist they had provided, instead of the one we have in our heads. But I can't help but feel more justice could have been done to Aarti. Her love is young, and almost puppy-like, I get it. They are justifying their definition of love, and showing us that Aarti has a lot longer to go. And that there will be further realizations and so forth. But I still feel a little meh about the whole thing.
Its like the writers said, "she needs to be in love, and the people need to know she's in love. But the audience is stupid, so we have to spell it out letter by letter." Am I being a little to critical? Maybe đ. Can't help it though. Other than Bua ji's personality change, this is the only other development I feel was mishandled.
ArYa is a couple of such subtlety and nuance, and I just felt a little adrift at the way she acknowledged that yes, she was in love. I expected more subtlety and more time to go into it. But then again, I am probably being to critical âď¸
*Edited: Another essay đ. What to say. I'm on summer break so I have lots of time đâď¸