What the heck!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Shayu.

@Shayu.

Rocker

27

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#1

I really wonder when all judges praising to poorvi's performance!! especially salim praising to poorvi after her performance that "aap koshish ki ho yahi badi baat hain" what the hell is going on in the show??? kya yaha participants sirf KOSHISH karne aate hain kya!!!!!!!!!!😲 shame on judges... participants shud be trained well in all styles of singing before entering in such a show... donno why thais judges r being that much biased to this gal whose voice is stucked only in western style and who is a below average singer..

yesterday may be sonia's performance was not better...but..i am bet she was 100% the best performer than poorvi..but these judges give such a weird comments on sohini...

Edited by .Shayari. - 13 years ago

13

Reply

Quote

Sara.

@-Sara.

Rocker

28

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#2

No I think Poorvi has the best voice in II6.

1

Reply

Quote

..ashu

@..ashu

Navigator

11

Posted: 13 years ago

#3

Originally posted by: .Shayari.
I really wonder when all judges praising to poorvi's performance!! especially salim praising to poorvi after her performance that "aap koshish ki ho yahi badi baat hain" what the hell is going on in the show??? kya yaha participants sirf KOSHISH karne aate hain kya!!!!!!!!!!😲 shame on judges... participants shud be trained well in all styles of singing before entering in such a show... donno why thais judges r being that much biased to this gal whose voice is stucked only in western style and who is a below average singer..

yesterday may be sonia's performance was not better...but..i am bet she was 100% the best performer than poorvi..but these judges give such a weird comments on sonia...

Sony Tv Should take some trained singers through wild card and these judges must be replaced. All present singers are not good at all. They should not be indian idol.

2

Reply

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

25

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#4

Poorvi's singing is a big joke. Her sa re ga ma sargam at the end of the song was like she is teaching numbers tp kindergarden toddlers

11

Reply

Quote

swan20

@swan20

Sparkler

33

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#5

The worst part was the judges were nitpicking the other contestant's performances while Poorvi gets appreciated for her ''attempt''...

5

Reply

Quote

Chitra

@Chits1

Trailblazer

40

Posted: 13 years ago

#6

Purvi is the producer's beti?

3

Reply

Quote

Suresh

@suresh555

Rocker

25

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

#7

Originally posted by: Chits1
Purvi is the producer's beti?

I think more than a possibility of being the producer's beti, it's how judges look at her. All four of them were satisfied with the fact that she did a (horrible) koshish to sing

5

Reply

Quote

Blossom5

@Blossom5

Inactive

15

Posted: 13 years ago

#8

It is so unfair how Poorvi was appreciated for her attemmpt at a song wwhile others were judged by the standards that should be in place for a show like this. If the judges had been strict from day 1, we would have had much better singers so i expected this kind of behavior from them. Did anyone notice how unsure Poorvi was of her placement in her sargam? Singers tennd to hum a note softly before beginning a song to ensure they start on the right note. Poorvi it seemed spoke more than sang on the sargam and after every few notes, she would hum a bit (listen carefully you will hear it) to keep hersellf in the right place vocally. My point is she was obviously uncomfortable but the judges were just so full of praises.

2

Reply

Quote

Shaitaan Haiwan

@Shaitan-Haiwan

Stunner

38

+ 8

Posted: 13 years ago

#9

I agree with all of you.

The judges are stupid. It seems like they have a hard time criticizing Poorvi. Even though if they were to say anything to her it would be constructive criticism.

Why are they like that? Why do they have SUCH a hard time giving her bad comments when she deserves it? I just dont understand. Even Sunidhi today was making sad expressions when she went into the bottom. Why are you upset? Who would you rather send to the bottom besides Poorvi? I dont understand these people. There is surely some politics going on, maybe shes related to someone on the Indian Idol team. The audience is not stupid.

They tore Sohini apart and didnt comment on any of the good parts of her singing (there were some parts that were good) but they were willing to overlook Poorvi's "attempt". Sohini was WAYY better than Poorvi!

Even I could do Poorvi's little "SA RE. SA RE GA MA PA".

This show is a joke now. I hope it doesnt renew again. Horrible song choices + horrible singers = pathetic show.

5

Reply

Quote

vansh

@vansh

Beginner

4

Posted: 13 years ago

#10

😔 I really wonder when all judges praising to poorvi's performance!! especially salim praising to poorvi after her performance that "aap koshish ki ho yahi badi baat hain" what the hell is going on in the show??? kya yaha participants sirf KOSHISH karne aate hain kya!!!!!!!!!!😲 shame on judges... participants shud be trained well in all styles of singing before entering in such a show... donno why thais judges r being that much biased to this gal whose voice is stucked only in western style and who is a below average singer..

yesterday may be sonia's performance was not better...but..i am bet she was 100% the best performer than poorvi..but these judges give such a weird comments on sonia...

i want to ask just one thing who is sonia????😃😆😔

Reply

Quote

What the heck!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Related Topics

Explore Topics