c85rie thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 20 years ago
#1
Athough Karan was always a good son, both towards Mandira ( before he came to know the truth) and to Tulsi, I find him doing a miserable job as a father. In yesterday's episode although he scolded Manthan for the right reason,I find him equally responsible for Manthan's behavior and character today. It is him who always boasts to Saahil about how rich he is, when Nakul and Manthan fight over money matters even then he will never support Nakul even though he is Ganga's son and never the one to start it. But suddenly when Manthan continues the same behavior with others, it causes him shame. I am sorry but all those who think that it is Tanya's fault that Manthan is like this are wrong. Even if Nandini had been there, Karan's behavior due to his success would be the same and for Manthan the role model he has presented would be the same.

Also it was heartbreaking to see a son having so little faith in his father in regards to his mother. Tanya is a blind fool for putting up with Karan for so long. She should have taken Manthan and got out. As it is she and Manthan are secondary to Karan. Bhoomi too left Baa in Haridwar and Baa had to ask KT for help but even then she gets the good dresses and all praises for not creating trouble from Karan as she is Nandini's daughter. Atleast Tanya is true when she says that she does not differentiate between her children.

But Karan has always been this way. He always find a scapegoat for his problems first it was Mihir. When he entered the show he never once questioned his father trying to understand why his father has left him. Instead just listening to mandira's words he tried destroying him. When he knew the truth and realized Tulsi's worth he became devoted to her to an extent that he is blind to her faults. Karan loved his mother a lot, but does it mean that he is the first son to do so. Mihir too loved his mother and Tulsi should have shared her condition before taking such a step. Also none of them ever took Mihir in confidence regarding Meera, so Mihir's behavior wasn't out of line when he was angry with her. But that never meant that he wanted Tulsi dead and hasn't mourned like the rest of them or maybe more. But no, to Karan he is responsible. And now to him Tanya is also the scapegoat for his problems. She isn't a good mother. a good wife, a good daughter in law. Really he should come in open and say the words. She is not Nandini, so that she gets a closure and moves on.

Created

Last reply

Replies

23

Views

2.1k

Users

21

Frequent Posters

mrs kavya nanda thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#2
Yes u r rite... I agree sahil made a mistake.. but karan was too much! thanx 2 him, manthan is 2 proud of his dad money...
BeyondHorizon thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 20 years ago
#3
Totally agree with you! I'm fed up of listening to ppl say its all Tanya's fault. 😡 Well a wife can raise her kids properly only if she has her husband's support. Karan held her responsible for everything that went wrong in his life. Never for once did he give her the love that she deserved coz he felt its bcoz of Tanya Nandani is not with him. Tanya wasn't responsible for Nandani going to coma, n it was Karan who proposed to her. She didn ask Nandani to murder Gujral and land up in jail n neither did she wish Nandani to walk out of Karan's life. Then why the hell r everyone blaming her? Karan is such a loser! 😡 I hope he gets one tight slap from Tulsi for all his mistakes.
Eynem thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#4
i totally agree with u...if karan does not love tanya then why doesnt he leave her..n women who dont get her husbands love usually give awl her love to her children n spoil them!
c85rie thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 20 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: mandy1024

Totally agree with you! I'm fed up of listening to ppl say its all Tanya's fault. 😡 Well a wife can raise her kids properly only if she has her husband's support. Karan held her responsible for everything that went wrong in his life. Never for once did he give her the love that she deserved coz he felt its bcoz of Tanya Nandani is not with him. Tanya wasn't responsible for Nandani going to coma, n it was Karan who proposed to her. She didn ask Nandani to murder Gujral and land up in jail n neither did she wish Nandani to walk out of Karan's life. Then why the hell r everyone blaming her? Karan is such a loser! 😡 I hope he gets one tight slap from Tulsi for all his mistakes.



Exactly ! Karan is being very selfish and ungrateful to Tanya. She has always stepped in to help him. If they show using a flashback that she provoked a fight like Mohini in the family, if she mistreated her stepchild, I will support Karan in saying that Tanya has ruined his life. But all she does is what he likes or his children like and yet such behavior. I know she was negative in the beginning but she did change and for the good, yet no recognition. I feel so sorry for her. Mihir has his drink, Ganga her work, Baa Lakshaya and Damini her husband but Tanya who entered as a business woman is now a housewife treated regularly like a doormat. She has no support or any interest other than living for her family. I am not saying that the wife who stays at home does not have any importance, but Tanya's life is a wreck and her husband and children are equally responsible for this.
achuv thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#6
oh please give him a break!!!!!

maana ki karan was not too much into bringing up the children , but thats no excuse for spoiling the kids. and tanya never corrects manthan when he is rude to baa. now, as some 1 said, KARAN DID NOT PROPOSE to tanya. and plz dont say like " tanys didnt ask nandini to kill gujral and go to jail" knowing ekta , it might ve been JUST that...

the behaviour of karan to saahil is not his arrogance bec of his wealth, but its his hatred towards saahil for the way he treated ganga, remember karan was the one to make saahil ganga realise thier love for each other...

if karan is a bad father its bec manthan DESERVES A BAD FATHER... if karan is a bad husband to tanya, its JUST BECAUSE TANYA DESERVES a bad husband

karan sure is a good father to bhumi
khanrocks thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#7
well said , tanya deserves this
adeela thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 20 years ago
#8
tanya knew it karan only and only loves nandini then why not she leave karan .karan told her so many times she didn't take place nandini' place in his heart.i must say she is the most cheap and chipko women on this earth.always crying and made karan emotional fool but now thanks GOD karan didn't care her tears.karan you rock.tanya churail deserve this.
yogesh_gaurip thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#9
yh agree its all tanya's fault
yogesh
yug kanan thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 20 years ago
#10
please people KARAN LOVE NANDINI ONLY and that fat cow knows it then y doesn't she go even her own son said it 2 her that if karan had 2 choose between her and nandnini he will deff choose nandini and plus that fat cow knew everything abt karan nandini then y did she came back 2 their lives!!!!!!!! i just can't wait when karan nandini meets god that will be worth watching wat say people!!!!!!!!!

KARAN NANDINI FAN

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".