Was Priya right in...

Page

Next Last

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Going and seeing Natasha's OBGYN??? Yes as a SIL she would be concerned abt her health...But DR. came to the house all checked out OK. What was the need to go to find out further abt Natasha?

I find it as a nuisance..Yes to be concerned is one thing but going to see the OBGYN is another..She herself should know that what happens between Dr. and patient is "confidential"

Although what Nutz did by aborting baby was wrong but that is her choice..Who is Priya to judge her?

Natasha should have told Kartik abt her pregnancy...First Aayesh was after her and now Priya the nose poking SIL is bit tooo much..

I do not condone abortion but I felt it was not right for Priya to go see the doctor...Pls share your objective views...I know we have many Priya - Sakshi fans...😳

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sunita

@Garkhelsun

Dazzler

Posted: 14 years ago

HI :

I am a silent member - but I like your point raised - and I have to agree - she has no right to go to the doctor to enquire - and as for the doctor telling her the truth is total BS and unethical - irregardless of how concerned she (priya)is for Nuts - the doctor has no right to disclose any information about her patient to anyone without the patient's consent .. Doctor could be sued for that (I am a lawclerk I know ) - so yea that was total backwas...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

dharad

@dharad

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

Dabulls23 with all due respect, you do not seem too familiar with Indian culture. What Priya is doing is out of concern and love for her family. i am not a big fan of this show, but Priya's concern is completely justified in my opinion. Keep in mind this is a middle class joint family, where love and care is the center of their relationship.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: dharad
Dabulls23 with all due respect, you do not seem too familiar with Indian culture. What Priya is doing is out of concern and love for her family. i am not a big fan of this show, but Priya's concern is completely justified in my opinion. Keep in mind this is a middle class joint family, where love and care is the center of their relationship.

Oh my dear I respect your opinion...I am well aware of middle class joint family Indian culture and living by one for past 57 yrs of my short life...😃

Did I say her concern for Natasha was wrong...NO I did not..😳

But going as far as seeing the OBGYN was not her place...Even what the doctor shared with her was unethical, and illegal...Doctor could be sued for breaking patient-doctor confidentiality by releasing personal info on Natasha...

Just because they are middle class joint family does not give any one any right to meddle in other's private business and poke their nose where it does not belong...

Love and Care also has a grey line which someone crosses becomes nusance 😃

Quote

Sej

@SejN

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

i think the doc was wrong in telling priya.. i mean ye priya is family and all but when you become a doc you have a responsibility .. and i mean i think its just wrong how they showed the doc just telling priya... i mean ye the show has to go and what not.. and maybe this was the only way they thought of to bring out the truth in front of priya.. but i still feel the doc should of said no cause she has a responsibility.. and its some what unethical.. because you are not allowed to share patient details if the patient does not want others to know...

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: sejal719
i think the doc was wrong in telling priya.. i mean ye priya is family and all but when you become a doc you have a responsibility .. and i mean i think its just wrong how they showed the doc just telling priya... i mean ye the show has to go and what not.. and maybe this was the only way they thought of to bring out the truth in front of priya.. but i still feel the doc should of said no cause she has a responsibility.. and its some what unethical.. because you are not allowed to share patient details if the patient does not want others to know...

Yep Doctor was defo wrong in giving out info but Priya was out of line in going and visiting that doctor to get info on Natasha's condition knowing the fact what she might be asking could be a Dr. patient confidentiality matter...Appreciate your response..

Quote

JAN_SA

@JAN_SA

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

I agree, Priya meddles too much she had no business going to the gynae and the gynae broke the patient doctor code. It has nothing to do with middle class families and love & concern. Even affluent families with good morals and ethics have love and concern for each other but one has to know where to draw the line.

Frankly if nuts was adult enough to fall pregnant before her marriage and then abort she should be adult enough to bear the consequences. Priya has no right to interfere

Quote

naraine

@naraine

Explorer

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Yep Doctor was defo wrong in giving out info but Priya was out of line in going and visiting that doctor to get info on Natasha's condition knowing the fact what she might be asking could be a Dr. patient confidentiality matter...Appreciate your response..

Agreed. Of course, there would no drama if none of htis were written, because Nutz had an easy out the other day when she was bleeding--she could have told everyone she's had a miscarriage.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

Originally posted by: naraine

Agreed. Of course, there would no drama if none of htis were written, because Nutz had an easy out the other day when she was bleeding--she could have told everyone she's had a miscarriage.

Exactly same thing I was thinking...She could have used her pain and bleeding excuse and labelled it as "Miscarriage" and gotten away with it...No need to tell Ayesha nothing or Priya...All would have been hunky dory...No one would have been hurt...

Nutz definitely is going thru emotional stuff...She is sad at one time for what she has done...but when someone questions it her defensive side comes thru...What Priya did was not right IMHO...

Thanks for responding..

Edited by Dabulls23 - 14 years ago

Quote

fosla

@fosla

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 14 years ago

#10

I thought Tht was not typical Priya behavior
Too! More like the Parvati types!
She could have simply told her to take her along
With the doc during her check up! Or suggest
Another! This was definitely crossing the line.

Which Indian middle class daughter in law would
Like her Sil to meet her obgyn w/o her knowledge??

Quote

1 2 3 4 5

Was Priya right in...

Related Topics

Explore Topics