I waited and waited

Yesterday I watched the ID episode, all thanks to forum for the reviews. So, I was specially waiting for the 'Ankoon ki gustakhiyaan" song since I heard that BS got harshly criticized by ID for they "band baja diya" his song. I waited and waited till the song ended but I could not make out where they faltered. For the first time I thought Banjyotsna was at a par with Sharib in a melodious romantic song. I liked it, actually I thought "Bazigaar o bazigaar" was a bad performance. I am no where near a person of ID's calibre, I have a ear of that of a common person, but truly speaking that song was not a total disaster as expressed by him, if not as good as the original one. And it was very mean-spirited of him to make caricature of Banjyostsna.

Originally posted by: Pradarshak

Yesterday I watched the ID episode, all thanks to forum for the reviews. So, I was specially waiting for the 'Ankoon ki gustakhiyaan" song since I heard that BS got harshly criticized by ID for they "band baja diya" his song. I waited and waited till the song ended but I could not make out where they faltered. For the first time I thought Banjyotsna was at a par with Sharib in a melodious romantic song. I liked it, actually I thought "Bazigaar o bazigaar" was a bad performance. I am no where near a person of ID's calibre, I have a ear of that of a common person, but truly speaking that song was not a total disaster as expressed by him, if not as good as the original one. And it was very mean-spirited of him to make caricature of Banjyostsna.

Originally posted by: bollywood_queen

i agree... i thought aankhon ki gustakhiyan was really good... i especially thought banjyotsna was good (sharib's always good so nothing new there 😉 )

i enjoyed baazigar o baazigar too but i actually thought banjyotsna was better in aankhon ki... sharib was probably better in baazigar making it an overall better performance

i think ID was just being overcritical coz it's his song... but he shouldnt have said that because he cant compare BS to kumar sanu and kavitaji 😕

agreed. even though i hate sharib, i liked their performance alot and ID had absolutely no right to say that!

Originally posted by: bollywood_queen

i agree... i thought aankhon ki gustakhiyan was really good... i especially thought banjyotsna was good (sharib's always good so nothing new there 😉 )

i enjoyed baazigar o baazigar too but i actually thought banjyotsna was better in aankhon ki... sharib was probably better in baazigar making it an overall better performance

i think ID was just being overcritical coz it's his song... but he shouldnt have said that because he cant compare BS to kumar sanu and kavitaji 😕

right 😕

Originally posted by: uknaik99

I agree with you.. I enjoyed the song very much myself.. since I don't know ID cooments beforehand.. I was shocked at his rudness.. well he was the MD of that song.. so he may know more than us.. after all it is his baby.😊😊

😛u r so nice uknaik99ji...🤗🤗polite too

Originally posted by: vikas1975

You have a ear of a common person thats why u could not find the fault. ID is the composer of the song. More over if u like some osne u dont see his/her fault ar all. This is a common practice. This happens. I never found any fault with SR or TV. I hope u understand what I wanna say.

yes i agree vikas1975ji but i HATE sharib and banjyotsana and still i found they sang wonderfully. That part which ismail pointed out "a- ah- a- ah- a- a" was perfectly done by banjo. That is a very very difficult part that is complicated for even professionals and i believe that banjo and sharib did a great job👍🏼..(even though i hate them)😆 So my point here is that ismail was unnessasarily being rude to them when they did a great job. but this is only my opinion. i may be wrong😛

Originally posted by: vikas1975

You have a ear of a common person thats why u could not find the fault. ID is the composer of the song. More over if u like some osne u dont see his/her fault ar all. This is a common practice. This happens. I never found any fault with SR or TV. I hope u understand what I wanna say.

Come on, they were not that bad. Even better than UA in the first round. (second round UA were better). Only probability for lashing out at them could be that it was his song and he looked into every minute details(bad luck they chose his song, while the other pair got spared from his harsh treatment). Whatever it is, he was very rude to comment like that. Audibly it was pleasant to listen to, sunke to nahin laga ke band baja diya.

Originally posted by: Pradarshak

Come on, they were not that bad. Even better than UA in the first round. (second round UA were better). Only probability for lashing out at them could be that it was his song and he looked into every minute details(bad luck they chose his song, while the other pair got spared from his harsh treatment). Whatever it is, he was very rude to comment like that. Audibly it was pleasant to listen to, sunke to nahin laga ke band baja diya.

true

Originally posted by: vikas1975

Abhi ji
If I hate some onbe then I cannot praise him/her at all. Mere paas itna bada dil nahi hai. AT the same time I dont like both the jodis. My favourites r out (SR & TV). So whosoever wins wont affect me a bit.

😉😃even my favourites were SR. i used to love them... but now that they are out, i'm supporting UA. and i hate BS. Sharib more actually. But somehow i feel that they sang Aankhoki Gustakkhiya very well