Saloni's conduct is flawed & condemning

realitybites thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#1
Saloni's conduct is flawed & condemning

In 8TH May India episode Kakisa narrates Chandani's death to Saloni that while on a picnic Chandani's feet get dirty as she steps in a ditch. She goes to wash it off to a gardener watering the plants. Nahar sees her gets suspicious and starts beating the gardener. For such a miniscule reason & with no provocation to do so Nahar finally pushes Chandni off the hill!

All this portrays Nahar as a PARANOID, DELUSIONED AND ANTISOCIAL personality - How? May be Saloni will like to blame Black Magic or MataRani ki icchcha!

Going into Nahar's personality portrayed so far he was shown to be mature, caring, loving, respectful and supportive Eg's are Shubra's misbehavior, running away from home, her pregnancy & later her marriage with Neel which was much against Nahar and family's wishes. Kakisa belittled Saloni but Nahar resented her, when Saloni had gone out shopping with Neel & Kakisa gets suspicious he keeps his mental composure. After all the support for Buasa marriage, Dhananjay's job, Samar's job and all the niceties showered on the Narpat Singh & family. For all he gets maltreatment from the wife in return.

Forgetting the present and past credentials of Nahar and his behavior towards her, Saloni deems him to be suddenly unworthy of trust and faith! His side of story is unnecessary for his wife to know. His wife believes and trusts a woman who was spiteful of her and conveniently accepts her version of the family's deep dark secret. Portrayed as sensible, mature and intelligent yet Saloni feels no need of asking the poor husband for his version. That of course cancels out the family members. This when the police also record the culprit's statement of crime committed.

Nahar calls her to meet and she agrees. In their meeting Nahar keeps crying and asks her to come back and Saloni orders him to repent for his crime. Nahar pleads with her but does not tell her what he did and neither does she bother. What was the motive of Saloni going to meet him then? To top it all she has the audacity to ask him to surrender to police without finding the motive and how the crime was conducted. How can a wife not desire to know the reason and too for a reprehensible crime like murder? When even in extra-marital affairs the wife wants to know how when where etc. This was disappointing and unacceptable portrayal of events.

Question unanswered still is how did the rational thinking & compassionate Nahar suddenly turned into incoherent, suspicious and possessive person.
Saloni was curious to find the Purani Dodi secret but wonder why is she disinterested in even asking Nahar what he did and why? Is it because she considers it trivial?

All this when she is shown to be a loving and caring wife unlike Shubra. (But think what wld have been the reaction had it been Shubra instead of Saloni!!)

Well starting with a good story and churning it into this mad and sickening caper is completely incomprehensible and seems so galling. The writers in India need to learn how to sketch characters beautifully and portray them realistically.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.2k

Users

9

Frequent Posters

princezna thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: realitybites

Saloni's conduct is flawed & condemning

In 8TH May India episode Kakisa narrates Chandani's death to Saloni that while on a picnic Chandani's feet get dirty as she steps in a ditch. She goes to wash it off to a gardener watering the plants. Nahar sees her gets suspicious and starts beating the gardener. For such a miniscule reason & with no provocation to do so Nahar finally pushes Chandni off the hill!

All this portrays Nahar as a PARANOID, DELUSIONED AND ANTISOCIAL personality - How? May be Saloni will like to blame Black Magic or MataRani ki icchcha!

Going into Nahar's personality portrayed so far he was shown to be mature, caring, loving, respectful and supportive Eg's are Shubra's misbehavior, running away from home, her pregnancy & later her marriage with Neel which was much against Nahar and family's wishes. Kakisa belittled Saloni but Nahar resented her, when Saloni had gone out shopping with Neel & Kakisa gets suspicious he keeps his mental composure. After all the support for Buasa marriage, Dhananjay's job, Samar's job and all the niceties showered on the Narpat Singh & family. For all he gets maltreatment from the wife in return.

Forgetting the present and past credentials of Nahar and his behavior towards her, Saloni deems him to be suddenly unworthy of trust and faith! His side of story is unnecessary for his wife to know. His wife believes and trusts a woman who was spiteful of her and conveniently accepts her version of the family's deep dark secret. Portrayed as sensible, mature and intelligent yet Saloni feels no need of asking the poor husband for his version. That of course cancels out the family members. This when the police also record the culprit's statement of crime committed.

Nahar calls her to meet and she agrees. In their meeting Nahar keeps crying and asks her to come back and Saloni orders him to repent for his crime. Nahar pleads with her but does not tell her what he did and neither does she bother. What was the motive of Saloni going to meet him then? To top it all she has the audacity to ask him to surrender to police without finding the motive and how the crime was conducted. How can a wife not desire to know the reason and too for a reprehensible crime like murder? When even in extra-marital affairs the wife wants to know how when where etc. This was disappointing and unacceptable portrayal of events.

Question unanswered still is how did the rational thinking & compassionate Nahar suddenly turned into incoherent, suspicious and possessive person.
Saloni was curious to find the Purani Dodi secret but wonder why is she disinterested in even asking Nahar what he did and why? Is it because she considers it trivial?

All this when she is shown to be a loving and caring wife unlike Shubra. (But think what wld have been the reaction had it been Shubra instead of Saloni!!)

Well starting with a good story and churning it into this mad and sickening caper is completely incomprehensible and seems so galling. The writers in India need to learn how to sketch characters beautifully and portray them realistically.

ya m totally agree wid u... still lots of questions are unanswered.... hope they soon clear all these doubts

pink500 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
exactly, saloni is acting so immature and stupid now, it is really irrating that after all nahar did for her, she can't even ask him his side of the story, and that she trusts kaki and not nahar
ramas thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
I do agree saloni is acting unreasobale. I have one question for all the people who are blaming saloni as if this situation is her fault. Anyone ever have been put in ever slighltest similar situation. Believe me it hurts a lot when the man you love most lies to you regarding the other woman in his life even though it happened before you marry him. marriage requries complete hoensty. Without that there is no marraige.

Nahar loves her a lot and did lot for her family and her. But saloni did lot for them too. Is it not what husband suppose to do? What about all the time he acted like maniac regarding the keys and painting supply. He left saloni with Ravi and went to dance with neelima knwoing saloni was so uncomfortable and for god's sake they were on their honeymoon. Regarding Shubra's marriage he refused to listen to anything from saloni.Why he is still not telling her the complete truth.
Edited by ramas - 19 years ago
pop77 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
may be saloni want to know wht kakisa motive thus she don't ask any quest. to Nahar. right now she only listen to kaki not any body. remember earky epi. kakisa told somebody i want saloni out of house and might be she listen that part.
may be saloni playing game with kakisa? who know's?wait & watch...
realitybites thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
Well after seeing today's episode its clear Saloni is not playing a game she prays to God to guide Nahar towards the path of repentance.

Raksha I totally support her anger thats understandable but the ques is why she is not asking Nahar for an explanation thats what makes it most unreasonable not her anger.

In real life married people must be asking their spouses for explanations to their querries and not letting it blow up!Even if she overhead isn't it better that the two work together?

And as Saloni is shown to be the epitome of care and understanding then why is being so unreasonable now?
mishtimeye thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
guys its the director who decides how saloni gonna react to Nahar's past, why are you taking everything so seriously 😆
nookway thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
I totally agree with you Lavanya. I think Saloni is not acting rationally. She should have shown more maturity to handle this situation.
asha rao thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: realitybites

Saloni's conduct is flawed & condemning

In 8TH May India episode Kakisa narrates Chandani's death to Saloni that while on a picnic Chandani's feet get dirty as she steps in a ditch. She goes to wash it off to a gardener watering the plants. Nahar sees her gets suspicious and starts beating the gardener. For such a miniscule reason & with no provocation to do so Nahar finally pushes Chandni off the hill!

All this portrays Nahar as a PARANOID, DELUSIONED AND ANTISOCIAL personality - How? May be Saloni will like to blame Black Magic or MataRani ki icchcha!

Going into Nahar's personality portrayed so far he was shown to be mature, caring, loving, respectful and supportive Eg's are Shubra's misbehavior, running away from home, her pregnancy & later her marriage with Neel which was much against Nahar and family's wishes. Kakisa belittled Saloni but Nahar resented her, when Saloni had gone out shopping with Neel & Kakisa gets suspicious he keeps his mental composure. After all the support for Buasa marriage, Dhananjay's job, Samar's job and all the niceties showered on the Narpat Singh & family. For all he gets maltreatment from the wife in return.

Forgetting the present and past credentials of Nahar and his behavior towards her, Saloni deems him to be suddenly unworthy of trust and faith! His side of story is unnecessary for his wife to know. His wife believes and trusts a woman who was spiteful of her and conveniently accepts her version of the family's deep dark secret. Portrayed as sensible, mature and intelligent yet Saloni feels no need of asking the poor husband for his version. That of course cancels out the family members. This when the police also record the culprit's statement of crime committed.

Nahar calls her to meet and she agrees. In their meeting Nahar keeps crying and asks her to come back and Saloni orders him to repent for his crime. Nahar pleads with her but does not tell her what he did and neither does she bother. What was the motive of Saloni going to meet him then? To top it all she has the audacity to ask him to surrender to police without finding the motive and how the crime was conducted. How can a wife not desire to know the reason and too for a reprehensible crime like murder? When even in extra-marital affairs the wife wants to know how when where etc. This was disappointing and unacceptable portrayal of events.

Question unanswered still is how did the rational thinking & compassionate Nahar suddenly turned into incoherent, suspicious and possessive person.
Saloni was curious to find the Purani Dodi secret but wonder why is she disinterested in even asking Nahar what he did and why? Is it because she considers it trivial?

All this when she is shown to be a loving and caring wife unlike Shubra. (But think what wld have been the reaction had it been Shubra instead of Saloni!!)

Well starting with a good story and churning it into this mad and sickening caper is completely incomprehensible and seems so galling. The writers in India need to learn how to sketch characters beautifully and portray them realistically.

well said, I appreciate your points. It is called 'vinasha kale vipareetha buddhi' saloni all along she was made to cry by her sister and bhabhi so suddenly when happiness came in her life she could not withstand that for long and wanted to go back to pavilion [sorrow life] but she left nahar in such a weak situation. very ungrateful character [saloni] .director is confused totally now as what to do and how to carry the story further. poor chap.

fannn thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
I agree !!
pls pls pls let's give the writers the benefit of doubt..
Probably they are trying to fool us..

So far, they have shown that Saloni is not stupid!

Like Ramas says, probably Saloni is just playing a game.. She probably knows Kaki sa is bad and instead of taking the bull by its horns, she is trying something else..
let's wait. Probably the serial will get better and more reasonable soon.



Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".