kamini gupta much better than prerna - Page 2

Tulip, no need to get nasty. My response does not mean that I don't agree with you about UD. What it means is that we have had this convo day in day out for so long I can barely remember. It gets a little tired, is all. YES, Prerna was an idiot not to support Tushar, yes, she shouldn't have freed UD and yes, there is not much improvement in him. BUT, she made a mistake and is human after all...at least she is trying to make up now by supporting someone who is not her daughter but whom she has known forever...in a way, Mukti is like Tushar...in the sense that she is Prerna's child even though she is biologically not. What Prerna couldn't or DIDN'T do for Tushar, she is doing for Mukti. And I don't really see Tushar complain much...

Also, at one point Prerna even threw him out of the house and refused to accept him or listen to him...twice, in fact...after she forgave his first mistake, she found it harder to forgive the next...

Tulip...yaar.....I think u need to wake up and realize this is a soap. Its nowhere related to reality and thank GOD for that.

Its only when ppl take these characters too seriously do we have a problem. Sure Prem is twisted and Prerna has her flaws. And what Kamini did today was Mahaan.

But lets see...Tushar being wounded by a jerk who turns out to be your lost son. If u r a mom and one of your younger son almost murders his older brother, how plausible is that?
Or how likely is it that a lady like Kamini who has been so far potrayed to be someone who looks down on middleclass ppl support Mukti over his son?
Ekta's script writers have never been consistent. During the rape track they made Bajaj look like an idiot (sorry Bajajians but I am sure if u took a neutral viewpoint u will understand), Mahesh a hypocrite and Prem......lets not even go there.

Dont get me wrong Tulip. I really respect your viewpoint and know that u back ur arguments with logic but the thing is....we are in Ekta land. This is not reality and ppl in real life aren't as awful as UD is and if they are they are rightly hated. Prerna has a lot of fans...Prerna is potrayed to be a strong woman by Ekta( although there have been times I had highly doubted that). The only reason y Prem didn't help Mukti and Kamini helped save the day was because this had to be women coming together against all men. If any man was with them and played a pivotal role in winning the case then there victory wont have been as gr8. This is really all Ekta's imagination and the world is a little less twisted.

I think u r taking kzk a bit too seriously. None of Ekta's characters are consistent and they are never likely to be.

well i know i hv said this b4 but today there ws a new perspective to it. Kamini actually showed she is a much much much more moralistic and pro-women lady than prerna.

and where hv all those ppl gone today who kept on writing how bad kamini is and how great selfish prerna is???
I just want every1 to realize that kamini is ACTUALLY MUCH GREATER THAN PRERNA.

u cant conveniently ignore bad things done by ur fav. characters..only if u put urself in the shoes of tushar, rishabh or jeevan u'll realise what this sinner duo of prerna-udi have done to them..

ionia, I agree with you completely. God help anyone whose lives are like those in Ekta's soaps.

and ionia Ekta may show anything but it is upto u to reject or accept it. Her characters are fictious but the ppl who post here are real..and we hv REAL ppl like u justifying sm immoral stuff..then there sure is a problem...with ur morals.
TV is fiction but ur views are real..and i am sad to say but they are immoral(if u r justifying prerna and udi).

Tulip...tell me one character u ADMIRE in kzk.

U know what I admire Kamini for her courage to support Mukti instead of her own son but I also hate her for being prejudiced against middle class woman and badmouthing Sneha just because she has two fathers.
If U admire Kamini completely, I wud say u r nuts. She has negative and positive aspects. There is not a single character in kzk that I admire. I am sorry but none of the main characters in kzk are moral and thats the way Ekta's mind works.

If an action taken by a character is not moral, I won't support that character but if the character takes a commendable action than I wud praise it. I am not a blind fan of anyone. I must admit there are some aspects of Prem and Prerna's characters which I really like but alas these characters from time to time end up taking actions which are as u say completely immoral and I can never support it.

But hating a character blindly just because they have hurted ur favorite character( who isn't completely faultless in the first place) is a bit too much.

What if Prem had tried to murder Sharad instead of Tushar, common Sharad was a goody goody in the beginning wasn't he?

We should support the positive aspects of these characters and criticise their negative sides.
As long as we are aware of the line that seperates reality from Ekta land, we should be fine.

Exactly. We don't praise Prerna when she does something silly and I sure as hell won't sit here and justify Prm's recent actions. He was a jerk, end of story. But, he has a positive side to him that you seem to have forgotten: he rebuilt Prem 1's samadhi, he tore a 12-crore contract for mukti, he lied to her father so that she wuldn't lose face, he threatened aparna two times to leave his mom alone, he save tushar from falling down the stairs when Birju kaka accidently let him go, he protected sneha against Kamini's snobbish friends, etc etc and the same for Prerna. She has done a lot of good as well, but when you blindly hate a character you don't see the good things they have done. Prem and Prerna aren't black and white characters like Komo and Aparna (even these two were good at some point in their lives). The truth is that no one is perfect and everyone has grey shades to their character, and we have to praise their good actions as well as condemn their bad ones.

ya i agree...before i used to really hate prerna, but nowadays seeing the way she is supporting mukti unconditionally in the motherly love inspite of mukti not being her own daughter and a driver's daughter, unlike bajaj, anurag, sneha who totally irradicated mukti from their lives forgetting that she was brought up with the same parvarish and for bajaj she was like a daughter and for sneha, her best friend and sister... i feel like respecting Prerna now !!

I have to agree with Ionia,vasu and dewdrops here. They speaketh the truth.I'm not a blind fan of any character either.We need to be objective here.

You are citing things from a bajaj fans point of view ronitfan. Put yourself in prerna's shoes and think...if she has mistreated bajaj over prem vs tusshar..I believe she forgave him for his one night stand/tanisha too and in that same scene said she has always taken him for granted coz he's perfect in her eyes and said even I have made my share of mistakes. Besides Bajaj has been the cause of her life going haywire in the first place..and her support system throughtout her lifetime at the same time too. It's complex isn't it?

I praised and still do praise prerna for the unbiased stand she has taken now for mukti's rights. What she did in the past regarding prem and tusshar, I don't condone either. No body's perfect in this soap and that's what makes this watchable. I don't want to watch ramayan.

If you break it down into a deep analysis,though such an illogical soap doesn't warrant such seriousness.. not a single character in kzk has been morally correct at any given point of time. Not the great Mr.Bajaj,who was quite a machiavellian smooth operator in his heydays, I can cite several instances of his double standards from the past if I do remember..prerna the "supposedly immorally impulsive" woman, Mr wimpy nobackbones Anurag Basu, the original brat Tusshar, who is such a goody goody mama's boy now..no one. This is a fictional soap and we need to take it easy.

No one expected Kamini to behave the way she did today considering the preconceived image we have of her. Kudos to her. But that doesn't make prerna any lesser what she's doing is commendable. Her past actions notwithstanding.
We can have this discussion on & on..but if those two said it's been done to death, no point in dragging this.