Really NOT FAIR! - Page 2

all i want 2 say now is.......i have started feeling really offended on these forums now.....i came here bcoz of sandeep and i am going bcoz of sandeep...the way sum people are offending us sandeep fans by talking such crap....i will not b cumin here again.....i cant believe can be so critical here 😭 bye every1
-Tish 😭

Originally posted by: rajeevzluvr

ok so u want an explanation huh
ok
1. indian idol is a complete package........u need 2 sing good, perform good and u need 2 have the personality....sandeep had it all
2. the judges also praised sandeep....karunya was just hyped too much bcoz he is from south and he sang a punjaabi song
3. if u can remember sonu said it at the beginning tht in the whole contest if sum1 has the best voice for the microphone its sandeep
4.farah said it herself , even sonu did tht sandeep was givin a tough competetion to karunya

i dont want to hurt or criticize any1....even i like karu but i am a really big sandeep fan and by saying wht we saw in sandeep and how bad he singz....u r criticizing us the sandeep fanz.........

if sumfing is said against karu u would feel bad....the same is wid us
we fell bad 2 when u say such stuff abt sandeep 😭
-Tish 😭

Let me share your points dear, as per my views:

1. Complete package u said is sing good, perform good and personality, did u see the last show on 22/4??? From singing to performance it was all Karunya. As far as looking good, it is very objective like some like Amitabh, some shahrukh and some even like abhay deol. So looks depends on someone's taste BUT singing and performance is universal and there Karunya is 100% perfect.

2. Judges praised sandeep, but how many times compared to Karunya? Did he get standing ovation even once BUT Karunya even on last day he got standing ovation and was told that he will be singer number 1 😊

3. You are forgetting that Kajol said the STAR of the evening is Karunya's Voice!!!!! where were you?

4. I agree that Farah said Sandeep is giving tough competition to Karunya why she did not say vice versa????? That means she knew Karunya is the best and sandeep is trying hard to reach karunya.

Finally, from your points I feel Karunya was complete package before even he joined II2 but Sandeep came as a trainee and I agree he has improved BUT he has long way of learning and short time 😭 BUT we are the loosers and not KARUNYA

Originally posted by: mhk9

Let me share your points dear, as per my views:

1. Complete package u said is sing good, perform good and personality, did u see the last show on 22/4??? From singing to performance it was all Karunya. As far as looking good, it is very objective like some like Amitabh, some shahrukh and some even like abhay deol. So looks depends on someone's taste BUT singing and performance is universal and there Karunya is 100% perfect.

2. Judges praised sandeep, but how many times compared to Karunya? Did he get standing ovation even once BUT Karunya even on last day he got standing ovation and was told that he will be singer number 1 😊

3. You are forgetting that Kajol said the STAR of the evening is Karunya's Voice!!!!! where were you?

4. I agree that Farah said Sandeep is giving tough competition to Karunya why she did not say vice versa????? That means she knew Karunya is the best and sandeep is trying hard to reach karunya.

Finally, from your points I feel Karunya was complete package before even he joined II2 but Sandeep came as a trainee and I agree he has improved BUT he has long way of learning and short time 😭 BUT we are the loosers and not KARUNYA

am i reading all this....i cnnot believe my eyes........how can u guyz criticize sum1 soo much....done and decided bye......i thought u guyz watch your mouths and say something appropriate tht might not hurt sum1 but i cnt take so much offense frm sum1.........i cnt believe this topic is yet not closed....bye guyz.......sorry if i made u mad bcoz i am going sad frm these forums.....i cnt believe sum1 can be o much hypercritical....i am not referring 2 only 1 person

-Tish😭

rajeevzluvr
don't take all these comments personally. I agree with mhk9. i mean that if sandeep was a really great singer then he would not have sung that badly at the final end of indian idol. i mean you too have to agree that he sung badder than usual at the end when they asked him to sing. i mean sandeep sings well but not as well as karunya. and remember, sonu gave karunya many standing ovations in the middle of karunya singing. sandeep never got that. and also, anu malik said karunya will become a number one singer of india. now i won't say sandeep sings badly. he sings well and at certain points he gave a good competiton to karunya but not always. and pl don't leave 😭 . don't take any of these comments personnaly. us karunya fans are hurt by karu not winning. he really deserved it and i wish sandeep all the best! 😊