creatives.. memory issues?

rrk401 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1

heyy everybodyy

i am a regular viewer of RBO but i barely make topicss but the current state of RBO has compelled me to share my views.. i mean the current track is soo disconnected with the past of shaan and khanak

firstly, for over 2 months we tolerated sam, rahul and duck who according to me, had zero chemistry. Then finally when the rock on track gets over, the creatives have conveniently forgotten what they should have remembered.. wasnt the point of the rock on track to make shaan realize his dreams and thus, confidently enter the occupation he always wanted to. so doesnt he kinda have a job and isnt he working hard for it and didnt that concert earn him ANY money, didnt that contract earn him any advance? So WHY ON EARTH is shaan going about earning.. aren't there more mature ways of convincing your wife you love her? Responsibility does not always relate to money.. it is about being there for her and standing up for her during the toughest of times and here we have shaan hugging Rahul, a short while after he learns he was the cheap mind behind the MMS.

Also, shaan in yesterday's episode referred to his hard earned money as his pehli kamai.. ahem ahem.. he is a singer and has also worked at a bhojanale during the epic days of RBO.so why pehil kamaii? WHY?

Also, whats up with soo much screen space to Rahul and jenny.. yes they have a good chemistry.. much more bareable than sam and Rahul but helloo creatives.. odhani was meant to be about shaan and khanak and shouldn't they be shown a lot more?

Ok so venting out done 😊

Please share your views.

Edited by rrk401 - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.1k

Users

7

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

OlicityFan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

@rk (i noe tht is rahul's initial...srry for calling u tht!).... - tht pehli kamaai was a big blooper!...

shaan relates resposibilty to earning money....but this will be explored more in wats coming.....revival of factory .....d one mentioned in the TB article!...

do visit d DT !....and post ur reviews in critic corner...we need them!..

welcome to the forum!...

rrk401 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
yes, the revival of the factory makes sense but creatives need to explore the nuances of shanak's relationship without external factors acting as catalysts.be it the millionth pehli kamai or a factory..
garfield1209 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Hey ..I am trying to answer in my toota phoota way some of your questions....😳

I for one seriously hope the CVs forget the band track even when the story goes back to Mumbai ..They had tried hard to make sense with the band track ,we had tried hard to like it..Both our attempts didnot work out...So instead of trying to connect to the rock on track and go in circles ,they choose this way .I am ok with it instead of again go back to the band and music...my POV solely
Yes he had worked hard but no the contract did not earn him any money ,coz if i remmebr he had done this in charity for Rahul ..coz he did not want to be beholden to Rahul ..😊 ..
@Regarding Money - For Khanak one of the most important attributes which she has said to him many times is - he take responsibilty and earn to support his wife and family .
So he is trying that I guess..Last time he attempted that with the mills project ,started going to office coz of her ..but never saw one thing through ..maybe this reviving factory can bring that ..😊
@Responsibility does not always relate to money.. (loved this line 😊)
Agree it doesnot relate to money .But it can relate to - be it a job or relationship ,you need to see it through thick and thin .Maybe this about that..who know!
@Pehil kamai -This is his first kamai in Dhulwadi in the tasks he has set for himself to win back Khanak😆 ..Neways I feel proud of him like Khanak does evrytime he gets a pehli kamai :)
@Rahul-Shan hug -yep did not make sense😊 ..But Khank doesnot know so whats happening now is just about Shaan and Khanak...
Yes Shaan and Khanaks story is foundation of odhani ..But in this track they are shown but with different character ..We wud see more of them together I guess as per the article when the start working on thefactory thing 😊
Have fun and be active more often!
Edited by priya1209 - 14 years ago
Anu80 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
I think one of the characteristics of Shaan is that he is all excited when something is new , like the cloth mill project then after the project takes off he is no longer interested in keeping his words..
And in one of the heated argruements with Sunil he even mentions the same...
And its the same with his relationship with Khanak, he worked hard to win her love but then he took it for granted that it will continue the same till the end... and Khanak has many a times reminded him of taking the relationship not so seriously be it the scene before the SR or when she leaves the letter saying she is practicing to leave home before he goes on the tour.

And regarding the nth kamayi, it was probably his first one in 1000s.. hahaha.. and as priya wrote it he did this singing this for free, remember the scenes with him and Rahul before KT went on his illness break... the one in the bhojanalay was like an earning to get home not the one that sustains for long...

Yes I do agree the CVs not only here but in many a serials have memory issues and issues with the time that has passed by...

And here in Dhulwadi track, its not about the money he earns that is important for Khanak, I think they want to show that he realises to take up his own responsibilities, face the struggles of life all by himself and that there is no spoon feeding for him...
I think this will be explored better in the next week's track as they showed in the precap..
rrk401 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
thankyouu for aall your replies.. now i do not despise the creatives so much.
and i am definitely looking forward to the factory revival trackk..you peeps have put my hopes highh.
anasuyaskbm thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
Seriously was thinking the same about pehli kamai, when Shan had given his second kamai to Khanak a lot time back. Regarding abt responsibility and earning he already has a job as a big singer. Okay fine if he doesn't want to leave Khanak in the village and want to earn his own money der to take her back , I love Shan about that. But the dialogues are so confusing sometimes. Please CVs don't jeopardize the show. I love this show only in the entire tellywood channel.
Edited by anasuyaskbm - 14 years ago
destinylove thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#8
Hey he (shaan) might have meant first days earning at dhulwadi
aditee thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
RRK,
Great post!
We have been lamenting over the disconnect between infidelity and being gainfully employed for days now
Thanks for making a separate topic on this
It is quite ridiculous actually to see him wander around and beg for work and be paid Rs1000 to make cow dung patties or what ever
I dont think he needs any special care or sympathy for that either.
What I absolutely HATED yesterday was Madz walking over to Khanak in the kitchen and pleading with her saying "Shaan maafi maang chuka hai, woh tumhaare liye ITNI TAKLEEF UTHA CHUKA HAI, AB TO MAAF KAR DO"😡😡
Really?
I was flabbergasted that the issue was about him getting a JOB!
I think I am watching a different show altogether when ever I see his family GUSH over him coz he worked like a REAL MAN for ONE DAY!
Most men do that 9-7 ...240 days a year!
Its shameful they would glorify Shaan this way
It all goes back to the erosion of his character
This was a guy who started going into the office in JULY.
Falling in love makes people idiots but it actually worked positively in Shaan's case
He wanted to impress Khanak, he wanted to be mature, he wanted to be responsible.
At the end of the noodles scene , he holds her wrist and says "I want to make this work, I want to do everything possible"
Later when she is feeding him kheer he again says "Its all about being responsible, I owe your family money, and I will make sure I pay them off"
This man has shown such amazing thoughtfuless and maturity
What we see today is a sad caricature of the most complex, mature, passionate, impulsive, playful...........yet immensely loveable man
Dont hold your breath coz the infidelity track is JUST NOT going to be addressed with the maturity and sensibility that we expect
Warm Regards
A
Edited by aditee - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".