Watch

TEAM

Debate Mansion India Forums

Is it right to beat your wife? - Page 30

First Previous

Page

Created

15years

Last reply

14years

Replies

Views

Users

Likes

Frequent Posters

souro

@souro

Alumni

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#291

People keep on saying that this topic is not even debatable and yet we get 38 pages. 😕

Quote

abandoned

@abandoned

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 14 years ago

#292

i dont think beating is an option..mayb scolding if its genuinely a wrong action..........

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

return_to_hades

@return_to_hades

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 14 years ago

#293

Originally posted by: souro
People keep on saying that this topic is not even debatable and yet we get 38 pages. 😕

Looks like the new fad is sex, SRK and wifebeaters. This topic is turning to be that wife who just won't stay down beaten. 😆

Quote

Summer3

@Summer3

Trailblazer

+ 2

Posted: 14 years ago

#294

Reminds me of the controvertial figure Ron Hubbard, author of scientific novels, He too married many times but seems like he was never good to his wives. He was a psychopath it seems.

Quote:

Publicly, Hubbard was sociable and charming. Privately, he wrote entries in his notebook like "All men are your slaves," and "You can be merciless whenever your will is crossed and you have the right to be merciless."

Edited by Summer3 - 14 years ago

Quote

Elsa

@Sweet_Waters

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#295

Originally posted by: -JONAKI-
Some husbands beat their wives when they are angry with them.Sometimes when there is a fight between husband and wife the husband slaps the wife.Some husbands also say sorry after beating their wives.And the wives forgive their husbands because she has learnt from childhood that husbands are like God and they can control your life.The husbands also feel that since he is the earner of the house he has full rights on his wife and so if she is wrong then he can beat him.They beleive that if fathers can beat a girl for her well being then he also has the right to beat her.Some girls want to get rid of these types of husbands but they can not divorce as they have children.
What do you feel is it right for a man to beat his wife?If the huband feels that the wife is doing something wrong then can he slap her?Is it right for a woman to endure all torture just for the sake of her child?What impact does this event have on a child?Should these husbands be punished by the law?

I appreciate you for bringing in such a wonderful topic....Many women are suffering but still these issues are kept under wraps either for fear or with the thought of what people might think...

A husband beating his wife can never be justified on any grounds.Even if the wife commits a wrong, it doesn't mean that he has to beat her.Infact if he does that, the wife will indeed develop some sort of seperation atleast in her mind and probably she will not be able to love her husband as she did.It's true that the husband is the head of a family.But it's not to be forgotten that his wife is his main support...A woman is not a slave to be beaten up as and when someone wishes.She is also a human being.It is said that, when a man marries a woman, he should treat her as his own....She becomes a part of him....No man in this world would hurt himself knowingly. Wife is a part of husband itself and should be treated like that....

It doesn't mean that, wife can live however she wants.Indeed, she is bound to obey her husband if she feels that what he says is true and is justifiable.In certain issues, husband may become adamant and in such cases the wife should try her best to adjust with him and to lead a peaceful life...

Family life is itself full of adjustments.Unless and until both the partners adjust themselves, a peaceful life is not possible.Forgiveness is necessary and each of the partner should believe that this is the man/woman God has destined for me and I have to live my life with him/her.If the husband/wife feels what his/her partner does is wrong, he/she has every right to correct her but not by hurting the partner.If the partner is not ready to go by your way, then leave it.It's enough that you do your duty by telling him/her that her action is wrong.Also one can stand on his decission and there is no need to support his/her actions if that act is wrong...

Children indeed with have an impact as if it is a girl child, she will have a fear towards men in her heart.In case of boys, they will always have some inner pain which may blurt out as anger towards their father....Children will have less respect to their father in such families....

Both the partners should try their maximum to go foward with the relation and if it is not possible then it would be better to part and live independently.Whether the husbands should be punished or not, we can't just judge regarding that matter....Just my POV....No offence to anyone😊

Edited by ding_dong - 14 years ago

Quote

chal_phek_mat

@chal_phek_mat

Inactive

Posted: 14 years ago

#296

Originally posted by: souro
People keep on saying that this topic is not even debatable and yet we get 38 pages. 😕

well depending on the situation the topic may not be debatable😆, shaadi karke dekho pata chal jayega😉

Perhaps that is the reason the topic keeps on popping back up😆

Quote

Anthony

@Polar Bear

Beginner

Posted: 14 years ago

#297

A man does not have the right to beat his wife or a woman.

In fact, no person has the right to beat another person.

Marriage is a mutual attraction/interest for two persons to enjoy a meaningful relationship.

Women are to be protected and not to be abused physically and/or mentally.