Is it a crime to know whats going on??

Angelic_A thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Okay one thing I do not understand at all is why Radha bhua is blamaing Suhana for tying to figure out whats going on with her and Deepak. I mean if you are in a family especially a joint family and see that something is not going on right then who wouldn't question what's happening?
The way Radha Bhua was talking aganist Suhana in today's episode was not right. I agree that what ever happened with Radha bhua was not right and its a pain she must carry thoughout her life.. but Suhana does not know about it. If she doesn't want to tell her then don't but atleast maybe talk to her once and explain her situation on not to quesition anything about it.
Comments..?

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

2k

Users

12

Likes

19

Frequent Posters

15836 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
Hmmm, I have some thoughts but they will be very random, so forgive me in advance ji.
From Radha's perspective:
I think her being agitated about Suhana trying to find out the reasons is alright. The kids of the house do not know that she was raped by a guy her husband sold her to. She is a rape victim and it is close to impossible at times to come out of that wound. Pschologically, this abuse stays with a woman-no matter how understanding a family may be. She finds a medium to exercise her frustration/hurt/anger/pain on something. Radha's medium is Deepika; moreso b/c he is her son with a resemblence to her rapist. That is torture for a woman. One needs to understand that the pain of rape exceeds rather than decrease for many.
Radha may be afraid of what will happen when the kids will find out. The love and respect will still be there, but she may be afraid that sympathy will also follow. For a rape victim (for my encounters with some) is that you need to be very careful in the emotions you emote towards them. Psychologically, every emotion weighs much for them. She may feel ashamed that the kids know, and will go into thinking they think of her differently (when that will not be the case, but the victim will think so). What will her Ishaan think now or the pity that the kids will have on her. Pity can kill, and for a victim is a major trigger for depression.
Suhana:
She is not wrong at all. She does not know, and feels that Deepak is treated unfairly. She has just begun to see what family means and the importance. From there she is being family to Deepak and rightly asks why that love is not given to Deepak. In her point of view, she is doing something she does not find wrong (and for me it is very sweet of her to take care of a family member like that). Suhana wants to know, and in a joint family I think she deserves to know-at least something. If no one is going to tell her anything, then she has every right to talk to Deepak and give him affection of a family.
It is very difficult to actually take sides for me. Solely going by half a heart, I would love to take Suhana's side b/c I feel bad for Deepak. As an outsider I see no fault of his, and see his mother treating him unjustly. I see Radha's ordering the family to stay away very bad. However, with the other half of my heart and mind I see Radha, a victim of something I cannot psychologically feel but have seen. The horror rape leaves behind can be something no other abuse may inflict. The fear of losing dear ones to that abuse, the pity, the self-hatred-it is unimaginable. It is very difficult for a victim to share something so painful. Radha's reactions are not wrong or mean in that sense b/c this is how she may cope. No matter how wrong I may see it from one view, the other view shows me a woman in pain.
That's all for now. Running a bit late ji. Sorry if not making sense.
psycho_angel thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
i agree...initially Suhaana was a private person and Radha and the entire family had problems with it.they never respected her privacy and would barge into her room all times for the AC or whatever reason they had.now that Suhaana has adapted herself to the family's lifestyle(which is a huge step for her,we all know what environment she has been brought up in),the family should share more with her instead of alienating her.even though what happened to Radha Bua is a sensitive topic,it should be discussed with Suhaana.No sane human being would stop short of sympathizing with Radha when they hear her side of the story.and both Radha and Badi maa know that Suhaana is immature but not insensitive.she feels for others.the way she behaved with Meena is a good example.So why are they keeping stuff from her?she's a part of the family too ,right?if Rajni-Disha know the secret,then Suhaana should be let in on it too,especially by Ishaan.
Edited by mjhtac - 15 years ago
gunjabhy thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
If suhana has a right to knw whats going on in the home, every1 else has a right to knw whats up with suhana and sid and ishan n what she did n y she got merried n how she thinks that her life is ruined...............
lovely_lady thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

I think Radha Bua might not want to tell people of her ordeal because she doesnt want to talk about it. Neither does she want the younger generation to look at her differently, ie. pity. But I do believe she needs to give Suhana a small explaination or something. Like the slap coming up in an episode was so uncalled for.

gunjabhy thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
Till now, she has not been involved into any household metters, any housework. she probebly doesnt even know how the kitchen looks like in her house, and now all of a sudden she wants to knw whats going on in an important metter like this. Did she cared before what was going on in the house????????
myvoice thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#7
Does Rajni or Disha know about Radha bua's past?? I don't think any of the younger ones know about the truth......they sense something is wrong, but they aren't questioning things to keep peace at home.
Radha bua wants to be as far away from Deepak as possible and hence she doesn't want anyone else in the house to get close to Deepak.
Suhaana being herself is naturally curious about Deepak-Radha bua's equation, parivar log askin her not to interact with Deepak is only making her more determined to find out the what is wrong....which will disturb Radha more, hopefully in the end it would help her come to terms with the truth that she needs to find a way to forget her pain and accept her son.
lashy thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 15 years ago
#8
simran you have voiced my thoughts and if i dare say possibly the thoughts of most of the viewers.. everyone pities Radha bua... but i guess that in the previous two episodes have started developing a soft corner for suhana as she is trying in her own (nevertheless carefree) way to gel in with the family and hence her childlike efforts to get to know the family's problems etc.
Seeing that Suhana is quite a private person herself... if Radha bua had pulled her into a room for a few moments and told her in many words to respect her decision etc etc...i guess suhana would have approached the problem differently... 😊
Edited by lashy - 15 years ago
bunmaska thumbnail
21st Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#9
It is just not fair on Radha Bua's part to treat Deepak this way. My heart goes out to the young boy. Even while Radha bua slaps suhana it was Deepak I felt sorry for. I mean what is the boy's fault that he is treated like that by the entire family. Radha Bua seriously needs to sit and think about it and let bygones be bygones.
pinkmonkey_2004 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#10
This could be looked at interferingly but .. the fact is, Suhaana is doing this with very pure and innocent intentions so in this case, neither is wrong.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".