MNIK -Hit or not - Page 2

Originally posted by: tweety_lovely

i have seen many articles tht CLAIM IT WAS A FLOP AS WELL.😆😆😆😆..I KNOW ITS NOT true...but they are quite hillarious..😆😆😆😆😆😆.

My Name is Khan completes a hat-trick of flops for Shah Rukh Khan
Tuesday, February 23, 2010

Playing to near empty houses now, My Name is Khan managed to collect just over 8 crores in India in its 2nd weekend, down by around 70% in its weekend 1, despite not having any release issues as was the case in opening weekend. Occupancies typically ranged from 30% to 5% for the film which had an open run created to it by the lack of big releases two weeks prior and two weeks afterwards.

The film had an increase of 5 theaters in its 2nd weeekend in North America, but lost by 64% in collections there also.

Optimistic trade analysts have pegged losses of MNIK at 20 crores minimum.

The film is the 2nd straight flop for Karan Johar after his disastrous Qurbaan featuring Saif Ali Khan-Kareena Kapoor and for Shah Rukh Khan it goes one further. It completes a hat trick of flops, starting with home production flop Billu in same time last year in February 2009, followed by Dulha Mil Gaya in January 2010, followed by My Name is Khan in February 2010.

https://www.ibosnetwork.com/newsmanager/templates/template1.aspx?a=22057&z=4

i hate misleading media!! that's exactly y aamir got pissed off at them at a point of time!

Originally posted by: AmritaRao-Nina

^LMAO that article, it was definetly not a flop 🤣 ..i was just wondering how well it did do.

That is good news thanks for feedback it deserved to do well😊..actually come to think of it i kind of remeber seeing that maybe on karans twitter that it did well overseas...

Zee that is a good idea never thought of that will check it out.

Why do you care so much as to whether the movie was a hit or not? At the end of the day you see if you like the movie or not.

I like a movie when I can connect to it & get a favourable emotional response & makes no difference it it was a hit or not.

I though MNIk was okay & found it over-melodramatic.

^ sorry I did not realise we had to justify a question on the forum, I have seen MNIK I never said I was asking wheher to see it or like it, I was curious watching k3g whether it did well like karana othe films. I like movies for wide range of reasons hits have nothin to do with it trust me if u saw my DVD collection. Anyways zee thanks again for links will check it out :)

Originally posted by: AmritaRao-Nina

^ sorry I did not realise we had to justify a question on the forum, I have seen MNIK I never said I was asking wheher to see it or like it, I was curious watching k3g whether it did well like karana othe films. I like movies for wide range of reasons hits have nothin to do with it trust me if u saw my DVD collection. Anyways zee thanks again for links will check it out :)

Sorry I didnt mean it that way, I was just saying a movies collection dont matter to me bcoz at the end of the day I only remember a movie by how good it was not how much money it made.

Hit, but I didn't like it all! I don't why but some of the movies that do well (like Partner, Welcome, Singh is King, Ajab Prem, New York) I really hate or don't at all apreciate and films that have flopped (like Awarapan, Luck By Chance, Tum Mile) I like more!

Originally posted by: pragya0

Sorry I didnt mean it that way, I was just saying a movies collection dont matter to me bcoz at the end of the day I only remember a movie by how good it was not how much money it made.

Sorry as well guess i read it the wrong way 😊

I agree with you 100% thats why some hits stay with you forever and some fade away..


Nina

Originally posted by: sweet coco

Hit, but I didn't like it all! I don't why but some of the movies that do well (like Partner, Welcome, Singh is King, Ajab Prem, New York) I reallyhate or don't at all apreciate and films that have flopped (like Awarapan, Luck By Chance, Tum Mile) I like more!

Agree with you most of those movies i wonder to why they did really well AP only one i liked lol i did like MNIK but its no K3G and KKHH in that its so entertaing you can watch it again and again, but MNIK i think worth appreciation and i can see why some people would not like it just like KANK.

Originally posted by: AmritaRao-Nina

Agree with you most of those movies i wonder to why they did really well AP only one i liked lol i did like MNIK but its no K3G and KKHH in that its so entertaing you can watch it again and again, but MNIK i think worth appreciation and i can see why some people would not like it just like KANK.

i guess it all comes down to taste! some people like a certain genre of movies, I tend to prefer certain types of scripts and and perfromances over others! But I can understand why the movie was liked by many!