Round 1: Shankar Mahadevan

Originally posted by: brahmabul

I'll give it a 9.

A good job for not singing in his usual style and still come tops. a 10 !

what an refreshing song! a clean clear voice. up-beat and nice renditions provided by Shankar Ji. however, it is comparatively easier to sing than his other songs. the high-notes are great. overall, i would like to give a 9 to this song.

I would rate it at 9..its different from shankarji's usual style..
just out of curiosity want to understand the reason behind somebody rating the song at 4 which is like below average

Originally posted by: swati_mjht

I would rate it at 9..its different from shankarji's usual style..
just out of curiosity want to understand the reason behind somebody rating the song at 4...

there are some hidden controversial people. who do not openly acclaim there opinion and want to bring the graph down for some unknown reason.

Originally posted by: somone999

there are some hidden controversial people. who do not openly acclaim there opinion and want to bring the graph down for some unknown reason.

just wanted to say that if somebody votes a song below average then maybe there should be some explanation with it...otherwise probably the vote should be discarded...
Just so to avoid people giving low votes due to personal grudges....

Originally posted by: swati_mjht

just wanted to say that if somebody votes a song below average then maybe there should be some explanation with it...otherwise probably the vote should be discarded...
Just so to avoid people giving low votes due to personal grudges....

Don't worry I am sure risingabove will take care of it.

Originally posted by: swati_mjht

just wanted to say that if somebody votes a song below average then maybe there should be some explanation with it...otherwise probably the vote should be discarded...
Just so to avoid people giving low votes due to personal grudges....

Well we got rid of 1s, 2s and 3s...maybe someone honestly felt it was below average or has a strict grading scale. If people dont have to give reasons for 10s, which could just be because they are big fans and nothing else, then I don't see why people would have to give reasons for 4s either.

Great singing by the singing legend Shankar Mahadevan!

Shankar is without a doubt one of, if not the most talented singer in bollywood. His high pitches were great in this song, and he matched the beat and sang the song perfect to the beat. Which he should be really good at anyways, since he is a MD. But once again, he handeled the difficult portions of the song very well, just felt that there weren't that many difficult portions, though he handeled them great. Such as the
"Masti Mein Rahe Dooba Dooba Hameshaa Samaa"
that was sang great. Wish we would've seen more of that througout the song from the singing legend Shankar Mahadevan.



Rating: 8/10