How would the forum react? - Page 2

i think with Shankar vs Himesh people would support Shankar

But of course there is growing dislike for Shankar since there is a larger amount of Shaan fans out there.

Thanks for the reply.

Now, let me rephrase the question.

1 )If the roles were reversed and Shankar was in shaans place and reacted the same way, what would be your honest opinion /reaction?

2 ) If shaan had sung twice in a match with Shreya and she had reacted the same way[minus flinging her top, of course! ] 😳 , how would you react?

Sorry for asking these uncomfortable questions. 😳

Originally posted by: nithyak

1 )If the roles were reversed and Shankar was in shaans place and reacted the same way, what would be your honest opinion /reaction?

2 ) If shaan had sung twice in a match with Shreya and she had reacted the same way[minus flinging her top, of course! ] 😳 , how would you react?

Sorry for asking these uncomfortable questions. 😳

on Question number one - most of the people will say that shaan can never do that.. anyways, my opnion is that, i would analyse both of their opinions and see their perspective, and would ultimately find both of them Justified in their respective places.. just like what i feel of it now, i would have felt the same.. because They are such Great Names that i don't consider myself the person to Criticize or condemn their POVs.. So i would like to enjoy the performances and relax 😆

on Question number two - Hahaah @ the joke 😆... no way, it would be perfectly acceptable if a captain comes to sing twice, if there is no rule that how much times a captain can come, then i can never condemn a captain to come out two times or three times or four times, to support his team, he is the sailor of his ship ofcourse, who has to steer it out towards success.. had there been a RULE that captain has to come only once, then in that case, i would have condemned the captain who comes twice..

P.S nice questions! yet again!

Originally posted by: shivani003

Arrre dont forget "Mann ka Radio.... Bajne de zara" 😆

Haahaha.. and that song "Kitnay arman arman man man man man man..." 😆

Originally posted by: nithyak

But of course there is growing dislike for Shankar since there is a larger amount of Shaan fans out there.

Thanks for the reply.

Now, let me rephrase the question.

1 )If the roles were reversed and Shankar was in shaans place and reacted the same way, what would be your honest opinion /reaction?

2 ) If shaan had sung twice in a match with Shreya and she had reacted the same way[minus flinging her top, of course! ] 😳 , how would you react?

Sorry for asking these uncomfortable questions. 😳

as you are speculating lot of things which will not happen for sure. bcoz SHaan is not Shankar who bends the rules to gain. looking at history we can safely say that shaan will not do it..

and we expect shaan to play fair, and he does not need to come twice, he has the best singers unlike shankar or himesh..

If Shaan had the team members that Shankar and Himesh have, will he then bend the non existant rules to gain??

Originally posted by: nithyak

If Shaan had the team members that Shankar and Himesh have, will he then bend the non existant rules to gain??

what do you think?

You tell me.
Would like to hear your opinion too.

My opinion is all these captains have reached a stage in their life[either by singing through their nose, mouth whatever], am a very small person to comment about their singing except to do wah wah !

Behaviour on national TV is another matter. All i can say is maine kabhi zindagi mein socha nahi that folks will stoop down to levels like this.I can understand because we are after all [un]social animals.

Originally posted by: nithyak

You tell me.
Would like to hear your opinion too.

My opinion is all these captains have reached a stage in their life[either by singing through their nose, mouth whatever], am a very small person to comment about their singing except to do wah wah !

Behaviour on national TV is another matter. All i can say is maine kabhi zindagi mein socha nahi that folks will stoop down to levels like this.I can understand because we are after all [un]social animals.

as you started all speculating then you should come clean about your stand. So, instead of going round about, come to the point and answer the question you asked.

Whom you are referring as folks, take the name so that all can clearly know that. no genralisation please. so that we can take the cases separately ...

I am very clear. All the captains.
You said Shaan will not behave like that.If the question is reversed, do you still stand by it??