MNIK(American Version)- REVIEWS (Pg125) *Spoilers* - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

974

Views

60.5k

Users

101

Likes

947

Frequent Posters

455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

SRK, Kajol ace in MNIK

Last updated on: February 11, 2010 19:08 IST
Tags: Kajol, Rizvan Khan, Shah Rukh Khan, Karan Johar, Mandira

A scene from My Name is KhanHow's the chicken?' asks the hostess.

'It's not very good,' says Rizvan Khan truthfully. There's laughter, because the answer is truthful, yet innocent of malice -- Rizvan, the Asperger's Syndrome-afflicted protagonist of Karan Johar's [ Images ] My Name Is Khan is incapable of lies or malice -- and a tense situation is defused.

This is also what the movie is about -- a tale about a man who is 'different' and how the lives of those around him are affected because of his 'difference.'

Those of you who have seen the trailers, and most of you haven't, will know this is a love story between Shah Rukh Khan [ Images ] (Rizvan) and Kajol [ Images ] (Mandira), that the destruction of New York's Twin Towers impacts their relationship and that Rizvan has an overpowering need to meet and tell the president of the United States that his name is Khan and he is not a terrorist.

That, essentially, is the 'plot' of the film, and I won't tell you more, because you might otherwise feel like posting some not-very-complimentary messages to me on the message board below. :)

But here's what I will tell you.

My Name Is Khan is a true Bollywood product -- it makes you laugh, it makes you cry, it even makes you shake your head at the occasional 'Bollywood' touches director Karan Johar just can't seem to resist (he could have, for example, avoided the pre-interval pan shot to the Koran; the message would have come through just as effectively).

It takes you though parts of America that Bollywood has not explored before -- Georgia, for instance, gets quite a bit of footage -- and uses American characters not showcased by mainstream Bollywood earlier -- Mamma Jenny and funny hair Joel, take a bow.

A scene from My Name is KhanThe film, like all Karan Johar products, is beautifully cinematographed (director of photography Ravi K Chandran). The difference this time is it is not the typically bright coloured, candy floss flavours that permeates Karan's films.

If there is one quibble, it would be the fact that Karan Johar could have made effective use of the talented bunch of actors who make cameo appearances.

Good actors, even in cameo roles, make an impact -- as we have seen in many films recently. In My Name Is Khan, they are unfortunately wasted. Anyone, for example, could have played the roles Vinay Pathak [ Images ] or Sumeet Raghavan did. Praveen Dabas, in fact, was miscast -- Sumeet Raghavan would have been much more effective in the same role.

The lead pair, however, is clearly well-cast; Shah Rukh and Kajol share a superb chemistry that highlights all their films, and is an important part of My Name Is Khan.

There are three films in which I have really liked Shah Rukh Khan (yes, I do like him otherwise too, SRKisms and all, because he can make you smile) -- Saathiya [ Images ], Swades [ Images ] and Chak De! India [ Images ]. To that, I'd add My Name Is Khan.

I've never met anyone afflicted with Asperger's Syndrome, so I can't say with certainty that Shah Rukh has portrayed the condition correctly. But he is believable and makes you like and feel sympathy for Rizvan at the right moments. It's the first time in the star's 18-year-long career (his first film was Deewana in 1992) that he has essayed such a character. He's not the chocolate hero, he's not beating up the bad guys, he's not trying to look good or entertain you as Shah Rukh Khan. And it works!

Kajol is, as usual, superb. Mandira's laughter, her determination, her joie de vivre, her grief, her anger -- Kajol brings it all to life. And, if I may say so, Kajol, no one runs up a hill dressed in a night suit, wearing floppy slippers, with no make-up on, as well as you do.

A scene from My Name is KhanOthers, too, do well -- Sonya Jehan is very beautiful and portrays her part with great sympathy and, hopefully, we will get to see more of this talented actress.

Tanay Chheda (Taare Zameen Par [ Images ], Slumdog Millionaire [ Images ]) is clearly very talented and does an excellent job as the young Rizvan.

Arjan Aulja, you were excellent. I wish I could talk more about what you did, but it would give the plot away.

Let's end this review with the climax -- it's a tad filmi, and there were some bits that I thought were a slight stretch of the imagination. But hey, this is a Karan Johar film and everyone likes a happy ending!

Rediff Rating:

Do you want to watch My Name is Khan? Click here!

If you come across any violence or demonstrations against My Name is Khan, here's your chance to play Citizen Journalist. Report it!

455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
@GabbbarSingh: #Mynameis Gabbar Singh and I tried my level best to prevent Esha deol from happening. The new trending topic ---- MyNameIs...LOL
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Some Mumbai multiplexes start screening 'MNIK' (Lead)

Mumbai, Feb 12

There was no first show of Shah Rukh Khan's much discussed "My Name Is Khan" here Friday as theatre owners shied away from exhibiting the film following violence by the Shiv Sena. But by noon some of the multiplexes started screening the film and others are expected to do the same later in the day.

Fun Cinemas began their first show at 12 noon, while the multiplex Fame is expected to start at 2.30 p.m. There was extra security around the multiplexes in this financial and entertainment capital of India.

Actress Pooja Bedi who came to Fun Cinemas with her father Kabir Bedi couldn't get tickets. All they saw was a House Full sign.

"I am certainly disappointed for not getting tickets but very happy that the film is going House Full. Police are doing a fabulous job. People need not fear at all. I walked down the street, there were no one with lathi (stick) and stones," Bedi told reporters outside the Fun Cinemas multiplex in Andheri West.

The movie was originally scheduled to hit 63 cinema halls in Mumbai. It ran into trouble as Shiv Sainiks started going on the rampage Tuesday, to protest Shah Rukh Khan's statement that Pakistani cricketers should have been included in this year's edition of the Indian Premier League.

Early afternoon, other multiplexes and major cinema owners were still closeted in a meeting with the movie's distributors and producers to sort out the issue of adequate security if they did decide to screen the film. Their decision is expected to be known later this afternoon.

The no-show in the morning came despite assurance of adequate security for the movie screening by Chief Minister Ashok Chavan, Home Minister R.R. Patil, Minister of State for Home Ramesh Bagwe and Police Commissioner D. Shivanandhan.

Halls that did not screen the film include the G-7 cinemas, Apsara, Maratha Mandir, Dadar Plaza, Broadway and other single-screen halls.

In a related development, Revenue Minister Narayan Rane demanded that the registration of Shiv Sena as a political party be cancelled.

crazy fanatic thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
Hope SRK knows about the happenings in India. In Kolkatta fans are burning effigies of Thackeray. SUCH support from all over. He has a reason to be happy now!!! And also see how dedicated his fans are.
khanrocks thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

not suprised its getting a good opening go mnik team

455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
From Twitter
@kjohar25 I am not a fan of hindi movies but I will go and see MNIK to support people who speak the truth and stand up for their principles
-RD- thumbnail
Hogwarts Championship 2025 Thumbnail Gulaal-e-Jung Thumbnail + 9
Posted: 15 years ago
Not such a great film as its made out to be by the reviews ...and definitely i didnt expect much from kjo seeing his past products and even then i found it a let down considering the plot itself was so unrealistic and over dramatised ...typical kjo style but the most astonishing fact is that someone like srk did not live up to my expectations however bad the movie i have never had complains from srk but this time i do ....................not up to the mark ...definitely ....Kajol ....cool as always ....but nothing more that i can mention in the positives !!!!!
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

SRK rocks, Kajol ditto

Khalid Mohamed | Cinema Ray, Editors, Exclusive | February 11, 2010 at 9:35 am Print

My Name is Khan

Cast: Shah Rukh Khan, Kajol, no one else matters except Zarina Wahab maybe who does an accomplished turn as Ammi India

Director: Karan Johar

Rating: Four stars

Your heart goes out to him. Hungry as hell, he accepts a roti roll from strangers in a bus cutting through the nightscape of America. He wolfs one down, shoving the other one poker-faced in his pocket. A perfect awwww-moment.

Indeed such vignettes are the most appealing aspect of the much-beleaguered My Name is Khan. Take, too, the man's monologue on the unbearable pain of losing a loved one. Clearly, here's the film's finest moment which moistens your eyes. As they do again when the vulnerable Khan is lashed by rain on a lonely highway. Or as he walks on a red-brick-walled street jejunely, striving to control his body language. And there's that tearing sequence when he mutters-stutters in an ice-cold hospital corridor on confronting tragedy.

Karan Johar's plea for global secularism,in the wake of the 9/11 devastation ,brims over with quite a few emotionally stirring punctuation marks. The entire text, alas, is neither convincing nor insightful. Like it or not, the subject required at least a patina of gritty realism and an experiential howl of protest. Instead, the result is more gloss than solid substance.

Huh huh huh…Fatally, the concluding reels fly off into la-la land, upgrading the little man grappling with insurmountable Kryptonite odds into a Super-duperman. Nuh, nuh, nuh.

Blame the glaring unevenness, essentially, to the screenplay, which believe it or not has shades of the Raj Kapoor-produced Ab Dilli Door Nahin (1957), in which wronged kids sought the attention of Pandit Nehru. Plus, Khan, afflicted by autism (Asperger's syndrome, it is specified), has elements of Forrest Gump, and the nervy habit of rolling pebbles in a hand – a throwback to Humphrey Bogart's shifty act in Caine Mutiny. A coincidental quirk, perhaps, but it's there. Bogey Wogey?

Honestly, of all Johar's scripts, this one takes far too many potshots in the dark. (Incidentally, the solo credit for the writing goes to Shibani Bhatija, thank you very much). Devoid of truly dramatic conflict, the written material is lean on ideas, culminating in a finale that's a mega-mess. Spoiler alert? Wait, wait, wait. Suffice it to say there's a mega-hurricane to handle, a marooned group of black souls filmed in the shadows and occasional close-ups, followed by bonhomie shared with…you don't want to know. Oh.

So, why the four stars above? Purely for two outstanding performances which assert that even if the two artistes were to read out telephone directories, they would still command your undivided attention, besides giving you a serious case of the goose bumps. Shah Rukh Khan and Kajol – bring them together – and any filmmaker's job is already accomplished. Their gift for raising ordinary material to the extraordinary is sheer delight. Here are ageless dilwales whose chemistry, physics, algebra –call it what you will – is as intoxicating as the world's finest champagne. Cheers!

Proof: the after-wedding scene when both are on bed, waiting for the other to make the first move. When he does, it's awwww-some. In fact, the film's first-half hinging on their romance is sheer delight, besides catching Johar at what he is more proficient at: charm, tongue-in-chic humour and cashmere warmth. Full marks to Johar for that.

Now, how you wish the director would consolidate his skills in this area of human behavour. Sorry, but he is a goldfish in a bowl, blowing bubbles, when it comes to swimming through societal and political currents. Awareness has to be innate, not narrated second-or-third-hand. Kabhi Islamic Issues Na Kehna.. just check out Garm Hawa to get clued into realpolitik. Please, please, please.

The plot, jagged and jejune, deals of course with Gump (Shah Rukh Khan) and his child-like love for a single mother (Kajol) and her knee-high son. Just sample that moment when he stops her from eating calorie-packed chocolates. Next: trouble in paradise. She accuses his faith for a tragic loss. Ergo, he must make a symbolic trip – up and way from home – for redemption. In this act, he remains true to his self, weaknesses intact, a loser, who must do right, to regain perhaps the only person he has ever loved. Follow encounters with fundamentalists, piggish cops, and assorted travellers.

Throughout, Ravi C Chandran's cinematography is cool and collected, except when the visuals dip into Hollywood-style special effects. Ehsan-Shankar-Loy's music score needed far more fervour, and the lyrics far more maturity (Tere naina is as shallow as they come). The dialogue aims to be punchy but is frequently strictly marshmallow. Mush ado.

Never mind. At the end of 18 reels, you do carry something precious home – SRK and Kajol. They are absolutely electric. Undoubtely, they don't make'em like that anymore. And never will, which is why MNIK is absolutely compulsory viewing. You may have problems with it. Yet it is a must-must-see.

PS: Am an unabashed SRK fan…and supremely proud of it. No one else compares to him today…

PS:The film's release has been stopped in certain states for politically partisan reasons. Support it, NOW.

http://passionforcinema.com/srk-rocks-kajol-ditto/
"Mama I'm not afraid they will take what they will take... Like a hobo in my broken home - Nothing's gonna stop me" - Charlie Winston he he he he
455517 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
http://ibnlive.in.com/news/srk-wins-sena-loses-mumbai-watches-mnik/110036-3.html?from=tn
I guess some people don't want to loose "paisa paisa"....
Edited by lalixlili - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: wat_up

5 months ago

American vibing to Salman Khans song

https://zeenews.india.com/viral/american-man-vibes-of-salman-khans-teri-chunariyaaa-song-while-driving-video-goes-viral-2871240.html/amp

https://zeenews.india.com/viral/american-man-vibes-of-salman-khans-teri-chunariyaaa-song-while-driving-video-goes-viral-2871240.html/amp
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: Maroonporsche

1 months ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

23 days ago

Dhadak 2 - Reviews And Box Office

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818

https://x.com/UmairSandu/status/1950399005738901818
Expand ▼
Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: oyebollywood

23 days ago

Bollywood Thumbnail

Posted by: priya185

28 days ago

Mandala murders reviews -Vaani Kapoor

Mandala murders reviews Vaani Kapoor www.youtube.com%2Fwatch%3Fv%3DKYD__HR-oac

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".