Originally posted by: saregama
Dont you think that Himani, Vineet and Hema are the worst candidates now. They are just cowards and whatever talent they have should not be taken into consideration for their behaviour on the stage where all the three rushed together on the stage when deboo received maximum votes and was declared as reaching in top three. All the three got scared of deboo or may be jealous of deboo and could not take the fact that he received maximum percentage of votes. They claimed that they are walking out just because Nihira was voted out. If it was so, then why they didnot walk-out that time, the moment Nihira was eliminated? Weren't they happy that time that they had a chance to win as the best candidate has gone now. Deboo was the guy who was genuinely sad when Nihira was voted out so why they didnot include deboo that time to threat to walk out. Now are these three candidates big stars to behave in that manner? It these were the reasons to walk-out then, why Himani vineet and Hema were dancing happily in the begining and were expressing their happiness. And why did they protest as soon as deboo got maximum?
And about ID going out, it was genuine because he felt that the best candidate and the most deserving candidate Nihira has been voted out even though she deserved to be the winner. It would have been the morale boost for the industry if she was the winner. She was much ahead of these people and was technically perfect in her singing. But still he could manage to attend next day's performance show. But when he saw that deboo inspite of singing well scored minimum marks, he could not bear it. And I agree with him because Deboo was best in qawali round with his powerful performance with lots of taans, sargams alaaps etc and the other three were mediocre and Himani's qawali sounded like a mujra and these three scored 10s from mentors. What about deboo who sang so nicely? So ID's walkout was genuine as he felt that there is some conspiracy to eliminate his good candidate deboojit. If you have a musical ears you will get to know about deboo's singing and ID walking out was genuine. So to expose the true colours of AS and HR, he had to take the step of walking out. Since then, not only AS and HR but all the rest of the three candidates, VINEET HIMANI AND HEMA showed their true colours.
AS and HR being a mentor to a music world, this was not expected from you. Both of you are very biased and never had the spirit or to praise other contestants but played your own games. Music is sadhana and this should be treated as god and when you are the mentors then one should have spirit of appreciating others.
I dont know ID personally but I have seen him praising other candidates as well as criticising his own candidates at times. This shows spirit in him with the music. And if he would have not taken this step of walking out then the true colours of this people would have not got exposed.
How cowards this people are?
AS HR and above all Vineet Himani and Hema are not the deserving candidates any more.