Is Black Really Ranis Best Work?

Page

Next Last

Poll

Agree?

Altaf Hussain

@Taify

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Hey

Rani is a fantastic actor and she has proved it again and again.

Her stars are in "gardish" these days so she isn't coming up with great films . Whats seen mostly is when the articles talk about her performance they mostly revolve around Black .

Do you agree it's her best work till date?

I personally disagree . She was brilliant in the movie (no two opinions on that) but i think her best role and performance has to be Hum Tum.

Thats where she took that giant stride. The role has many shades in it and she carried it with perfection.

Discuss.

Quote

Frequent Posters

shivangi

@shivzi

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

i find Black her best work till date!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Altaf Hussain

@Taify

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

I dunno why i feel that was an easy role =P

Quote

zara

@khanrocks

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

i feel it is she was stunning in it

Quote

Niharika Jain

@Ultimate_Shadow

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

her role in veer-zaara moved me...

Quote

@pksanam

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

i believe so, yes...!

but i loved her performances in chalte chalte, saathiya, and hum tum as well... she was superb in those roles...

Quote

zara

@khanrocks

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

yuva was her second best she played the abused bengali wife convincingly

Quote

293418

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Yuva is probably my favorite Rani Mukherjee role, and that is the one role I really thought she did a great job. It showed a different side to her and she showed range on her part with her spiritedness and ultimately her helplessness.

Black, I cannot overlook the overacting. That is a major quip I have with that role. But some of her roles that I happen to like where she played a supporting role and was a scene stealer would have to be Veer Zaara where she played a lawer and Saawariya, she was great here.

Quote

415781

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: dizzyonlemonade
Yuva is probably my favorite Rani Mukherjee role, and that is the one role I really thought she did a great job. It showed a different side to her and she showed range on her part with her spiritedness and ultimately her helplessness.

Black, I cannot overlook the overacting. That is a major quip I have with that role. But some of her roles that I happen to like where she played a supporting role and was a scene stealer would have to be Veer Zaara where she played a lawer and Saawariya, she was great here.

Could not agree more. Black was over the top in every single department.

Yuva has to be her best performance. I also really liked her in Hey Ram - another supporting role.

Quote

293418

Suspended

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

How could I forget Hey Ram? Stupid me, I saw that such a long time ago when I was so young. I need to see it revisit it at some point, and I would definitely recommend it to you if you are a RM fan. She was phenomenal there.

Although the film is not too great and probably the Sudhir Mishra film I like the least and perhaps dislike, Rani's performance in Calcutta Mail had me seeing her in a whole different light.

Edited by dizzyonlemonade - 16 years ago