*sigh* Salman wins at everything...

Tamedtempest thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
I don't know about anyone else but I am getting tired of how Salman wins almost EVERY postive poll around here.
best dancer/strongest contestant/best guy/most likely to win...etc.

I mean really?? What is everyone voting on??
Just his looks or what??

so many other of the contestants out rank him, (at least in my opinion) so why is salman getting all the love?💔

What about Jai and Mayuresh? What about Mangesh and Siddhesh?
How about ALisha and the other girls??

can we please NOT vote on looks and vote on Dance???Please??

This thread is not meant to trash/bash him, I'm only curious!
and when he does well, I give him his prorps! (his due credit)
Edited by Tamedtempest - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.5k

Users

11

Frequent Posters

-chandni- thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
For me Jai n Siddesh are the best dancers
Dabulls23 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Mayuresh, Jai, Sidesh are equally good dancer as Salman...some may be even better or Versatile in GRP or Solo performances. ....Mangesh is good but last couple times not as good...Prince is my least fav dancer of the show....I know he has many young fans here...
Now I never like to compare Gals to Guys....Plus I always support talent and not the other factors...It has to be overall good performer...Complete package...
In Gals I loved Mandakini the most..But she ain't here..😒
I am not sure who is the most versatile and best dancer so far...Consistantly like some of the boys have proven themselves...
Alisha initially was doing really really well...but last couple performances I am not so thrilled with her or Vrushali....Sunita is average with all performances nothing with WOW or Awww factor...
Khushboo has done well recent few episodes and Bhavna with last one....Rakhi is just really bad so nothing to write home about...
So lets see who does better this wknd episodes....
I wanted to respond to your post b/c it is a genuine question from you and deserves views from others....
Tamedtempest thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Mayuresh, Jai, Sidesh are equally good dancer as Salman...some may be even better or Versatile in GRP or Solo performances. ....Mangesh is good but last couple times not as good...Prince is my least fav dancer of the show....I know he has many young fans here...

Now I never like to compare Gals to Guys....Plus I always support talent and not the other factors...It has to be overall good performer...Complete package...
In Gals I loved Mandakini the most..But she ain't here..😒
I am not sure who is the most versatile and best dancer so far...Consistantly like some of the boys have proven themselves...
Alisha initially was doing really really well...but last couple performances I am not so thrilled with her or Vrushali....Sunita is average with all performances nothing with WOW or Awww factor...
Khushboo has done well recent few episodes and Bhavna with last one....Rakhi is just really bad so nothing to write home about...
So lets see who does better this wknd episodes....
I wanted to respond to your post b/c it is a genuine question from you and deserves views from others....

awww that's so nice of you! Thank you for the response, i appreciate it!

See for Salman...I just can not see him as being as versatile as Jai and Siddhesh. For me, he still has to prove himself. So far we have seen only one solo act on Salman's part and it was the fire dance. I appluad his bravery and courage but I feel it is not fair to compare him to Jai and Siddhesh. Both have proven themselves time and time again.
Jai and Siddhesh both have worked with many dance forms (siddhesh with saroj khan on Nachle Ve and Jai runs his own dance institute and has won Boogie Woogie). I know Salman competes in intermedeiate salsa but I feel no matter what dance he does, the Salsa translates through and shows. I feel at times he can not seperate himsel from it. WIth him my biggest concern is he may be like tanvi: Amazingly mind blowing with a partner but sub par on his own.

It's no flaw on his part nor is it an insult, some dancers do better in duets.

and Mayuresh! wow he has gotten my attention and kept it! The 'Dil Se' performance was AMAZING.
I am excited to see the next performance but I hope he does not get caught up with acrobatics (he is Damn good at that!). But I'm not too worried about him getting caught up in just stunts, Terrence sir is much smarter than that 😃


I actually believe Mangesh is very versatile. I think at this point he's a bit underrated. Emotional drama vama aside (I think Remo is going to sink Mangesh with the emotional bs, the janta is gonna get sick of it)
I remember his audtion, I cannot remember the song but he was a homeless (crazy?) guy with a stuffed animal for a friend. yaaaaar it was AMAZING. I was so in awe

Then his Sri Ram perforamcne was very good, the Maa performance was good. Also the perofmance where he was the villian!

All the guys are great (I will withold my opinion on Prince)

Now on to girls:

I think Mandakani is the only girl that could have competed with the guys in terms of calibere, versatility, strength and expereince. actually, she may be better than the boys in some areas. I wish she had stayed

I was rooting for Alsiha for a while, not sure I feel now

The rest: I will comment later. I have to go to work now 😳


Edited by Tamedtempest - 16 years ago
zaraa10 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
hey ppl... salman is one of d best dancer in DID... leme tell u one plus point ... he s d oly contestant whom d judges hv not pointed out any mistake so far.... salman rocks...
holymary thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6
If you had been a longtime member of India Forums it should not come as a surprise to you why Salman wins every poll in this forum. It is almost a given - so you will just have to ignore it. Dancing wise, I am sure all the rest of the boys are better than him - and he looks a bit older too. Performance wise, Mayuresh's performance on 28th is the best so far - it was so awesome my jaw dropped to the floor. If I am asked to make a judgement based on performances so far, Mayuresh is the clear winner to me.
Edited by holymary - 16 years ago
uknaik99 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

Mayuresh, Jai, Sidesh are equally good dancer as Salman...some may be even better or Versatile in GRP or Solo performances. ....Mangesh is good but last couple times not as good...Prince is my least fav dancer of the show....I know he has many young fans here...

Now I never like to compare Gals to Guys....Plus I always support talent and not the other factors...It has to be overall good performer...Complete package...
In Gals I loved Mandakini the most..But she ain't here..😒
I am not sure who is the most versatile and best dancer so far...Consistantly like some of the boys have proven themselves...
Alisha initially was doing really really well...but last couple performances I am not so thrilled with her or Vrushali....Sunita is average with all performances nothing with WOW or Awww factor...
Khushboo has done well recent few episodes and Bhavna with last one....Rakhi is just really bad so nothing to write home about...
So lets see who does better this wknd episodes....
I wanted to respond to your post b/c it is a genuine question from you and deserves views from others....



I agree with Varsha didi here.. All of them are very good.. these 3 mentors did good job while choosing the final 18.. except Rakhee everyone deserve to be here...

Salman is good and other boys are equally good no doubt.. But I have soft corner for Salman because he is from my state Karnataka.. and for Prince because he resembles my nephew back home... 😊

Just 11 weeks of DID left till we get winner.. 😭😭.. will miss it...
ShellyB thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: holymary

If you had been a longtime member of India Forums it should not come as a surprise to you why Salman wins every poll in this forum. It is almost a given - so you will just have to ignore it. Dancing wise, I am sure all the rest of the boys are better than him - and he looks a bit older too. Performance wise, Mayuresh's performance on 28th is the best so far - it was so awesome my jaw dropped to the floor. If I am asked to make a judgement based on performances so far, Mayuresh is the clear winner to me.

he is actually only 23 turning 24 in June (1 month older than me😆), i read on DID.sify.com dat siddhesh is 25/26 so he's da eldest, mayuresh 24 i think, jai 22/23
anyways about salman for me he's got da whole package, da talent, the looks n personality, sumfing about him just stood out n it wasnt just his gud luks, for me he's got da x-factor!! ⭐️
i mean i hadnt really noticed jai until his "behka behka" performance which was gr8, prince till his "tip tip", mayuresh till his "dil se", mangesh till his "maa" perofrmance, siddhesh has yet to impress me with an outstanding performance which really makes me notice him and his performance to stand out, no offense to sidhesh fans he's a gud dancer n i'm sure u can name a few performances dat u'v luvd of his, but nufin so far has made him stand out 4rm da crowd atleast for me
crazyfan thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
i like all the guys lol😆 but seriously all the guys, salman, siddesh, mayuresh, mangesh, prince; they are all soooooooooooo damn good! weneve i watch their performances, i am like OMYGAWDDDD, they are justt tooooo good, i luvvvv all of them, their looks, their dances n all!
but i think out of all of them, salman's plus point is his personality. he has a terrific personality which atleast i can see so clearly on screen, even when salman khan came on the show and everyone was going ecstatic over him(including this salman), but when he went upto to meet SK, he wasnt jumping out of joy or falling at his feet or wateve, he walked up to him very graciously and told him that he is a big fan and shook hands, thats wat i realllllly like about him; his personality!!!
desicrowd thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ShellyB

he is actually only 23 turning 24 in June (1 month older than me😆), i read on DID.sify.com dat siddhesh is 25/26 so he's da eldest, mayuresh 24 i think, jai 22/23
anyways about salman for me he's got da whole package, da talent, the looks n personality, sumfing about him just stood out n it wasnt just his gud luks, for me he's got da x-factor!! ⭐️
i mean i hadnt really noticed jai until his "behka behka" performance which was gr8, prince till his "tip tip", mayuresh till his "dil se", mangesh till his "maa" perofrmance, siddhesh has yet to impress me with an outstanding performance which really makes me notice him and his performance to stand out, no offense to sidhesh fans he's a gud dancer n i'm sure u can name a few performances dat u'v luvd of his, but nufin so far has made him stand out 4rm da crowd atleast for me




Well I think Jai, Mayuresh, Mangesh and Siddhesh have proved their talent way before Salman. I infact took notice of Salman only during the ja re hat natkhat and azeem o shaan shahensha performances whiich was quite recent an in the latter Mangesh I felt outpeformed Salman. To tell the truth Salman is good but he still has a lot to prove in dancing in comparison to the others mentioned. Baaki saare ghute hue dancers lagte hai, Salman seems a good Salsa dancer who has the capability but needs some more time to get there.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".