Analysis - 23rd Sept Episode

Page

Misty

@-funnfrolic-

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

The realities of this show are many and darnm by seeing this video, here i go drooling away and put myself in the same position as I was when I saw the scene!! few months ago...

crying prem - no ways, upset prem - yeah may be, hurt prem - definately...but before that loved the back ground score in te scene and how beautifullly it blended with the emotions of the scene... Appealing and Impactful... prem is standing by the wibndow upsert and hurt...caught in the emotions, caught in a predicament... on one hand is the family, and on the other is his siuster who he dearly loves. The very guy who his father hates, how can that girl, be the guy, his sister loves, and Heer , how and why did she hide this from him. These and many other emotions are running in his mind. Unable to express his pain, his sorrow, he is left wondering...he blames himself. he blames himself ashe thinks he gave his sister everything and yet she didnt have the confidence to walk up to him. He blames himself as he thinks heer, his life, some onew whom he thought he understood, he couldnt see her helplessness as he was binded by his own thought, his love for his sister... he blames himself as he thinks he couldnt instill that confidence in heer, in walking up to him and telling him. he wonders what he has done wrong... as these emotions are running in mind, heer comes in. She knows what prem must be feeling. and she knows that prem is feeling helpless right now. She knows she ought to leave prem alone but she cant. ...

She walks up to prem slowly, the doves in the tree signify the strength of their love and the moon the purity.

She puts her hand on top of his, to re affirm him that she is there for him, but he takes his hand away as he feels he cant look at her as he thinks he didnt believe in her. So he is hurt and upset and in a denial. He is a denial as he is yet not able to figure out the reason as to why he didnt believe him, or believed heer and chose to ignore her when he himself knew deep down in his conscious mind that she was right.

Heer : Mujhse Naraaz Ho.

Prem : Haan Naaraz Hoon.Lekin tumse nahin. Apne aap se.

Heer Kyun Prem

Prem : Sorry Heer. Maine tumpe vishwaas nahin kiya. main hi samajh nahin paaya.

(the baxkground scores moves to the a more subte score of the title track signifying the bond)

Heer : Mujhe maaf kar do prem. Galti meri Hai.

Here, prem cant believe that heer is saying sorry to him, when he thinks its all his fault. he cant help but respect her at that.

Heer : Us din, jab maine rishabh ko veera ke saath dekha, mujhe tab hi sab kuch bata dena chahiye...

Notice how prem expression change from disbelief to shock

Heer continues - lekin mere paas koi saboot nahin tha...is liye maina socha ki...

prem (the expression change to anger as he is fully convinced that its his fault. He is not angry that heer hid this fact from him, but he is angry that he couldnt give heer the confidence in walking up to him) maine bhi socha heer , pata hai kya (the background score changes to one that has high impact, signifying intensity in emotion)..main is baat main gussa nahin hoon ki tiumne mujhe puree baat nahin batayee, mujhe is baat ka zyada dukh hai ki tumhe vishwwas nahin tha ki main tumhare baat manoonga, samjhoonga.

Tumhe is baat ka darr tha, ki main apne behen ke samne, humare is rishte ko ahmiyat nahin doonga. yahin darr tha na heer. Woh rishta hi kya jo darr se dar jaye,

Looking back, these lines actually define prem. Prem hasnt been the kinds to get hiloed by fears. He has been quite strong that way. For him, belief, trust and understanding ,mattered and naturally so, as for him, thats what guided him, thats were based on his foundation.

Prem continues... haar chuka hoon main bahut. tumhe lagta hai ki main sierf apnee behen ki baat manooga and he sits down as if he is collapsing, in this so called revelation of his. Heer, Unable t see prem so torn, angry and upset runs to him and sits down as prem opens up to the only person he ever has... and lets him talk, talk out all his pain...

... mere saamne paida huee thee, usse zyada janta hoon usse, ussne kabhi mujhse koi baat nahin chupayee, har baat batatii thi mujhe, ma ne chilaya, mujhe bataya; mrha main marks kam aye bauji ne danta mujhe bataya, har kushi maun, mujhe pakad kar kush hote thi woh, har dukh main meri god main baith kar royee, phir aaj kya hua, ek ladka aaya uskee zindagi main, aur woh itna apna ho gaya, hum sab paraye ho gaye... heer put her hand on him, she does not know what to tell him as she knows that somewhere she should have been honest with prem - something that prem thinks too as he says tumne bhi wohi kiya heer, jo veera ne kya.

Angry with him self he gets up to go, but heer holds him on, the moon giving her the strength and the direction as she gets up and turns to face prem, still holding on to his hand

Prem : Heer mere liye, mere parivar se badkar aur kuch nahin hai, (which actually means the happiness of the parents as for prem, his parents are in the pedastal as god). Main chahta hoon, ki hum is parivar ka hissa ban kar rahe (which actually means pillar and solidarity of the family) na ki ek ajnabee (like harman and veera) abd he holds her (because he loves doing that), looks at her in his eyes (because by looking at her eyes, he falls in love with her again) and says aaj ke baaat mujhe kabhi koi baat mat chupana, kuch bhiu nahin,. Badee upsos ki baat hai heer, apne pyar ko bachane ke liye (so that i dont get hurt) , tumne meri parivar ko nahin bachaya (it ended up caushing hurt and grief to those who matter alot to me - my mom and dad..it ended up paining them). Apne pyar main dard na aa jaye (so that i dont get hurt), tumne mere parivar ko dau pe laga diya (you didnt think of my parents, you let a point comr where a stranger could come and may be spoil our lives). Saccha pyar woh hota hai, jo vishwaas pe tikka hota hai, phir chahe kitnee bhi badee sachaair samne aa jaye, woh vishwaas nahin toota.. (the doves signifying their undying love and reaffiring this pleadge, the moon depicting the honesty and sincerity of each word spokemn and unspoken being saud) Nahin toota woh vishwaas, kabhi nahin toota.... and prem looks away, heer takes her hand forward (title song plays - positive impact !!) and she takes his hand and lowers her eyes and touches her eyes with his hand as if promising to always he truthful to him and she says mujhe maaph kar do prem, galtee meri hai, mujhe tumse kuch nahiin chupana tha and prem cant help but be moved by her innocence...

wah kya love story hai... dono ek doosre ko sorry keh rahe hai...😆😆😆 and how cute both are saying galti meri hain...😆😆😆 and dono ne ek doosre ke haath pakade hue hain...😆 galtee meri hain, maine tumpe vishwaas nahin kiya aur main bhi ainda aisa nahin karoongee and they embrace in a hug with the moon and the doves looking on, witness to their undying love and faith for each other

Would love to hear your views on the said part of the episode

Quote

Frequent Posters

Svetalana Singh

@-svetalana-

Rocker

+ 4

Posted: 16 years ago

wow...what a analysis.Too good.I really miss their chemistry and seroiusness of the show.The episode had made me felt that this life and this is the way the couple should resolve their life's biggest problems.Sacha Pyar hamesha strength deta hai.

GOOD ONE.Hope Harshad is back as no one can protray such sincerity in love for life , parents, relatives...He is just rocking actor who has all potential to turn a simple scene on fire.

MISS YOU PREM

MISS YOU HARSHAD

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

DGill28

@DGill28

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Awwww....I totally missed your analysis's!!!! This analysis totally blew my mind away and I actually had to go back and watch that part again! Everything you said was so true!!! -Deepika

Quote

-Bee-

@-Bee-

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

Beautiful. Just beautiful.

You put into words why I fell in love with this pair. This scene just proved how DIFFERENT they were from the run-of-the-mill lovers, who do not trust, and break up in a second. In fact, they reminded me of people far beyond their age, trying to hold their family together (like Om and Parvati, or Mihir and Tulsi). The only difference was they're so young. Yet, they know they are meant to be.

Watching scenes like this at this point, when Prem is not there, makes me feel scared. I do not want Prem to come back in a stupid storyline, which ruins the purety of all previous scenes. That is why I don't want a humshakal track. Because, the character - Prem- has lived all these moments, and it'll somehow ruin them if he's no longer there. On the other hand, I certainly do not want Heer marrying someone else, because the innocence and purety of Premeers relationship is ruined. I watched KYPH and Kasturi before, and I always felt that the innocence and love they had in the initial days was never replicated after their whole multiple marriages, revenge against each other tracks. Even the TRPs dropped after these multiple marriages, lol.

Prem-Heer are one. And the HAVE to remain so. *sigh*.

Quote

Misty

@-funnfrolic-

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Deepika G.
Awwww....I totally missed your analysis's!!!! This analysis totally blew my mind away and I actually had to go back and watch that part again! Everything you said was so true!!! -Deepika

Hey Deepika thanks...love your writing skills and would like to know what you felt about the scene

Quote

zaara006

@zaara006

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

very nice analysis!!!!!!👏Whatever you said was soooooo true throughout the scene, it had a mixture of emotions, Harshad truely at one of his best moments as an actor dispalying sooo many emotions in one scene, mindblowing!!!!! 👍🏼

I too felt when watching this episode, that Prem and Heers love will survive anything that comes at them and they will always stay together, but as usual, in the true balaji style we got dissapointed!!!!!! What a SHAME!!!! 😡 Harshad could have taken the character forward, but was not even given the oppertunity, still the loss is theirs. This could be seen clearly in the TRP's, they are going down. So if the creatives know what is good for them they should bring him back, before its too late!

Quote

Misty

@-funnfrolic-

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: zaara006

very nice analysis!!!!!!👏

Thanks.... I dont think I have met you on the forums before... My Apologies..hardly come here!!

Whatever you said was soooooo true throughout the scene, it had a mixture of emotions, Harshad truely at one of his best moments as an actor dispalying sooo many emotions in one scene, mindblowing!!!!! 👍🏼

Yep Both, Harshad & Additi were brilliant in the scene, I loved the way how both prem - heer complimented each other. How their minds were at the same wavelength, how they could relate to what they were feeling..how each emotion was depicted so beautifully

I too felt when watching this episode, that Prem and Heers love will survive anything that comes at them and they will always stay together, but as usual, in the true balaji style we got dissapointed!!!!!!

Well not really... it remains to be seen how they will get back together. the problem is that i think they tend to rely on things that have worked rather than taking a risk to see something new. Kis desh was/is so different from other shows... If they think as to what made kis desh tick, they will not need to rely on these tried and tested formulas. Hopefully the break would have given everybody the much need time to recharge theirt batteries

What a SHAME!!!! 😡 Harshad could have taken the character forward, but was not even given the oppertunity, still the loss is theirs.

Something work and somethings dont. This time it didnt...because people are fed up of seeing the same thing time and time again.

This could be seen clearly in the TRP's, they are going down. So if the creatives know what is good for them they should bring him back, before its too late!