''We're not even 5 percent of Potter sales' articl

344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

'Twilight': Will the Movie Be a Hit?

Will fans find the film true to the novel? Will even one male go see it? Will the filmmakers get the go-ahead to make ''New Moon''? What does Stephenie Meyer think about all this? Some answers to these burning questions

  • ent_weekly:https://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,20238689,00.html Buzz up!
  • addthis_pub = 'ewcom'; //addthis_options = 'myspace, yahoobkm, newsvine, reddit, technorati, more'; //addthis_options = 'myspace, yahoobkm, newsvine, reddit, mixx, more'; addthis_options = 'myspace, fark, newsvine, reddit, mixx, more'; addthis_offset_top = -20; addthis_offset_left = +10; addthis_hide_embed = false;
< ="https://s7.add.com/custom/ew/js/add_widget_new.js" =text/>
rob-cover-twi_dl
TWILIGHT Early tracking suggests that tween boys like the Cullen vampires (Robert Pattinson, pictured on one of three EW Twilight collector's covers) almost as much as girls do
if ( ew_queryVariableExists( 'commentsPage' ) == 0) { commentsPage = 1 } if ( ew_queryVariableExists( 'print' ) == 0 && (commentsPage == 1 || (commentsPage > 1 && 1 == 0) )){ tiiQuigoWriteAd(760767, 1291707, 320, 180, -1); } else { // alert( 'Skipping Ad = 320, 180' ); } < id=qas_frm name=qas_frm ="" method=get target="">< = name=ie52_mac_only>< id=adsonar_serve406068 name=adsonar_serve406068 marginWidth=0 marginHeight=0 ="https://ads.tw.adsonar.com/adserving/getAds.jsp?previousPlacementIds=&placementId=1291707&pid=760767&ps=-1&zw=320&zh=180&=http%3A//www.ew.com/ew/article/0%2C%2C20238689%2C00.&v=5&dct=%27Twilight%27%3A%20Will%20it%20be%20a%20-es%20%7C%20Entertainment%20Weekly&ref=http%3A//www.wizardnews.com/" Border=0 width=320 scrolling=no height=180>
By Nicole Sperling
Nicole%20Sperling
Nicole Sperling

The last thing the filmmakers behind Twilight want to hear is that their movie is the next Harry Potter. Sure, it occupies the release date once held by the boy wizard. But while the seven-book Potter series has sold 400 million copies and generated $4.5 billion in worldwide box office receipts, Twilight is working off a global fan base that has purchased only 17 million books. ''We're not even 5 percent of Potter sales. We're not even a toenail on that body,'' says director Catherine Hardwicke. ''Ours is a character film, a little more sophisticated teenage Romeo and Juliet.''

But Twilight is likely to be anything but a tragedy for Summit Entertainment, the fledgling studio behind the film. So far in the company's 18-month history, it has released five movies, with nothing grossing over $25 million; some, such as Sex Drive, have been outright failures. Twilight — a possible four-film franchise — could transform Summit into a real player. To hit it big, though, the vampire romance needs to lure moviegoers beyond the series' core fans. Teenage boys are an obvious target, and Hardwicke has peppered her film with gravity-defying fight scenes. ''There are action sequences in the book, and as a director, you want to make everything more cinematic,'' she says.

Early tracking of the movie suggests that tween boys like the Cullen vampires almost as much as girls do. That should help Twilight reach at least a $20 million opening weekend — the number the studio probably needs to please in-house accountants. What it requires to greenlight the sequel, New Moon, is another story. Summit won't comment, but Hardwicke guesstimates Twilight must gross $150 million for the studio to approve a follow-up, which will require extensive special effects and location shooting. ''This has to be a crazy hit,'' she says. ''Nobody can say that it can do that well right now.''

Except, maybe, Stephenie Meyer. The author loves the movie, though she had her disagreements with Hardwicke. ''I mostly stepped in on the script level,'' she says. ''You know the line 'So the lion fell in love with the lamb'? It's a bit of a cheesy line, I have to say. They had changed the wording on that, to downplay it a little. And I said, 'I really like how you've changed this, but this line is tattooed on people's ankles. I think you're going to have a problem if you don't do it exactly right.' And they listened to me — and saved themselves the outrage of the people who know these books.''

After seeing the first cut, the author's only real concern was that Edward and Bella's steamy kissing scene was too hot for the beginning of a relationship. ''You're not going to have anything to work with as the series continues,'' Meyer told Hardwicke, who cut the sexy wide shots in exchange for more chaste close-ups. ''In a weird way I think it's better,'' says Hardwicke. ''It's less like other movies.''

Even if they're nervous about admitting it publicly, Summit thinks they've got a hit on their hands. They've already got Twilight screenwriter Melissa Rosenberg at work on the sequel. Expect to see a New Moon rising.

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.2k

Users

8

Likes

2

Frequent Posters

TINK thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
Thanx for sharing!

Twilight will never be no where near Harry Potter, interms of the franchise, books & the fans!!

Sam x
Edited by TINK - 17 years ago
224529 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3
Thanks for the article!
I dunno why people compare Twilight and HP. They are not at all similar in anyway.
~Triv
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Power20

Thanks for the article!

I dunno why people compare Twilight and HP. They are not at all similar in anyway.
~Triv

If by "people" you mean me, then no I wasn't comparing them. Was just posting what I got from a site. But if u weren't, then I apologize.😛
Shital17 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: Power20

Thanks for the article!

I dunno why people compare Twilight and HP. They are not at all similar in anyway.
~Triv

I agree! to me, both harry potter and twilight are number 1! 😊
diyafah thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#6

well u can't compare both of dem actually but YES..twilight is no way near HP even though..I am waiting for the movie!

But i guess HP's summer release is amazing😃
cool_rashi thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
Same here..
i dont understand why ppl compare these two books...they are both completely different stories....
i never watch Harry potter..but i think it is boring...
but i realli like twilight and going to wtach it torrw in threatres...
PLus, harry potter is popular porbably it has more than 7 books i think....and twilight just came out...
and i think it is a good start....
everyone talks about twilight 24/7..in skools, on radios, tv news, interent, like verywhere....
I think twilight is gonna be popluted than HP..
My htoughts, but yu never knoe
inkinscription thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Engager Level 3 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
they are both completely different genres...if u say so...i mean they are totally opposite...and are brilliant in their own ways.....
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: cool_rashi

Same here..

i dont understand why ppl compare these two books...they are both completely different stories....
i never watch Harry potter..but i think it is boring...
but i realli like twilight and going to wtach it torrw in threatres...
PLus, harry potter is popular porbably it has more than 7 books i think....and twilight just came out...
and i think it is a good start....
everyone talks about twilight 24/7..in skools, on radios, tv news, interent, like verywhere....
I think twilight is gonna be popluted than HP..
My htoughts, but yu never knoe

LOLLLLLZ😆
Incase u didn't know, comparing books is very well allowed in this section. I saw an article saying that stated that Twilight isn't even 5% of HP and I send it.😉 That's all. I don't know why people are getting so much hyped up.
BTW incase u didn't kinow this as well .......... people also talk about HP 24/7......not only in schools and colleges but everywhere. Both financially,. and as a litarature HP is way off successful than twillight.
344471 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: cool_rashi

PLus, harry potter is popular porbably it has more than 7 books i think....and twilight just came out...
and i think it is a good start....

If it doesn't get popular now, then it will never ever get popular. That's it. HP became a history on day one. When it was released people all over the world were mad abt it..................................... Twillight and HP both series are over now.
And its not an excuse that HP is more popular because it has 7 books. HP was much more popular than twillight even when only the 1st series came out.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".