Mannat Har Khushi Paane Ki: Episode Discussion Thread - 42- Page 145

Originally posted by: Ammu99

I agree 👍🏻, it wasn't entirely Mannat's truth to tell Vikrant last time. But going back to the terrace confrontation, she accepted her mistake of not telling the truth about Visakha to Vikrant at the right time. Committing the same mistake by hiding DK's truth from Dua (and everyone else, which isn't clear yet) is highly unlikely and dangerous. As per the convenience of the plot, the writers make the leads dumb and foolish enough to say and believe anything.

Both Vikrant and Mannat accepted each other's point of view as to what lead to what & how their actions were justified before 7 yrs leap. So that ends there itself.

Right now they both are being dumbed down unnecessarily probably to end ManVik.

At the end DK will win again proving that Mannat makers were never interested from Day 1 to give the Leads any edge over others...

And thats the saddest part bcz we as viewers never got to see any peace in their lives not even for seconds.

Gen Leap news is everywhere now, with some channels reporting that Adsha may be leaving by choice because they don't want to continue with the age leap storyline. What's frustrating is how Mukta continues to give the villains the upper hand while ruining both leads. It feels like the focus is more on continuing the criminal drama than giving Manvik a meaningful storyline.

Dua is constant with her endless baba jaap, and now DK will manipulate her against Manvik. The audience has already struggled to connect with Dua's character, so how makers are expecting audience to stay connected with her for next gen story??? after 1 year leap, she was distant from DK, but the moment Vik entered SM, dua was back to the same baba jaap. Her character has become inconsistent and feels completely out of sync. She's more loyal to dk than her own parents, forget Vik not even Mannat come close to where dk is for dua...what a pathetic writing where child is putting her foster father above a biological mother, who was always giving and out there for a child...

Also, Manvik has been brutally destroyed by the writing team. What's the point of creating hig end sequences and dramatic confrontations when the villains always escape and remain one step ahead? The show has lost its charm, and while Manvik kept many viewers hooked, even that connection is now fading because the storyline has become too repetitive and crime centric. This is probably the only show where we barely get a happy moment for more than a day before another criminal track begins and the villains start winning again after dk-vish entry. Now Mannat is being used as the scapegoat for the next setup, hiding a secret from dua, glorifying a criminal through fake stories, and making Vik agree because of her. None of this feels like Mannat, and it doesn't resonate with the her character. Few days back she was desperately looking for opportunities to punish him and now his memorial service, writers👎👎 Victim and survivor of his attacks has to be silent and not react, his child is worshipping someone who attacked him so many times, killed his mother and almost murdered him too but he can't tell her the truth...Kya fuk k likhte hain yeh log😡...it feels like the writers are deliberately butchering Manvik just to make DK look powerful. At this point, I don't see happy ending for them.

Dk character spoiled Mannat series, his too much positivity and now negativity both weren't balanced properly by the Mannat team.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Gen Leap news is everywhere now, with some channels reporting that Adsha may be leaving by choice because they don't want to continue with the age leap storyline. What's frustrating is how Mukta continues to give the villains the upper hand while ruining both leads. It feels like the focus is more on continuing the criminal drama than giving Manvik a meaningful storyline.

Dua is constant with her endless baba jaap, and now DK will manipulate her against Manvik. The audience has already struggled to connect with Dua's character, so how makers are expecting audience to stay connected with her for next gen story??? after 1 year leap, she was distant from DK, but the moment Vik entered SM, dua was back to the same baba jaap. Her character has become inconsistent and feels completely out of sync. She's more loyal to dk than her own parents, forget Vik not even Mannat come close to where dk is for dua...what a pathetic writing where child is putting her foster father above a biological mother, who was always giving and out there for a child...

Also, Manvik has been brutally destroyed by the writing team. What's the point of creating hig end sequences and dramatic confrontations when the villains always escape and remain one step ahead? The show has lost its charm, and while Manvik kept many viewers hooked, even that connection is now fading because the storyline has become too repetitive and crime centric. This is probably the only show where we barely get a happy moment for more than a day before another criminal track begins and the villains start winning again after dk-vish entry. Now Mannat is being used as the scapegoat for the next setup, hiding a secret from dua, glorifying a criminal through fake stories, and making Vik agree because of her. None of this feels like Mannat, and it doesn't resonate with the her character. Few days back she was desperately looking for opportunities to punish him and now his memorial service, writers👎👎 Victim and survivor of his attacks has to be silent and not react, his child is worshipping someone who attacked him so many times, killed his mother and almost murdered him too but he can't tell her the truth...Kya fuk k likhte hain yeh log😡...it feels like the writers are deliberately butchering Manvik just to make DK look powerful. At this point, I don't see happy ending for them.

Dk character spoiled Mannat series, his too much positivity and now negativity both weren't balanced properly by the Mannat team.

When was Mukta or makers even interested ?

Makers approached Ayesha last time for Dua's role & for Gen leap which didn't not happen & lead to intro of the stupid Punjab track.

Finally Makers are doing things now as per their wish.

Since Aramabhi started Mannat show got heavily neglected. Kahin pe kuch bhi kardo.

Not even a single day of happiness in ManVik's life as if they were born to just get killed or drugged.

Now ManVik both are being shown like idiots underestimating their respective enemies just so that they get killed...

I dont even understand the relevance of the show's Title anymore...its a joke...there was never any Khushi....

Before 1st leap they butchered Vik core traits and now it's Mannat turn...like she seriously compared dk with Shruti... so disappointing to see this kind of pathetic writing. Comparing murderer with Shruti and setting a narrative of his bravery was so put off on Mannat's part that she didn't even saw Vik pain. What good memories for a child when a foundation is based on a lies...Mannat was completely wrong today and makers ensure just like Sai ended in Ghum Mannat core arcs will end too with her exit....

It's all gen leap setup nothing else to make exit for Adsha and take story forward of gen x crime patrol... 👎👎👎 nothing make sense today on whatever Mannat said...., it's not how justice happened but Mukta world what is justice as Villains are the heroes and runners of the story.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Before 1st leap they butchered Vik core traits and now it's Mannat turn...like she seriously compared dk with Shruti... so disappointing to see this kind of pathetic writing. Comparing murderer with Shruti and setting a narrative of his bravery was so put off on Mannat's part that she didn't even saw Vik pain. What good memories for a child when a foundation is based on a lies...Mannat was completely wrong today and makers ensure just like Sai ended in Ghum Mannat core arcs will end too with her exit....

It's all gen leap setup nothing else to make exit for Adsha and take story forward of gen x crime patrol... 👎👎👎 nothing make sense today on whatever Mannat said...., it's not how justice happened but Mukta world what is justice as Villains are the heroes and runners of the story.

Pathetic comparison honestly. 1st Vik justified pre-leap Malla comparing with Mannat's love & now..

Mannat doing the exact same thing 😔

Just destroyed everything....

The ending will be so painful to watch if ManVik exit indeed true...

In the entire show from day 1 till today only Malla's character has been advantageous.

She was good, then became bad, then became worst of all still she stayed throughout in SM.

Again she is back to being all nice 🙄..

Even DK didn't get that advantage bcz his character was finally butchered to a point which was really not needed. Manit wasn't exactly happy about it too.

But Malla ko dekho...🙄😬

The moment DK entered, the show was no longer about ManVik, it has been turned to sob stories about DK and how he is the biggest victim.

And they are really crazy to show Mannat hasn't learnt anything from her previous mistakes and what calamity it caused. They are showing her lie again to Dua so blatantly without hesitation and literally calling DK a Martyr

Originally posted by: Ammu99

Mannat made the same blunder again, showing she has not learned any lesson from her grave mistakes. She is forcibly making Vikrant listen to her and taking one-sided decisions again. They will have to pay a heavy price for this blunder. She doesn't want to do justice to Neetu, Yashika, or Vikrant. By not revealing DK's murders to the world, she is keeping her daughter in the illusion that her baba is a saint rather than a murderer. She is letting her live in a false world instead of facing the truth, which is sheer cowardice.

Agree with this 💯, and with Daman's post 👍🏻. She hasn't learned anything from her past. She is making Vikrant a part of her lies and ignoring his pain over not doing justice to his mother.

Originally posted by: Daman17

Gen Leap news is everywhere now, with some channels reporting that Adsha may be leaving by choice because they don't want to continue with the age leap storyline. What's frustrating is how Mukta continues to give the villains the upper hand while ruining both leads. It feels like the focus is more on continuing the criminal drama than giving Manvik a meaningful storyline.

Dua is constant with her endless baba jaap, and now DK will manipulate her against Manvik. The audience has already struggled to connect with Dua's character, so how makers are expecting audience to stay connected with her for next gen story??? after 1 year leap, she was distant from DK, but the moment Vik entered SM, dua was back to the same baba jaap. Her character has become inconsistent and feels completely out of sync. She's more loyal to dk than her own parents, forget Vik not even Mannat come close to where dk is for dua...what a pathetic writing where child is putting her foster father above a biological mother, who was always giving and out there for a child...

Also, Manvik has been brutally destroyed by the writing team. What's the point of creating hig end sequences and dramatic confrontations when the villains always escape and remain one step ahead? The show has lost its charm, and while Manvik kept many viewers hooked, even that connection is now fading because the storyline has become too repetitive and crime centric. This is probably the only show where we barely get a happy moment for more than a day before another criminal track begins and the villains start winning again after dk-vish entry. Now Mannat is being used as the scapegoat for the next setup, hiding a secret from dua, glorifying a criminal through fake stories, and making Vik agree because of her. None of this feels like Mannat, and it doesn't resonate with the her character. Few days back she was desperately looking for opportunities to punish him and now his memorial service, writers👎👎 Victim and survivor of his attacks has to be silent and not react, his child is worshipping someone who attacked him so many times, killed his mother and almost murdered him too but he can't tell her the truth...Kya fuk k likhte hain yeh log😡...it feels like the writers are deliberately butchering Manvik just to make DK look powerful. At this point, I don't see happy ending for them.

Dk character spoiled Mannat series, his too much positivity and now negativity both weren't balanced properly by the Mannat team.

It seems Mukta's plot is written by keeping negative leads at the center and then the leads are written around them, so that they will make the villians shine. First it was ars and then its dk. These people don't understand, letting one character, that too a criminal character, overstay kills the vibes. When they were showing ars as invincible, that time majority of people were begging them to make her exit the show and when they delayed, many walked away from the show. The same thing is happening right now with dk, he has overstayed and to make him stay, they are throwing Mannat, the show's female lead, under the bus. Just few episodes back, they made Mannat acknowledge that they shouldn't have hidden Vishakha's truth which caused misunderstanding between her and Vikrant and now they are letting her that same thing again. She herself has witnessed how delayed truth hurts and destroys over the time yet they are making her do that. What annoys the most is everyone knows Mannat is not like this, agreed she is not some moralistic, ideal character, she has her own set of rules but this one seems so out of her character. She was the one who desperately tried to expose him, she hated how he used Dua, she was at front to bring out his true face and now they are washing it off just because they want to give DK an upperhand and a grand re entry.

Despite the news everywhere, I am still hoping against hope they won't go for generation leap with such a pathetic plot by making female lead take such stupid decisions and making her the ultimate culprit whereas she herself is one of the victims. Already Dua isn't that likable character amongst the kids. No hate towards Trisha, she is a fantastic actress, but the root is how Dua's character is written, inconsistent. Her solid loyalty towards DK isn't favored by audience much and I don't think anyone will be interested to watch the story where lead's kid will be raised by a criminal and she will bring justice later. Mannat is definitely not an ideal show to bring a generation leap. The plot isn't strong plus the channel doesn't have reach as compared to star.

I will prefer either taking small time jump by keeping the same cast for some time or shutting the show with this generation only by making good win over evil atleast for once.

The worst part is that, in the name of protecting mental health, they are making a child believe in something that is neither ethically right nor based on the truth. The writing is just terrible😡

Mannat herself pointed out a few days ago how much hiding the truth from Vik cost her, and now she's doing the exact same thing with Dua. How does that make any sense?

They have completely butchered Manvik's core traits and values just to elevate DK and the other so called villains. It's honestly infuriating to watch😡 show class in drain for a long time and it's only dk on screen for almost a year. This show should be renamed to Dhairya ki kahani sunane ki🤓🤓