Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi-EDT #16 DT note p25 - Page 73

Originally posted by: The_Best

She went to coma in S1 and S2 haven’t denied that. We are following S1 from S1 until they say something else or show something else. So same with Nandini. She was in coma when Karan cheated and had a child with his mistress

OMG, so in S1 they showed that Mihir and Mandira got into a physical relationship after he had regained his memory and was fully aware of what's happening while thinking that Mandira was mentally unstable.

The makers in S2 have not denied it, they have just added that Mihir Mandira also had a relationship when he had amnesia

Yet you are believing that Mihir didn't have any physical relationship with Mandira after he regained his memory...

Just because makers have mentioned that Mihir Mandira had a relationship while Mihir had amnesia doesn't mean he didn't have a relation later. I hope you understand these two are mutually exclusive things..

So accept this that as per S2, Mihir got into a physical relation with Mandira more than once . One of them conceived her a child and the other one didn't, untill and unless makers clearly show that Mihir had no physical relation with Mandira after he regained memory, by your rationale, him having physical relation with Mandira after regaining memory holds

If you want to give Mihir a clean chit that's your assumption but makers never said that

Originally posted by: The_Best

Forget S2. You can’t even accept that Karan cheated in S1 and keep making excuses for him. I can’t have the same conversation over and over. Fine. Karan is an angel for you. I don’t know why you even want to argue or debate. You can’t expect others to have same opinion as you. Karan is a cheater as per what’s shown in S1. That’s what I am going by. I don’t have the energy to keep on debating and going over and over with this

Dont tag me and argue that I am making others have same opinion as of me...forum is to put across opinions...neither I have forced anyone to accept my opinion nor have enforced it on anyone...I am sharing my opinions and asking relevant question for which there is no answer...You said Karan is an angel for me...kind of can you enlighten me where I have mentioned he is an angel? ...you mentioned I cant accept Karan is a cheater..have you even come across my posts where I have bashed karan for being an emotional cheater? Dont claim something which is not true by calling me that and this...and if you really want to... then quote me with a post which contradicts to what I am denying...anyways lets end it here as this is turning ugly and I wouldn't like to involve in baseless arguments.

And obviously as per current timeline of S2, Karan married Tanya and Nandani before the age of 16, hence being the closest biological relative and de facto natural guardian around, Mihir is also a criminal for abetment of child marriage and child marriage bigamy...

Matlab S1 Mihir sirf cheater tha, S2 Mihir is cheater+criminal

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

OMG, so in S1 they showed that Mihir and Mandira got into a physical relationship after he had regained his memory and was fully aware of what's happening while thinking that Mandira was mentally unstable.

The makers in S2 have not denied it, they have just added that Mihir Mandira also had a relationship when he had amnesia

Yet you are believing that Mihir didn't have any physical relationship with Mandira after he regained his memory...

Just because makers have mentioned that Mihir Mandira had a relationship while Mihir had amnesia doesn't mean he didn't have a relation later. I hope you understand these two are mutually exclusive things..

So accept this that as per S2, Mihir got into a physical relation with Mandira more than once . One of them conceived her a child and the other one didn't, untill and unless makers clearly show that Mihir had no physical relation with Mandira after he regained memory, by your rationale, him having physical relation with Mandira after regaining memory holds

If you want to give Mihir a clean chit that's your assumption but makers never said that

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

And obviously as per current timeline of S2, Karan married Tanya and Nandani before the age of 16, hence being the closest biological relative and de facto natural guardian around, Mihir is also a criminal for abetment of child marriage and child marriage bigamy...

Matlab S1 Mihir sirf cheater tha, S2 Mihir is cheater+criminal

I rather go with this narrative until makers call it otherwise

Fine not tagging you. But you yourself said Karan didn’t cheat Nandini in S1 and at most what he did is just an emotional cheating when the fact is he had sex with Tanya multiple times. That’s not emotional cheating. That’s physical cheating as well. So if that’s not seeing Karan as an angel then I don’t know what it is

How convenient to make up things only to show Karan as angel. When did he marry Nandini at the age of 16? Making up anything to defend criminal bigamy practicing Karan 😭

All characters get criticized here, but only for poor Karan the rules should be different and we should make stories which are not even shown in the show just to defend him

Originally posted by: The_Best

The makers never said Mihir had a physical relationship with Mandira after memory loss this season. They said it happened during memory loss. So you now assuming he had a physical relationship without memory loss too is your opinion. Tomorrow if makers say he did, I will accept that. But they haven’t said that yet, so I am going based on what’s shown so far

Why do makers need to repeat?? They have clearly shown in S1 and everything in S1 holds true unless denied in S2

The makers never denied that Mihir had a physical relation with Mandira after he regained his memory. S1 clearly had shown they did have a physical relation after Mihir regained the memory

The makers have only said Karan was conceived during memory loss which means that they had a physical relation while memory loss, but it nowhere means they never had a physical relation after that.

If now makers say that Mihir never had any physical relation with Mandira after regaining memory then we will accept but till then we will go by what was shown in S1, that Mihir Mandira had physical relation after memory gain

Since you mentioned I cant agree..Let me agree with you...I will keep the "Why Karan consummated with Tanya" aside and according to law he cheated Nandini physically and emotionally in S1..I am accepting...since I have agreed can you highlight the facts of how in S2 Karan can father a 18-yr old kid at 36 with Tanya while being married to Nandini and cheated on her?

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Why do makers need to repeat?? They have clearly shown in S1 and everything in S1 holds true unless denied in S2

The makers never denied that Mihir had a physical relation with Mandira after he regained his memory. S1 clearly had shown they did have a physical relation after Mihir regained the memory

The makers have only said Karan was conceived during memory loss which means that they had a physical relation while memory loss, but it nowhere means they never had a physical relation after that.

If now makers say that Mihir never had any physical relation with Mandira after regaining memory then we will accept but till then we will go by what was shown in S1, that Mihir Mandira had physical relation after memory gain