Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi-EDT #16 DT note p25 - Page 58

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Shock value. Ekta probably didn’t find anyone who could play the part well enough.

God knows and Ekta knows.

I am sure even Akash can't play a 25 years old's role well

Yes it is for shock value but something that makes sorrowful

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

Even if we go by this theory it doesn't add up coz in S1 he marries Tanya just for sake of Bhumi. So if Bhumi is not in S2 how can we say he just married Tanya all of a sudden ?. In S1 he backed out from marriage multiple times and apparantly married just bcoz of bhumi and since S2 negates existence of bhumi it also negates Karan marrying tanya while Nandini is in coma. He was never a cheater - that was his character sketch in S1 and he never had EMA. His marriage was illegal in S1 - I agree but he never intended to cheat Nandini. He moved on with Tanya coz Tulsi asked him to and moreover doctors confirm she wud never wake up. Doctors had given up on her and he kept her on life support. I dont even mind Karan moving on with Tanya coz it was almost 3 yrs and I suppose ppl somewhat require a partner and he was seeking that partnership in Tanya. But calling his relationship with Tanya as cheating or EMA is something I dont agree with...Lawfully yes his marriage was Illegal but circumstances were way too different...his intensions were never wrong and with that I feel even in S2 his characteristics are retained and that is the sole reason I am sticking with theory of Tanya being Karan's first wife in S2

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Doesn’t matter to Ekta

Why is she so obsessed with Akash...

Originally posted by: Phir_Mohabbat

Tanya first wife hi hogi how else it can be explained samaira is in her teens and parth atlst 25 above

If they show thoda hi change hoga. The day ansh nandini married tanya karan married too. Parth born to them first. Late the rape thing and ansh's death. And either tanya dead or she left karan long back so it can be possible parth don't know tanya is his mother. After all drama KN married and had samaira. So in the place of bhoomi this guy would be there who was pronounced dead or something. That way we have to think he's parth dev ritiks age..how stupid actor wise

And this niyati lady two possibilities. This lady was the nurse during delivery. Karan either told her to take care of Riyansh or nurse found the baby. So maybe at first karan gave her money then this lady had mental issue so she thinks they are married and karan is playing along to look after Riyansh

So if this is true what's his plan for this son and nandini. Will he keep these two in dark? I think the sudden shock of ansh ka beta being alive will make nandini more hurt. Affair is one thing but this is mental insanity level

I am leaning towards Tanya is first wife theory too. And posted earlier about the theory that I have about Karan asking Niyati to raise the child here

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/post/167854976

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

Its weird that they brought Akashdeep back as the son, if he was used for a flashback scene.

I wonder if they would show him having some disease that aged him, something logical.

yes something like Amitabh Bachchan had in Pa..

Wahi dikha dein

Originally posted by: A_Star39

Wtf

Wtf

Wtf

Is a grown ass 45 year old playing a 26 year old

My mom was traumatised

Ekta are u crazy

Originally posted by: The_Best

His marriage with Tanya was illegal and Nandini was his wife. So regardless if he didn’t intend to cheat or felt like moving on by abandoning his sick wife who he claimed to love and sleep parayi aurat Tanya, it’s called cheating. That way then you can say replacement Mihir was also in guilt and gratitude for Mandira for saving his life and her faking mental illness, but he didn’t intend to cheat tulsi as he loved her and that was just one night moment. But you have two different rules for both. And since makers haven’t said Tanya was his first wife or his lover this season, so it’s still following S1 story which is Karan the cheater and Tanya the mistress story. But if you assume Karan may have married Tanya legally this season and he may not be a cheater this season, then it’s fine. That’s your assumption

how is Tanya the mistress this season when Parth is way older than Samaira?

Or is Parth is supposed to be a product of a live in relationship?

Either way most logical is Nandini was not in the picture as wife when Parth happened.

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

hopefully they do that...

Him playing Nandani's son would be a torture to watch..

NGL, watching him in flashbacks is traumatic enough; he was just so good at playing Ansh.

Originally posted by: The_Best

His marriage with Tanya was illegal and Nandini was his wife. So regardless if he didn’t intend to cheat or felt like moving on by abandoning his sick wife who he claimed to love and sleep parayi aurat Tanya, it’s called cheating. That way then you can say replacement Mihir was also in guilt and gratitude for Mandira for saving his life and her faking mental illness, but he didn’t intend to cheat tulsi as he loved her and that was just one night moment. But you have two different rules for both. And since makers haven’t said Tanya was his first wife or his lover this season, so it’s still following S1 story which is Karan the cheater and Tanya the mistress story. But if you assume Karan may have married Tanya legally this season and he may not be a cheater this season, then it’s fine. That’s your assumption

makers have never said that Tanya married (legally or illegally in this season) so you are wrong to believe that Karan and Tanya had that relation in this season which they had in season 1 due to a character that doesn't exist in this story'

You can't compare that to Gautam Damini because their story had nothing to do with Mayank. Whether or not Mayank existed, Damini and Gautam would have married.

Here Tanya and Karan had the fake marriage only because Bhoomi existed and Nandani was in coma. In this season Bhoomi doesn't exist, so there is literally no reason for that relationship..

If you still want to assume that Karan cheated Nandani in this season due to some other reason then you are fine to do that, but that will be your assumption not something that makers have shown

Originally posted by: EkPaheli

Per this season’s canon we have no idea about whether or not Tanya was a mistress or not. Per S1, their marriage was not legal in a manner of speaking but only Nandini could sue them but she doesn’t.

Gautam would never be so crass as to taunt Karan over this, particularly because he knows Tulsi may not like it and Parth is an innocent regardless of his equation with Karan.

Per this season’s canon they may show Tanya was Karan’s first wife legally and Parth is hers via that marriage, meaning Parth is a legitimate child. Tanya has either been divorced by Karan once her connection with Ansh was out and Karan got the custody of their son or she died giving birth to him.

Poor Hiten because he’s gonna be called Dad by someone who looks so much older than him though they’re close to the same age. Not to mention that Rio may probably be shown like Ranvijay from Animal which means Karan is his Balbir

I haven’t watched animal so don’t know. I think they shouldn’t have cast this Ansh actor for son’s role. He doesn’t look 26 years old from any angle. If they wanted to bring him back, they could’ve shown he was Ansh’s twin who survived someone or basically anything rather than introducing him as 26 years old son