Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi-EDT #16 DT note p25 - Page 56

Created

Last reply

Replies

663

Views

16.6k

Users

37

Likes

1.4k

Frequent Posters

The_Best thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

Tanya being with Karan after Karan Nandani marriage was not directly due to Ansh or him r**ing Nandani (although those were indirect reasons) . the main reason was Bhoomi. Had Bhoomi not existed in season 1, despite Nandani having been r**ed by Ansh, Karan had never thought of having any relation with Tanya.

So definitely here Karan had no reason to marry Tanya after having married Nandani.

Hence cheating part doesn't exist here

We haven’t been told he married Tanya this season. So bhoomi doesn’t matter. What we are told is that Parth is Tanya and Karan’s child and since they haven’t negated the S1 story about Karan Tanya being in illegal marriage, so it’s still following S1 just as it’s following S1 story for Gautam Damini despite the fact that their one child doesn’t exist this season and for others as well
Me_Harini thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: Phir_Mohabbat


Tulsi had asked tanya first if she liked karan and almost fixed that marriage . But karan spoke to Tanya and she backed out


What if right after this ansh somehow pressurized karan that if he's not marrying nandini can't move on and something. So emotionally tortured karan married tanya and she got what she wanted anyway. And what if ansh somehow killed tanya. That can be such a good twist


Or tanya left to unite KN. Karan tanya marriage thing is very easy to explain

I dont think even this will fix the story...Karan was madly in love with Nandini so even if he married Tanya under pressure he wouldn't consummate his marriage. In S1 he did after Tulsi asked him to and after almost 3 yrs when Doctors confirmed Nandini wud be never be out of coma. So I am sticking to the theory that he married Tanya way before Nandini even came to SN.

The_Best thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

If bhoomi doesn't exist then technically Tanya and Karan are not married at all. The sole reason Karan married Tanya was because of Bhumi. Also, I dont really agree with the idea that Karan cheated on nandini and had Parth with Tanya. That just doesn't fir his character - He would never cheat on Nandini or go against Tulsi's sanskaar. Even in S1 the only reason he completely accepted Tanya and consummated his marriage with her was because Tulsi asked him to just accept Tanya. I mean I have lot of issues with this entire track all together where Karan marries Tanya coz of bhumi and consummates his marriage coz of Tulsi and that too after almost 3 yrs...but this topic is for a later discussion...however coming back to Karan and his character - he was madly in love with Nandini and wud never cheat on her. Which is why I feel in S2 tanya might either be his first wife or someone he had parth with out of wedlock before Nandini came into picture. And considering Tulsi knows abt Tanya and since makers have changed a lot in S2 math just doesn't add up to say Karan had EMA and his character literally is not sketched in that way though

Except he didn’t marry Tanya in S1. That was not a real marriage. That was an invalid marriage. And he already cheated on Nandini with Tanya in S1 since Nandini was his wife and bigamy is not legal in India. He committed a crime. Tulsi telling him to go sleep with Tanya doesn’t change the fact the fact that he was married to Nandini and he cheated on her
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

Do you think Nandini abandoned her own kid? I am not sure if that is the path makers wanna take. Didn't karan in S1 assured nandini he wud be father of the kid born out of that assault when she went to abort the baby? did makers replace bhumi with this riyansh? Also savita was so much in love with Ansh's unborn kid...how come makers will justify the track if this rio turns out to be nandini's son?

I think they might show this exact thing.

When Nandini first found out she was pregnant she asked Tulsi what do I do. Tulsi has no clue what to say and Karan is mum as well. No one except Savita is happy with the news of her pregnancy.


Nandini was even willing to undergo an abortion and it’s only when Karan finds out that her life is at risk because medically she’s not fit enough that he intervenes and stops her. She was at risk of dying and that’s what prompts Karan to step up and say that she can have the child and he will accept that child as his own as it’s her flesh and blood.

Karan himself didn’t just happily accept the child instantly. It took him being scared of losing Nandini to accept her pregnancy. Later when she went into coma, he was avoiding Bhoomi like the plague. It was again him being questioned by Tulsi regarding his own promises to Nandini and the obligation to an innocent child that he finally accepted to father Bhoomi too and spoiled her rotten.

They’re probably gonna show Nandini had the child because she was unable to undergo an abortion owing to the risk of death that no sane and legit doctor was willing to take given it could cost them their career, license and life for good. But she left the child at some orphanage for adoption and somehow Karan was always tracking her. He couldn’t make her change her mind about keeping the child and raising him as ultimately he couldn’t ask her to just move past her trauma like it’s NBD.

Maybe they can show Nandini had postpartum depression by merely being around the child and she got suicidal or something. To make sure Nandini didn’t harm herself or worse, Karan somehow managed to convince everyone that her child had died.

In both scenarios, Karan takes responsibility for the child and decides to raise him as his own as he can’t bring himself to just walk out and abandon a child for no fault of theirs. He has lived through that - Mihir abandoning and rejecting him throughout his childhood, he couldn’t do that to any child even when it was Ansh’s; especially when he carries Nandini’s blood too and is as much a part of her as Samaira and Raunak are.

They would have to shoehorn in how Parth happened here, changing the backstory of Karan and Tanya’s marriage entirely. Probably it maybe shown that Karan married Tanya before Nandini to convince her that he was in love with Tanya so she could marry Ansh as Tulsi wanted. Ansh had tried to convince everyone soon after marriage that Nandini was pregnant; of course she wasn’t. But the news causes one thing to lead to another and Tanya really does get pregnant.

Later it’s revealed that she was hand in glove with Ansh all along to separate Karan and Nandini from day one. Karan divorces her and gets custody of their son or she ends up dying while having Parth. Eventually when Karan marries Nandini, he’s a single dad and she accepts Parth as her own son.

Karan can’t bring himself to abandon a child of Nandini’s when she chose to mother his son born to another woman.

Eventually, he ends up connecting with Niyati who may have been an old friend or classmate or something. Basically someone he felt was safe, genuine and nice enough to raise a child who was someone else’s as their own. And ever since he’s been living a double life, where one side of his family/life has finally caught up with the other. The real fireworks happen when both collide and explode in his face.


Edited by EkPaheli - 10 hours ago
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: Zoya56

ATP I am just pitying Amar 😭😭. cheque ke liye kya kya karna pad raha hai smiley18

He’s chill.

He would play Baa’s grandpa if he was paid well enough in this economy when people don’t get jobs easily especially in this industry.

EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: SaHi_Fan

Its weird that they brought Akashdeep back as the son, if he was used for a flashback scene.

I wonder if they would show him having some disease that aged him, something logical.

Logic has nothing to do with ITV.

The_Best thumbnail
Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: FlauntPessimism

it proves Ekta hates Karan Nandani fans the most...

No other fandom would have had this heartbreak

Ekta loves Karan Nandini fans the most. It’s why they were given so much importance despite being a supporting/parallel couple. It’s why Karan was whitewashed and instead called a mahaan despite him cheating his wife, sleeping with his mistress and having a child. They didn’t even leave their fl to whitewash Karan
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: Me_Harini

I think he is not Niyati's but nandini's son as Ekpaheli mentioned.

He nowhere looks like 26 yrs old...infact he looks older than his onscreen grandma Tulsi...how did Ekta even think to cast him as 26 yr old...moreover Niyati looks like his granddaughter smiley24

Ekta knows shock value works more than anything. If the reception is bad he may be replaced by a plastic surgery but I doubt it will happen.

Me_Harini thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: The_Best

We haven’t been told he married Tanya this season. So bhoomi doesn’t matter. What we are told is that Parth is Tanya and Karan’s child and since they haven’t negated the S1 story about Karan Tanya being in illegal marriage, so it’s still following S1 just as it’s following S1 story for Gautam Damini despite the fact that their one child doesn’t exist this season and for others as well

Even if we go by this theory it doesn't add up coz in S1 he marries Tanya just for sake of Bhumi. So if Bhumi is not in S2 how can we say he just married Tanya all of a sudden ?. In S1 he backed out from marriage multiple times and apparantly married just bcoz of bhumi and since S2 negates existence of bhumi it also negates Karan marrying tanya while Nandini is in coma. He was never a cheater - that was his character sketch in S1 and he never had EMA. His marriage was illegal in S1 - I agree but he never intended to cheat Nandini. He moved on with Tanya coz Tulsi asked him to and moreover doctors confirm she wud never wake up. Doctors had given up on her and he kept her on life support. I dont even mind Karan moving on with Tanya coz it was almost 3 yrs and I suppose ppl somewhat require a partner and he was seeking that partnership in Tanya. But calling his relationship with Tanya as cheating or EMA is something I dont agree with...Lawfully yes his marriage was Illegal but circumstances were way too different...his intensions were never wrong and with that I feel even in S2 his characteristics are retained and that is the sole reason I am sticking with theory of Tanya being Karan's first wife in S2

FlauntPessimism thumbnail
Posted: 11 hours ago

Originally posted by: The_Best

We haven’t been told he married Tanya this season. So bhoomi doesn’t matter. What we are told is that Parth is Tanya and Karan’s child and since they haven’t negated the S1 story about Karan Tanya being in illegal marriage, so it’s still following S1 just as it’s following S1 story for Gautam Damini despite the fact that their one child doesn’t exist this season and for others as well

That in itself shows that this story changed.

Karan might not have married Tanya.as we haven't been told this season. The main reason Bhoomi is missing, the S1 illegal marriage of Karan Tanya is negated here. There is no reason for that marriage to have had happened

About when Karan had Parth from Tanya, we have no clue if it was before or after his marriage with Nandani since Parth is much elder to Samaira and Ronak. Samaira is still a teen while Parth was an adult 6 years back.

Their relationship or Parth could have very well happened before Karan Nandani marriage..

So for sure, S1 story of Karan Tanya illegal marriage doesn't hold here

Related Topics

Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2 thumbnail

Posted by: Armu4eva · 21 days ago

Hello folks Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread for Kyunki Saas bhi kabhi bahu thi 2. Please keep these Rules in mind while posting. Please...

Expand ▼
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2 thumbnail

Posted by: Armu4eva · 1 months ago

Hello folks Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread for Kyunki Saas bhi kabhi bahu thi 2. Please keep these Rules in mind while posting. Please...

Expand ▼
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2 thumbnail

Posted by: Armu4eva · 1 months ago

Hello folks Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread for Kyunki Saas bhi kabhi bahu thi 2. Please keep these Rules in mind while posting. Please...

Expand ▼
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2 thumbnail

Posted by: Armu4eva · 1 months ago

Hello folks Welcome to the Episode Discussion Thread for Kyunki Saas bhi kabhi bahu thi 2. Please keep these Rules in mind while posting. Please...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".